Geet - Now I Cannot Relate To

nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Everyone is entitled to have a opinion, sharing mine not putting it up for a 'debate' or 'contest'.
If you disagree please refrain from commenting.


Geet - Now I Cannot Relate To.


Geet the woman of today.
A phoenix that rose from its own ashes time and again.
An inspiration to many who related to her plight & every fight to begin with.



As a viewer and as a woman Geet Hui Sabsey Parayi appealed to me not coz of any actor to begin with.
It had me waiting since the promo promised to give us glimpse into the life of this innocent girl who is to be wedded far from home & her fears, hopes & anticipation were hinted clearly as was the alarm of her future in this bond.


As her journey began so did mine as a viewer who felt connected to her both as a girl & as an individual.

There were moments I felt one with her & lately have had moments I found her a total stranger.


'The only constant thing is change.'

Yes I know nothing is static.
People change as their environment, their situation & circumstances change.
Experience & emotions we exposed to change us & so do people who cross our life & more the ones who stop in our life, they change us.


But within this change & growth one thing that does not change is who we are, our soul holds our true self to us always.
Just like the roots holding to ground when branches aspire to touch the sky.


*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who punished her family for having wronged her, who seeked justice not alone for herself but as a lesson for those who thought woman are weak & can be treated as flesh or rag.

She lost her family in this quest, a big loss yet that did not stop her.


But I cannot relate to this woman who forgives Dev in name of 'moving on'.

She had moved on long back.

Had come out from the shadows of her dark past when she broke away from her family.

When she loved Maan.

When she told him about her being pregnant.

When she learnt Dev is Maan's brother.

When she married Maan

When she had her miscarriage & when she wanted to start her family with Maan.


*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who could not voice her love for Maan, nor accept his love coz she considered herself as tainted as Dev had touched her.

She called herself not pure anymore.


But I cannot relate to the woman who with a smile let her sinner touch her with the same hands those once had violated her.
I could not relate to the woman who showed respect by doing the 'tikkaa' of the same devil who her husband hated to the core for having ruined her life.


She knew Maan did not know the truth & without him accepting Dev as family, the family ties that were tore of coz of her she acknowledged him all on her own.



*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who when wanted to explain to Maan the whole truth about her pregnancy had run after him, dared to lock him in a room & make him hear her since she felt she owed it to him.

But I cannot relate to the Geet who did not wait for Maan or reach out to him to tell him the truth, hear him or be heard.

Only walked away leaving others to explain what was but only theirs to say & understand.


She had earlier refused to let go of the love that has come her way without putting up a fight & now her marriage did not matter to her but those few words did that Maan said only coz he was unaware of the whole truth that she did not tell him of.


*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman in love who having seen the broken frame of the man's picture who she felt binded to by an unknown force, by destiny.

Overcome by concern for his well being had rushed with the need to see him once to sooth her soul to know that he is fine.

But I cannot relate to the Geet who seeing the broken frame of her husband's picture frame dropped tears of silent prayer but dint feel the need to call him, hear him once for herself to know that he is fine.

Neither could I relate to the woman who is so much engrossed in self pity that has not for once has thought of the well being of her man & her family knowing that like her they too will be suffering.


*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who after having heard from Adi that Rasikha has filed a case on Maan rushed to him to tell her that she is there for him & wont leave him alone not oly coz he had invited trouble for her sake but because she cared.

But I cannot relate to this woman who having seeing her man humble himself to her anger & to appease her, to be with her he is living a life of a servant at her relatives place.

She saw her brothers humiliate the man who never let anyone not even his own family ever say a rude word to her.

She saw it, cried.

She knew it wasn't easy for him to swallow the humiliation but he did, only for her, them.

Yet she could get to sleep in peace when he lay awake concerned for her. No I don't relate to her



*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who was filled with love & pride for the man who said 'Infront of me no one can say anything bad to you'.

Driven with this love she too had stopped Rasika from raising her voice against Maan & had dared her.

But I cannot relate to the woman, a wife who let her family bad mouthed her husband & instead of stopping them or herself reflecting what Maan is to her stood there listening to them.

