rima thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
There are directors and directors and more directors.
But only one Guru Dutt, One James Cameron, One Hitchcok and one Raju Hirani..and One Lalit Mohan for IPK
Some people have the flair to bring out the best in their actors
They have the ability to create setting, decide camera angles and lighting and scene direction, such that it libgers in our heart and makes the difference.
Whatever one says passion towards one work shows
Aamir Khan is known to interfere in all his scripts...something which shows in his movies.
LM had a similar flair to move the story as per the creative need.
No one can deny that till he was there ...till Feb to be precise we got the best of IPK.
This is not to say Arshad is a bad director. Some people have a flair for special scenes and moment. Arshad perhaps excelled in some scenes. But no doubt to have magic everyday we need a person with a midaas touch
Now here is an analysis by Maverick (who comments on my posts and makes posts too) on why Lalit Mohan mattered:
(I liked this comment so much I saved it and bombarded 4 lions with this)
The episode being discussed is the hug Arnav and Khushi share during kidnap when Khushi first finds him.

About the director

I watched today's episode -- it is nice -- but here are a few things when I was complaining about the direction. I will analyze one episode and tell you how today's epi would have looked had Lalit Directed it.

The example I take is the "mehendi start" day -- it is the day after she wins the Sangeet Competition with his help. First, he started with keeping her away from the rest of the Gupta Bunch -- she followed them and was eating her fav Jalebi -- see he got us to think that she is already worried about the stuff he did to her the night before -- specifically the line "Tumhare Isharon Pe Na sahi, tumhare saath to nacha hain. Thanks Nahin bologi" -- if you picked up on his voice there -- there was a specific change. You will observe the same change in voice (directors tell their actors what they need from them and good ones deliver!!) -- On the first song when he goes to her and tells her "lagta hain mere bina tumhara koi kaam hi nahin banta" -- he wasnt yelling -- he was very soft. This was all reflected beautifully when she walks into through that door (back to present time on Mehendi day) -- arranged in such a way that he answers the door. Then there is the "Hi" -- listen closely to the voice -- I have had this happen to me before -- when you are actually intoxicated your voice changes -- He is intoxicated -- she is confused. His "Hi" is soft! This is direction.

Then he lets her in, calls her from behind -- Lalith lets this scene linger -- Brilliant because when there are good moments, as humans we want them to last -- that is the only way we can "feel" them -- slam bam doesnt work here -- slow does it better to set the mood!!! Then the way Khushi acts is so much Khushi like. In these scenes you will see that the lighting is so special -- the lights are all "BRIGHT" and it is all "White/Pearl" lighting to make it look bright. She looked bright and radiant.

So another point on the way he made people look. I dont think the Barun Droolers may have noticed this but as a director Lalith paid special attention to this and you can see it in them

1. Barun smiles a lot more from the start of the Sangeet Program -- in his mind all the doubts are slowly vanishing -- she is his lady love. -- clearly shown in his face -- it goes from bright to beaming.

2. Notice that on the Mehendi day, his face has a lot more "GLOW" added to it -- "we glow when we are in love" -- you will see that in our Sanaya as well! She started glowing super bright from the day of the Sangeet.

Continuing on, when she confronts him pool side, Lalith decided to keep it bright and she was pondering/talking to herself etc -- he kept that "glow in both of them". In the scene where he is standing behind her when she is all concerned about him -- he is no longer barking -- he is happy to let her yell -- Honestly when a girl I am in love with yells at me or hits me, I enjoy it immensely -- this is a guy thing -- it shows.

From then on, Barun's facial expressions are more happy and glowing than "I hate this world, yeh Duniya itni bedard hain" type! So is she. All the way from Episode 147 to 185 and then picking up after the wedding, Khushi looked her VERY BEST. She was radiant, she was beaming, she was glowing, her smile was like a 1000-watt bulb, her lines and her hesitation etc were so cool!

The main points:

Lalith developed the story and let it slowly grow with the characters -- people got better as the story progressed. She got more and more beautiful -- see there is a symbolism in this -- as we see the beauty in people they become more good looking -- it is a fact that the ones we love are always the most beautiful ones for us.

