Kurbaan: A Case Study

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

4492

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#61

Originally posted by: rhea_6

Even I was surprised how 90% critics liked Kurbaan.

I mean the usual scenario is that if Normal ppl are crazy about a film then the critics will like it,if people are finding it average then critics will hate it.

BUT,with Kurbaan most people are finding it average yet the critics have loved it.How is that possible?😕

Also,Kurbaan review came in front page of Bombay times and this never happens with any other film.All reviews come in the page 2/3 of the main TOI.Anyway,In the review it was written don't miss this KJO film and the review was unusually long and in detail..., again nothing like the other movie reviews.

I don't think it's possible to buy all the critics but maybe they gave it good ratings as it's a KJO film..

i agree the name is just too big

Quote

4492

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: -bluemoon-
I don't know about others but I don't care if you defend Saifeena on this forum Desu. I have no problems with that. People here weren't even criticising Saifeena but the film, and you took it personally. You reacted and then people followed it up with their own responses. I don't think anyone needs to stop posting their views - positive or negative.

As for Shahid and Deepika not needing defending - maybe you missed that Harman and Vidya interview thread. There was quite a lot of Shahid criticism going on and people were responding to it. (Its another matter that once Vidya clarified that she wasn't talking about Shahid that thread became dead). I don't remember Shahid fans telling people to "move on". Deepika has also been criticised on this forum - but I usually just go and post once or twice and if I have nothing more to say I leave. Yes Shahid and Deepika fans might be here in higher numbers, but it isn't as if no one criticises them. Plenty of people do and have in the past, including you.

I personally don't appreciate being told that I should "move on" from a particular topic because I have a "negative" view.

I AGREEE, AND IT IS TRUE U HAVE said bad things bout shahid in the past, his fans did not react that violently, and u r doing this all because of a movie?? bottom line girl, the audience know wat is it saying, if the audience says the movie is 'crap' it is if it is saying 'its amazing' it is, people like KJO sweat for the audiences and this audience praises and gives a lot of regard in return and when the movie doesn't turn out well u also need to accept criticism, u r way too biased, I AM A HUGE HRITHIK FAN but i know that he has done crap movies, he might've not acted top-notch in sum movies, but look now his body of work is talking for him, his versatality is speaking for him the only person to cover a mentally retarded child, a terrorist, a superhero and an EMPEROR, i stood by him, and i stayed quite when people said he was 'FINISHED' and had this inherit faith that he'll emerge back, and those people who criticised were gobbling up their words!! the fact that u r soooo insecure is not a good SIGN, i have also waited for hrithik movies that have dun crap, people thought they were shit, i accepted, they were no masterpieces

Edited by nkapoor - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

233283

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: ~angelz16~
Because you have done it time and again and it can be irritating but NO ONE says anything because we all know how much you love Saifeena. So thats point one.

Point two isthat was ALSO A MERE STATEMENT. Pure Sarcasm. If you dont like it then you can SKIP IT. Just like I do MANY A TIMES on your posts because I DO KNOW that you are completely in awe of this couple.

1. Kurbaan sucked. Ghisa pita film on 9/11 has been done to death. Time to move on.
2. No, I did not see it. My sister's review and Johar behena as the producer is a big enough turn off for me.
3. With 1 and 2 out of the way, people going gaga over Katrina, Deepika, Shahid, Priyanka, Rani, can also be extremely annoying and pathetic. Nevertheless, lurkers like me and writers like you do tolerate it. Why throw stones at others when you live in a glasshouse?
4. You say what kind of people like Kurbaan? I ask what kind of grownup female uses Selena Gomez as her avatar?
5.Don't like personal insults as much when it comes to us, do we? Well...then don't accuse others of shiz when you can be blamed for the same.

Edited by xetaxeta - 16 years ago

Quote

403365

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#64

Wow all, way to offend each other on a personal level over ghissi pitta actors, be it Saif, Kareena, Shahid, Deepika, Priyanka, Katrina and the rest. Just highlights so much more on the maturity of this forum. 😛

No wonder some amazing and sensible posters have been amiss lately

Edited by zainab25 - 16 years ago