The bride who shivered in fear at her mandap that her Darji will separate her from her Maan, acknowledged Beeji's order to never allow her to see him.

Wife who lets all question her husband's principles.

Wife who is letting everyone walk on her husband's self respect but not let go of her stubbornness .
No I don't relate to her.



*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who read her man's silence.

She knew his silence speak more than words could do justice to & also knew as was his possessiveness, his trust , his fear , his love ; so was his anger only driven by his heart that only did beat for her.


But I cannot relate to the woman did not feel the pain, the hurt in the anger of this man who did not blink once before jumping in between her & the bullet that was meant for her.

'I hate you Geet' when he had said this to her moved by the hidden pain in his raging fury she had reached to him & did not allow him to drift away from her & now her own hurt was so consuming that his shattered being never appeared to her sight.



*****


Geet I felt connected to was the woman who had not given up Dev when he had after a night of pleasure had left her at airport drugged, crying, scared,unprotected, in trauma..unconscious.

Yet she refused to give up on the sacred bond of matrimony, on her husband of one night.

She fought with herself , with her family that she cannot let go of her marriage, she wanted to hear Dev's reason to have abandoned her, to tell him she cared for him.

She did all she could to keep her marriage.


But I cannot relate to the woman who walked out of her true marriage.
Walked away from the man who protected her, her tears have always scorched his soul, her happiness he holds above everything else, her self respect above his own pride.

She walked out of her marriage, leaving her love , her man & her home for few rude words alone.

Yes the one we love & trust their words hurt us the most but don't their pain affect us first too.

But still has not felt his pain, his fear that caused his emotional outburst.


Instead of feeling his pain, confronting him with her own hurt she walked away from him for forever. And now who refuses to feel for his pain of going through all this humiliation. No I cannot relate to this woman.


*****


Where is the Geet who thought about Maan before herself, who accepted him with all his anger as he did with her past, who knew every action of Maan is just for her.

Where is the Geet who had promised Maan she wont let anyone or anything come between them & now her one decision shook the very foundation of her relationship, of her love.
Now its people like Darji who is to decide 'their' fate, the future of their relationship.

No I fail to relate to this Geet, to connect to her both as an woman & as an viewer.



Nandita.
Edited by nanditasingh - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

89

Views

6.2k

Users

25

Likes

275

Frequent Posters

Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

Geet the character is butchered so mercilessly brutally by GHSP creators there is nothing I can relate to her. Dont know what she is............but not the GEET I loved...........not the GEET I looked for..........not the GEET I admired.........not the GEET I was proud of................not the GEET I want to be ever in my life.............. not the GEET I would like any NRI marriage victim to follow...............

..

First she forgive Dev he rapist for Maan why not than she tried to forgive than Maan for Maan. ...IF she really wanted a new life and wanted move on and for it applied that larger than life concept of forgive and forget to her own rapist for it. Why she dint do same ultimate sacrifice for MSK....Is it forgiving rapist is easier than forgiving your own husband who saved yout life trillion times and was there through your life thick and thin.. Why she didn't forgive him and forget him better only for Maan sake...Or is it Maan sake forgiveness work for Dev the rapist not him . After all raping self respect if manage to deserve forgiveness, a statement on self respect definitely earn forgiveness right there. ?

WHY the girl who is doing all this for MSK sake and their new life. Took such big step of forgiving rapist for new life'didn't thought of twice of forgiving her own husband. I don't know about others but for me rape is bigger crime than anything on this earth even more than murder. Two evil darjee and Dev jee achieved forgiveness so easily evn in post MC depression syndrome due to which she is unable to forgive Maan for questioning her self respect. Sleeping with wife..on pretext of false marriage was rape itself which took everything from her life...her childhood ...her dreams.....her family and her life.....from 18 year old girl ......she was changed to....18 year pregnant women in span on 1 month.....from a cute chirpy girl......she was unwed mother fighting alone for her own life...her baby ....All because of ....Dev and his sins and his crime...