He moved from being an "Ass" to being in love -- he realized that he was in wrong with Lavanya all by himself -- he started understanding how to treat people. He fell in love and got nicer -- this is the point -- you dont have to be a flowery guy to be a nice to your loved ones -- you can always have a face for your people and one for the outside world.

In direction -- he let every single important moment LINGER long enough to have an impact. He brought and let people go from scenes with this in mind.

Finally, if he had directed the episode today, I think the impact would have been entirely different.

First off, I dont think both of them would have looked the way they did -- See there was attention to detail in Barun's clothing as well -- He made him wear a vest in Delhi!!!! The reason is simple -- Barun is skinny -- To make him look majestic to go with the character he had to add bulk -- so he added layers -- here Barun is wearing a lose shirt -- well the skinny little guy shows!!! By the way, if you notice through the show when Lalith was directing Barun always wore layers -- good for skinny guys to show bulk. he never let him wear a pyjama shirt!

Sanaya was good today because of her natural talent but the director did not help any.

If Lalith had done this -- he would have made their "hug" the highlight by showing lingering doubts and slow movements -- he would have kept Barun strong but soft -- this is what he did during Mehendi and also Haldi -- by the way on Haldi day Sanaya was out of this world beautiful. Barun looked completely out of place. Then before the hug, he would have showed her hesitate and twitch -- I dont know if you guys noticed -- the most lovable thing about Khushi was her "shifting in place" -- if you notice she is never still -- she is frigidity, shifty, moving and mumbling in Barun's presence -- showing the effect he has on her -- this is the first time they are free after he says "I love you" -- there would have been so many things going through her head -- Lalith would have made us feel those instead of just rushing her to run and hug -- run of the mill romantic movie style!!!!. She does that when she is nervous. This is her first real close hug with the guy -- you need to make people realize that -- let the scene linger a bit -- show her shifting in place, moving slowly and then suddenly gain momentum to hug him -- he could have shown similar stuff in Barun's face as well.

Honestly, Lalith would have hit this out of the park!

Now that I really understand what ruined the show I will write a long note for the "MORON of the Decade -- Gul" in my next post.

Maverick hope you are reading this post buddy. The morons just got Lalit back (or so I believe)
guys do comment on Lalit Mohan's Facebook to express your happiness if possible
Edited by rima - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

314

Views

19k

Users

77

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

..Anannya.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Awesome post rima di! we arshians finally did it! a special thanks obviously goes to u di for ur petition! now we can have our OLD IPKKND back..! i'm really happy! one of the best day in my life! 😳
And whatever Maverick said is so truee! agree a lot! LM really matters, matters to IPK, matters to actors, matters to us fans..! Such a magician he is..!⭐️
Yeah i'm ready to fall in love with IPK once again!!😊
hugs to all arshians🤗
Edited by anannya_arshi - 13 years ago
sow2428 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
⭐️Rima, you did an awesome job by writing it out to starplus and collecting the IF comments and likes.Your efforts have not gone wasted.Now with immediate effect we have got Lalith Mohan bvack.
Wish him good luck for his 2nd innings in IPk and fingers crossed our show becomes no.1,

May under his care and guidance the show reaches out to more audience and enthrall them with the performance of the actors.Hope the Cvs work together with him and bring really interesting tracks and etch the characters, esp. kushi better in the upcoming episodes.

It's Sanaya's Bday and lalith is on sets tomorrow.2 things to rejoice for all the fans of IPk.😊

Another Thankyou for your post today.Lovely writing and keep up the great work Rima !!👏
Edited by sow2428 - 13 years ago
OmNaMaSteOm thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Alibaba im glad LM is back & Maverick did a great job with the analysis & i cant add anything to it.

Im just overwhelmed that our show has been given to the right hands & now as the episodes & days passes IPK wont seem like DKS & we wont regret our addiction & dedication to the show any longer.

