Is sameer really the villain??

forbiddenlove thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
I remember when I saw the wedding scene when he told her its not his child...and indirectly implicating that she's a slut, i was shouting at the TV screen coz I was so angry at him for betraying her like that. But after seeing these recent episodes (post-marriage) ones, I realized Sameer isn't the bad guy. I have begun to sympathize with his character actually. Because even though he got his revenge, he's not happy. He didn't enjoy hurting Avni or humiliating.....but he never let go of the thought of his suffering mother. He already lost his father thanks to the Gujral's. Sameer was at the hospital ALONE....he was caring for his mother ALONE.

This thing started because they wanted revenge. They didn't know how till our very own brilliant Prithvi Bhayya came up with the idea of using Ila's daughter to take revenge. I hadn't seen those episodes back then when there father got killed etc etc....but after finding it was all Prithvi's idea, I was furious. Prithvi isn't mahan at all. He is in fact just as bad as Sameer or worse. Varun is the only one didn't stray.

Its not easy to see your family member suffer. Trust me I know. And If someone dare to cause them pain I would never show mercy. According to me, Sameer is the MOST human from all of them. I really love how they have developed his character. I love how he's in conflict with not only himself but also with the ones he loves because he loves them 😉 I also love the shades of grey given to him. In general, I am glad this show is going on a route different from the typical candy floss love stories. Finally, a show thats has more mature issues and characters. The writers are doing are swell job. 👏


Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4.2k

Users

17

Likes

73

Frequent Posters

sistu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Hey i will copy and paste something i wrote in shwetha's post yesterday to answer ur question:
I knw sameer stands at a point where we dont have much of respect from him. But we have also seen where he is coming from. No one can deny the fact that he loves his parents and brothers, otherwise why would he leave all his dreams behind and come to Mumbai. he was once the very sweet, charming, and nautanki sameer that we liked. I dont knw if I am right or not but I think if circumstances were ok then may be sameer wudnt hurt avni the way he has.
AmbyCious thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
I agree with every WORD of yours!!!!Prithvi is not great,it wasn't sameers idea to hurt avni.he already liked her very much!And varun?He was always against revenge.He said to himself " i dont know if hurting the girls would be right or not but if bhaiyya says so i will do it"
so except for prithvi,i support both the brothers!
Eksie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Yup .. Sameer loves his parents .. and went all out to seek revenge for what Ila Gujral did (or so they believe).
At the end of it all ... their mother will SMACK Prithvi for coming up with the whole revenge plan in the first place .. and be VERY PROUD of Sameer for avenging their father's death by getting a girl pregnant, denying the child is his .. basically, insulting the very core of what a woman is all about! Way to go, Sameer!!! 👏 👏 Yup .. he is Human ... and nowadays, we see a lot like him around!
Question here is not about having no mercy on the person who has caused you that pain ... its about one's upbringing & morals! Prithvi puts his morals & upbringing in front, coz thats what his parents gave him .. Sameer puts his parents in front of him, but does things his parents never gave him in his upbringing! As a woman, a mother, a parent .. who will you be proud of?!
Almas. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
d only good thing abt sameer's character is tat wo apne prithvi bhaiyya ki itni izzat kata hai...unka kehna manta hai......tazit..😳
i agree tat it ws prithvis plan to hurt illas daughters n all...but he alwayz reminded sam to b in his limits.... but sam.ussse to apni hi karni 😡thi....avni se uski zabardasti shadi usiki sazza hai..........
adits7 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
I think its only sameer who hs bn wrkin 2wrds der mission..coz he is d only 1 who hs kept his emotions,true feelins aside 2 complete his badla,it must b painful/diff fr him too to hurt sum1 he actually luves.
Priya. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Yes Sameer loves his mother ..

But will his mother still love him when she recovers and comes to know that her laadla has humiliated her first bahu in front of the whole world and also rejected her first grandchild ?

She might then prefer going back to her veggie state....
Edited by Priya. - 16 years ago
Sonikins thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

sorry guys i can't defend sam whatever he did with avni is totally wrong and if avni had died he would have been murderer too(no offence savni fans this is only my view and i agree K.T is a wonderful actor)

(if my views someone feelings than i m sorry)
441597 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Ektaj

Yup .. Sameer loves his parents .. and went all out to seek revenge for what Ila Gujral did (or so they believe).

At the end of it all ... their mother will SMACK Prithvi for coming up with the whole revenge plan in the first place .. and be VERY PROUD of Sameer for avenging their father's death by getting a girl pregnant, denying the child is his .. basically, insulting the very core of what a woman is all about! Way to go, Sameer!!! 👏 👏 Yup .. he is Human ... and nowadays, we see a lot like him around!
Question here is not about having no mercy on the person who has caused you that pain ... its about one's upbringing & morals! Prithvi puts his morals & upbringing in front, coz thats what his parents gave him .. Sameer puts his parents in front of him, but does things his parents never gave him in his upbringing! As a woman, a mother, a parent .. who will you be proud of?!

i wholly disagree with u ektaj.......it is about having no mercy on the person who caused u pain....tell me u would be very merciful towards people who caused u pain such as killing ur dad..............as i said every1 is looking at thye situation from the POV of avni?
oh yes, i dont know if his mother will be proud of sameer's deeds or not...........but according to everyone here, she will be SUPER PROUD of the fact that her elder son has completely forgotten of his father's death, is trying to destroy his younger brother by forcing him into an unhappy marriage, and,
LAST BUT NOT LEAST, married one of the KILLER'S DAUGHTERS himself! shes going to be sooooooo proud of that wont she?????
she will be thinking, "ela gujral did such a huge favour on me by killing my husband, why did that sameer rascal spoil my happiness by hurting ela???? idiot!"
441597 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Ektaj

Question here is not about having no mercy on the person who has caused you that pain ... its about one's upbringing & morals! Prithvi puts his morals & upbringing in front, coz thats what his parents gave him .. Sameer puts his parents in front of him, but does things his parents never gave him in his upbringing! As a woman, a mother, a parent .. who will you be proud of?!

what morals are u talking about here, eksie, morals for someone who took away one of ur PARENTS????????????????????????????
I will tell u one thing, instead of blindly judging morals try putting urself in the place of someone who has lost their father..........see how much mercy crops up in ur heart for the one who made u orphan..........its very easy to give such judgements when ur NOT suffering the pain.................
cheers

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".