And Darjee who tried to kill her twice and always treated her like dirt'during her childhood'.giving . Irony was todays...Darjee dailgue....You suffer when your kid suffer.........where was your suffering.........when you suffocated her in store room to save ur reputation when she want to fight agsint Dev............where was your suffering......when you send entire town to kill inncent girl.........fighting for life from own loved ones..............

She survived everything ......every fight .......to save her child ....save her life....start new life afresh...be independent ....and than fight against Dev and NT...all because of one Man ..its Maan who was there ....with her......every second when noone was there with her'not even her new found family..............A guy who did so much doesn't deserve forgiveness....Why not she think of forgiving MSK for same new life for which you give pardon to your own rapist.?

If forgiving rapist is divine or forgiving your husband will me more diviner then.If raping your self respect is forgivable than question on self respect should be forgiven much easily.

A guy like Maan who did so much doesn't deserve forgiveness....for one statement on self respect..because if he was her strong pillar.....and Dev and Darji were none....so they can get away with crime sin like Rape.or murder attempt...........So in that sense we are preaching a new theory that you should not do anything selflessly for others........and than other will expect you to be perfect like GOD when you are human being at end of day...............and .same other will not forgive small mistake from you as its not expected from GOD and will forgive sin from other as they were from human being...MAAN seriously did big mistake by loving you selflessly unconditionally''....................And what about her post MC depression syndrome post MC depression syndrome.....which work situationaly......as this syndrome has no effect on forgiving culpirt and rather playing holi with your rapist..............as far as I know.........in depression..........time everything worst in your life take over your brain..........you reactions are extreme....so if go by strong clinical symptoms a victim cant even bear his rapist or murder around her'..I agree closed one bear most burnt but not only closed one ..........all around you..suffer because of your behaviour.....But her depression is special..........she is normal all around even DEV and Dadaji............and his MC syndrome work only agsint MAAN...........New depression symtom .........you forgive one and give attitude to other..........in depression I heard and saw first time...........

If not this for her fake pseudo self respect is ....she is letting MSK self respect tarnished to death......Everyone is insulting him questioning his principles nor she stood for Maan once nor she stopped anyone to stop their crap............First check your principles before questioning other...........A wife abuser .........a murder who killed you almost questioning THE MAAN SINGH KHURANA PRINCIPLES............who's principle ...made you realize your self respect at first place in HP ...who fought for your self respect ( during rasika or restaurant manager time ) more than you...........But WHAT kept you quiet mum when everyone was insulting him questioning him........downgrading his self respect.............IS your ego or pseudo self respect is bigger than his existence or his support in your life........than being wife you allowed your relatives to insult your own husband..................in this way and still you managed to not utter one word for him ..........Why you were quiet and not utter single world to show your faith in his principles.......you dont believe in his principles for which he fought with Brij ti save your life twice and for which he broke all ties with Dev for you.....who taught you at first place how to stand for your self respect and right......Seriously you dont belive in his principles...

IF yes than only GOD knows what principles you follow......you allow everyone on this earth to insult him......be it wife abuser or murder...........you forgive every criminal so easily and what they did to you and ....................Forget what Maan did for you and against those whom you chose to forgive without punishment to attain ultimate Nirvana.........HOPE you achieved that........and these infinite insults are quite boost to your self respect...

.So in future we should expect more and more insult of your stupid husband who loved you selflessly

Special Mention to creative's

Creative's you have made Geet character a shear torture her tears look fake....her concern for MAAN look fake.........her self respect look fake.................only her arrogance .......attitude.......... ego look real......


__________________

Edited by kuls11 - 14 years ago
saanjh11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
geet has become totally stranger nowadays me watching her now days getting irritated hearing same dialogues and same watching maan getting insulted with teary eyes .cv get ur facts right hearing daarji or seeing dev the way u r portraying has nothing to do with us as we don't care ,main lead has been made cameos nowadays and we sit total half an hour just to have glimpse pf maneet who gonna say it is same ghsp she is same geet and he is same maan ,ask me every time i see balwant singh me remember maan's first entry in his office and my heart bows down to find cv 's feet .
are cv too blind and this much insensitive that for carrying the story further they have lost the real magic that created maan n geet .now what ever u do how will we forget our journey from real deep love to this shallowness that we r watching daily
Shweta13 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Geet I felt connected to was the woman who had not given up Dev when he had after a night of pleasure had left her at airport drugged, crying, scared,unprotected, in trauma..unconscious.

