Kurbaan: A Case Study - Page 4

I suppose so.

Originally posted by: Angelic_J

Why should the haters move on when the lovers keep pushing it up their faces?😆 Everyone has an opinion so they are more than welcome to express it be it either negative or positive. Just because it is against your own opinion doesnt mean people should stop giving it😆

I know you've brought that point up time and time again. But by me defending saifeena, have I ever HARMED another's member's sentiments?

Because you have done it time and again and it can be irritating but NO ONE says anything because we all know how much you love Saifeena. So thats point one.

So what do you want? If I have something to say in defense of my favorites, stay quiet and let ppl come in and criticize without any defense? Is that what this forum is about now?

See, when something is told directly then you get irritated. Thats why I rather stay shut because A and Z you completely misquoted me. I said I DO NOT SAY ANYTHING BECAUSE YOU LIKE THIS COUPLE. THIS IS WHAT A FORUM IS. TO LET PPL BE and let them ENJOY.

I don't know about others but I don't care if you defend Saifeena on this forum Desu. I have no problems with that. People here weren't even criticising Saifeena but the film, and you took it personally. You reacted and then people followed it up with their own responses. I don't think anyone needs to stop posting their views - positive or negative.

As for Shahid and Deepika not needing defending - maybe you missed that Harman and Vidya interview thread. There was quite a lot of Shahid criticism going on and people were responding to it. (Its another matter that once Vidya clarified that she wasn't talking about Shahid that thread became dead). I don't remember Shahid fans telling people to "move on". Deepika has also been criticised on this forum - but I usually just go and post once or twice and if I have nothing more to say I leave. Yes Shahid and Deepika fans might be here in higher numbers, but it isn't as if no one criticises them. Plenty of people do and have in the past, including you.

I personally don't appreciate being told that I should "move on" from a particular topic because I have a "negative" view.

Originally posted by: desigal90

So what do you want? If I have something to say in defense of my favorites, stay quiet and let ppl come in and criticize without any defense? Is that what this forum is about now?

If I have something to say, stay quiet? Now i know why so many ppl merely LURK on this forum. Infact a few have even come and told me they dont feel comfortable posting here. Now I know why.

If you defned someone, if your views are in the minority, its looked DOWN upon. Infact, its made a spectacle out of. LIek right now. Why do you think Shahid and Deepika fans are not singled out? Becuase they dont NEEd to post to defned their favorites becuase A) they dont need to, B) there are so many fans you will HARDLY see one fan trying to defend them.

In the case of saif and kareena, if i dont speak up, no one will.

Whatever, if my posts are so damn annoying, then I shall refrain as well. Have no desire to irk anyone whatsoever.

Go on, happy posting.

Desu to be frank no one in this forum has anything against you and you are a really sweet person. All people are saying is that you don't take their words seriously. Sure XYZ may dislike Saifeena, but Saifeena can't please everyone right? If you want to defend them, then I would suggest post a comment in general, and don't direct it at anyone. It's upto you though. I don't think everyone hates Saifeena here, and the word hate is far too strong over a celebrity that we don't know. Some of us pass general comments and leave, but our posts are meant to be taken lightly :-)

Originally posted by: ~angelz16~

See, when something is told directly then you get irritated. Thats why I rather stay shut because A and Z you completely misquoted me. I said I DO NOT SAY ANYTHING BECAUSE YOU LIKE THIS COUPLE. THIS IS WHAT A FORUM IS. TO LET PPL BE and let them ENJOY.

Had I QUOTED U BACK YOU COULD HAVE SAID THIS BUT I DID NOT EVER BECAUSE AS I SAID I KNOW YOU LIKE THIS COUPLE. BUT YOU on the other hand HAVE WROTE A REPLY ON WHAT I DID NOT DO. And I dont see any ppl from BS section missing and everyone still enjoys and heck, I only see new members coming in.

So Happy posting TO YOU.!!

@bold: I agree on this! The main point of the forum is for members to come and post their opinion.

To be honest, New York was much better. Much more cohesive and the performances felt more real. With Kurbaan, it was like everyone was TRYING to be put in this award winning performance. It felt like they were too aware of the responsibiity to portray this story well and for me, the acting in the film didn't ring quite true.