Edited by Harshitha - 13 years ago
Roslyn1991 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Agree with you.
After all a story directed good gives result good.
Without Lalit mohan IPK is nothing.
He always opens a loophole in one week and closes them in the next or next after next week but keeps in mind to close them surely and with a neat ending.
Feeling to dance now that Lalit Mohan is back.
Hey Rima finally our petition has worked.
Nice post by the way.
Edited by Rozyln - 13 years ago
AmazingAmy thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Rima...wonderful post! I associate everything positive about IPK with LM because he reminds me of when the show used to be amazing.

He said tomorrow is his first shot after 7 months...so last time he shot for it was February. Coincidentally, that's when the show started going downhill. The nail in the coffin was the Anjali miscarriage. Maybe the 2.3 TRPs was a blessing in disguise since it gave the PH a much-needed reality check, now the focus is immediately back on Arnav and Khushi and the man who made them shine, LM is back.

I think Arnav's apology to Khushi in the bedroom would have had a much bigger impact if LM was directing it. It was supposed to be a vital scene as we were waiting for that apology for a year. But none of us felt the connection because it was rushed and treated as just another scene. LM brings out the best, in terms of intensity and emotions, in ASR. I remember that episode where he ran after the ambulance and thought he lost Khushi...I've lost count of how many times I have watched that amazing episode.

Since February, the most glaring flaw in this show for me has been the degradation of Khushi's character with comedy and nonsensical scenes. LM understands Khushi better than anyone else. He can portray her to us in a way where we can relate to her and feel for her. He actually focused on her feelings. He gave us beautiful monologues, flashback scenes, etc to help us understand her side. That has been missing BADLY for months now, as the story has become very one sided...we either get Arnav or Anjali's side but never any clarity from Khushi's side.

He can show balance, growth and depth in her character. Most of the blame goes to the writers but LM proved in the first 6 months that he can make up for the writers incompetency.

P.S. He also paid attention to making our lead pair look GOOD, which added to the overall quality of the show.
Edited by AyeReKhushi - 13 years ago
Edella17 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Res - Edited

Well Said Rima , '


His magic has not gone unnoticed... He has delivered IPKKND episodes superbly and has left all of us breathless... He is back to steal our breath and make us drool more and more...

Tomorrow , He will steal my breath again like he did 7 Months ago...I am so glad to see the Midas touch of LM on the screens of IPK again 😳
Edited by Edella17 - 13 years ago
Barundeewani19 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Wow!! Awesome post and anaylsis by Maverick.. I had missed the great analysis.. Looking forward fr his direction epi😳
Edited by Barundeewani19 - 13 years ago
premparbat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Hi Rima,

I think the combination of Lalit and Arshad matter as they have been there since the start.

Lalit has been there much longer and has been part of the character sketch since the start and has a big part in their formation. On the other handi think Arshad really gets the romance right so inmy opinion both are essential.

Also I get the feeling the LM was more disciplined in his execution as I did not see so many loopholes and bloopers as I see now . Even simple things as a wrong hand cupping the face is so evident. It takes away from the quality of the product.

Between Arshad and aman it was so clear who directed coz. I think aman let the characters loose. Example the date episode you could see Barun and it was not tight at all.

What I am hoping that he will bring back a tighter execution of the screenplay. I remember one interview by Barun in the episode where he gets to know about Khushi,s engagement and the ring drops from his hand. Barun said that Lalitmade him do the take 17 times as he was not happy with the expressions and wanted diff angles...and you know how beautiful that episode was..

Maybe LM is overrated and he may not be able to do much to TRPS but my hope is that he can bring back the intensity guide the story bait and challenge the actors . Would like him to balance others characters as well like Payash, mami , the Guptas...all ere needed unlike a unbalance of Shyam and Anjali and NK who I like... He should get a new intensity in the coming days where it is going to be tough for Arnav and Khushi.

Hoping for the best and keeping fingers crossed. All the best to the IPK team. We have stuck to it for over a year now and we have been very unforgiving... Now is the chance for the ph to prove thematic we have. Shown.

And thanks for the petition...I believe in saying what you have to and take that step to be heard which you have done Rima.

Take care

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Sapnokiduniya · 2 months ago

I am trying to post my OS here and its giving me PHONE NOT ALLOWED error I haven't specified any phone number and I am posting this via laptop....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".