Yet she refused to give up on the sacred bond of matrimony, on her husband of one night.

She fought with herself , with her family that she cannot let go of her marriage, she wanted to hear Dev's reason to have abandoned her, to tell him she cared for him.

She did all she could to keep her marriage.

But I cannot relate to the woman who walked out of her true marriage.
Walked away from the man who protected her, her tears have always scorched his soul, her happiness he holds above everything else, her self respect above his own pride.

She walked out of her marriage, leaving her love , her man & her home for few rude words alone.

Yes the one we love & trust their words hurt us the most but don't their pain affect us first too.

But still has not felt his pain, his fear that caused his emotional outburst.


Instead of feeling his pain, confronting him with her own hurt she walked away from him for forever. And now who refuses to feel for his pain of going through all this humiliation. No I cannot relate to this woman.

This is so APT, Nandita I remember i justified Geet in my PM to you and at that point of time i do agree that she did forgave her sinner and good to move on but really today as a woman I will never take questions on my husbands self respect for any damn thing from others, no matter how much I am angry with him or whatsoever....... i really felt like doing something to geet to make her realize what is she doing and whom she is depending on..... After the behne de song and jhumka scene , maan told her this , no matter how much differences we have but infront of other i will never be against you , no doubt they had differences and MUs later on and somewhere maan was also at fault by not clearing them but he repented , regretted and what not , made things right back on track but now She is taking it too far to be stretched ...... I will not bash her but CV's have completely ruined her character and I also cannot relate toooo.....
Every Husband and wife fights at soe point and say harsh things to each other in anger but doesnt divorce the relation on it ..... she did leave the house at tha point of time as she coudnt control or had enough strengh to be with him but what now .....missing him , caring for him only when he is humilated, not able to see his love only if she sees it but doesnt react emotionally...... actually no words left to describe her behavior now.
CV's are not even giving us a glimpse of her self talk of her realization of loosing maan, her realization of him being there for her, her feeling of love and thinking whether i should forgive him or not....her disagreement with her family.... nyting.
it seems weird now.
nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#5


@ Kul -
LOVED IT Kul...👏
Yes she is lost for me ....

MC syndrome..!!!!

I may not hold medical knowledge but being a woman I do know the trauma a mother goes through..rather a couple. But I blame the creatives for not showing it effectively & what shown only made it seem that her trauma was only for Maan to see.
Maan tried his best to hold on to her but she 'cocooned' in her 'self' pity/grief not for once reached out to him, feel his pain.... I still remember his shattering when he said to Geet for 'our Baby's sake' lets go to the Doctor & Geet said I'm fine & 'my Baby is fine'.
When she apologized he understood her having been left all by herself has affected her to hold on to 'self'. He assured her its no more I or U now but We.

Yet when the Baby was gone it was only her grief that she was occupied with. Yes she is mother but does a father love his child any less.....if she was holding the child in her womb...Maan was holding it in his heart, he had no 'self' ties with the Baby but to him it was his, theirs.

In a mutual bond the man who is ur companion not alone in life but every fight how is he not included in the major decision of your life. He was only to be informed..! not counted for his emotions & opinion about it. The man who broke his ties with his kin only for u how can u go ahead & acknowledge that kin when he himself is absent there. Where is 'WE' here?


And Self respect ..well I plead to stop this mockery in the name of a 'womans self respect'.

What is Geet's interpretation of Self respect?

Something that gets only hurt when 'questioned' by her husband but not while she allowed her rapist to touch her, not while she lets any & everybody act as crutch to her, not when she is living as house guest at a relatives place, not when all around her take control of her life, not when her 'mayka' people bad mouth her husband, not when she sees her husband grovel, not when he is humiliated...not when people question his principles ...Never in all these occasions her self respect is hurt as a woman, as a WIFE !!!!!!!!




nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sanjh1234

geet has become totally stranger nowadays me watching her now days getting irritated hearing same dialogues and same watching maan getting insulted with teary eyes .cv get ur facts right hearing daarji or seeing dev the way u r portraying has nothing to do with us as we don't care ,main lead has been made cameos nowadays and we sit total half an hour just to have glimpse pf maneet who gonna say it is same ghsp she is same geet and he is same maan ,ask me every time i see balwant singh me remember maan's first entry in his office and my heart bows down to find cv 's feet .

are cv too blind and this much insensitive that for carrying the story further they have lost the real magic that created maan n geet .now what ever u do how will we forget our journey from real deep love to this shallowness that we r watching daily




The PH pleads to give them a chance & take this as a 'New story' is the old story dead! If not then why are the characters becoming so inconsistent & magic..well at least cvs made me believe magic indeed is illusion hence disappears..it did.
Ninelives thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
Nandu..i have no words...i second each and every word...the essence of what was shown today exceptionally put by U....
I am saddened by the upsetting scenario as u all are aware....hope better sense prevails and we get our GHSP back...asap...waiting for it for so long....
nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Shweta13



This is so APT, Nandita I remember i justified Geet in my PM to you and at that point of time i do agree that she did forgave her sinner and good to move on but really today as a woman I will never take questions on my husbands self respect for any damn thing from others, no matter how much I am angry with him or whatsoever....... i really felt like doing something to geet to make her realize what is she doing and whom she is depending on..... After the behne de song and jhumka scene , maan told her this , no matter how much differences we have but infront of other i will never be against you , no doubt they had differences and MUs later on and somewhere maan was also at fault by not clearing them but he repented , regretted and what not , made things right back on track but now She is taking it too far to be stretched ...... I will not bash her but CV's have completely ruined her character and I also cannot relate toooo.....

Every Husband and wife fights at soe point and say harsh things to each other in anger but doesnt divorce the relation on it ..... she did leave the house at tha point of time as she coudnt control or had enough strengh to be with him but what now .....missing him , caring for him only when he is humilated, not able to see his love only if she sees it but doesnt react emotionally...... actually no words left to describe her behavior now.
CV's are not even giving us a glimpse of her self talk of her realization of loosing maan, her realization of him being there for her, her feeling of love and thinking whether i should forgive him or not....her disagreement with her family.... nyting.
it seems weird now.




Yes Shweta I remember your pm .. i still do appreciate your gesture ..u dint want to contest my view but wanted to share with me yours...I loved it.

As a woman & as a wife she has failed big time. Where is self respect in her anyways .... it was wouldn't she confront him before walking out..I could if I were in her shoes...isn't that what she had done with her family before she left them....that was strength of a woman not this...
Where is her self respect that does not mind living off as a house guest at a relatives place...
Where is her self respect when she saw her husband humiliated...& instead of reaching him she went to sleep..how could she even get herself to rest he dint rest when he learnt she is hurt...he rushed to reach her, sooth her....dint she feel the need to reach him...
Where is her self respect that stays mum at all bad mouthing her husband..where is it when all are controlling her life..& where is it when someone like Darji has come to decide her & Maan's relations fate....

Its not self respect ..rather never was..it was always about Self only.


nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: maaneetian

Nandu..i have no words...i second each and every word...the essence of what was shown today exceptionally put by U....

I am saddened by the upsetting scenario as u all are aware....hope better sense prevails and we get our GHSP back...asap...waiting for it for so long....



Hope against hope ..is the situation...until she reflects of her own role in the misunderstanding, until she feels that she owed him an explanation, regrets her decision that has brought this day on them....until this done ..she has no hope nor the show
mysterygurl1427 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Sorry, when someone goes under depression, she doesn't have the thought process to even make decisions....here to geet is walking around and talking sanely....and making decisions...there is no depression......if she can sooo stubbornly say that she will not go with maan.....check right there her brain is functioning.....
Nandu brilliant post baby, i agree with you!

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 1 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: heart882 · 1 months ago

Hey Guys! I’m excited to be back after a long break and to dive back into my story. The Prologue is now posted, and Chapter 1 will be coming...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 6 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".