Is sameer really the villain?? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4.1k

Users

17

Likes

73

Frequent Posters

Sonikins thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#31
I agree that sameer is not villian but we can't justify him too I like his character as he cares abt his family but don't like that he left his own child.i know he has moral values too but forgot b/c of his parents death
but plz don't bash pri 4 sam's mistakes as pri has nothing to do with that. He makes a plan which is alright he thought he shd use girls that waz compltely wrong.But he did not want a girl to suffer like this and that is positive sign of pri
Plz guys if u like sam's character it is ok if u think he is hero its ok but plz don't bash pri in order to defend sam
forbiddenlove thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#32
I am sorry if my views offended you pridafan 😊 I personally don't like prithvi so I might have drawn comparisons. I wont bash further.
-Doppelganger- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: forbiddenlove

I am sorry if my views offended you pridafan 😊 I personally don't like prithvi so I might have drawn comparisons. I wont bash further.

agree wid u...
i used to like prithvi's character in the beginning.....but not any more!!!!!
I mean it was prithvi who came up with the plan of hurting ila using her daughters...then why is he so concerned about avni?
Has he forgotten about his father's death & mother's condition?Is his love for the unborn child more than that for his father and mother???
Sameer's way of taking revenge was not at all right...he went too far(i really sympathise with avni's character)
But wat about prithvi???If he did not want to hurt the girls...then why in the first place did he marry damini?won't she be hurt to the core when she finds about his truth????
I feel prithvi is being a hypocrite....varun is perhaps the only one amoungst the three who is righteous as he was always against the idea of using ila's daughter to hurt her
Sorry no offence to prithvi or prida fans...this is just my opinion
-Doppelganger- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: pridafan

I agree that sameer is not villian but we can't justify him too I like his character as he cares abt his family but don't like that he left his own child.i know he has moral values too but forgot b/c of his parents death

but plz don't bash pri 4 sam's mistakes as pri has nothing to do with that. He makes a plan which is alright he thought he shd use girls that waz compltely wrong.But he did not want a girl to suffer like this and that is positive sign of pri
Plz guys if u like sam's character it is ok if u think he is hero its ok but plz don't bash pri in order to defend sam

Sorry but for the past 2 months everyone(including me) has been bashing Sameer....So is it wrong if we post in our opinions about prithvi??...People think differntly...i don't think u can expect everyone to like his character
Please don't take it as bashing up of characters...we are just posting in our views
Anyhow GK is doing a very good job as prithvi...i like him as an actor
(sorry this post was not to offend you or any prida fan)
441597 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#35
ok let me make one thing clear....i DONT intend to bash prithvi.......but here are my thoughts:
prithvi is a hypocrite. it was he who 1st made the plan of hurting ila gujral through her 3 daughters....."illa guiral ki galtiyon ki saza unki 3 betiyon ko bhukatni hi paregi"
but later, when sameer does this, he gets agry. WTH?????? why did he make such plans if he did not want sameer to hurt avni????
he supported sameer when he married avni but went against him when he consummated?WTH was he expecting sameer to remain a virgin even after marriage?????
and speaking of morals......well what kind of "morals" he himself has?????? he agreed to marry damini for property.....but says he beleives in saath phera and their meaning...........on one hand he speaks of nivaoing the vachan of saath pheras and on the other hand he is marrying her for money..............what kind of morals this is????
pure hypocricy.......and if u argue that he has not touched her physically as yet............i will remind u that he hasnt had the CHANCE to do that.......or is he trying to say that he will marry but not consummate?????? he is the world's biggest fool then.
atleast sameer is consistent in his deeds...whether good or bad........but prithvi just keeps oscillating...........once this and once that
441597 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#36

@ ektaj:

just one question for u:
WHAT WOULD'VE U DONE IF U HAD BEEN IN THEIR PLACES????
Bugger thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#37

So ...is sameer really the hero ????

There r many wayz to revenge ...........but to make a gal pregnanat and leave her .......is sumthing any person with conscience wont dare to do! I mn ot saying saxenas shud hav left them scott free .....but wat gud wud it do to them if tht gal wud hav commited suicdie and prithvi cudnt hav saved her .................
Not only sameer, prithvi was wrong as well when making this stupid revenge plan ...which holds no ground!
they shud hav made a plan to clear their father name off teh murder and framing ela rather than goin on with this stupid plan!!
but obviously we r not creatives!!
prithvi now n then knew his limits and to certain extent varun too ......but sameer crossed it ........after crossing it he felt bad and thot of repenting! we were wit hhim ....... but yet again he did the mistake of dejecting both avani and teh child!!
galtiyaan karne ki bhi ek limit hai ......u cant do anything in the name of revenge ......there r sumthing known as "extreme" ....where sameer already went.
Edited by Bugger - 15 years ago
forbiddenlove thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#38
I totally and fully agree with Krystal and lnmdjrocksss!!

krystal - the part you said about prithvi's inconsistent character is very true. I noticed it many times but this time it really bugged me!!

lnmdjrocksss - You speak my thoughts exactly. In this whole scenario, even though Prithvi is the biggest hypocrite, no one says anything about him. He run's scot free and is shown as some sort of saint....and only Sameer is bashed 😲 Why?? Because Sameer consumated his marriage??? 😕

In a way, I am glad that they didn't show him repenting...it would have been unrealistic. He liked Avni but he was never IN LOVE with her. He always controlled himself when it came to his feelings for her. Whenever he would think that he was getting too emotionally involved with her....he would remind himself of his parents...then he would feel ashamed of himself for losing his focus from his goal of taking revenge. THIS is what I call 'keeping limits'. He was always in his limits. His each action was carefully thought out. I love what he says to Prithvi in the previous episode "hum apni maksad se bhatak rahe hai".

As far as Prithvi is concerned, he is already lost. He has easily moved on from his father death or his mother's illness. In fact, he is showing more concern for avni n her child...than he ever showed towards his own parents or brothers 😕 How can he feel so much for Avni (who he hardly knows) and so less for his parents??? Its a bit disturbing actually. And if he wants to live happily ever after, then he should have the guts to tell Damini the truth...lekin he wont do that also. He wants to hide...pyaar bhi karna hai....revenge bi lena hai.....mahan bhi dikhna hai... lol.

Having said all this, I want to say that none of us are AGAINST Prithvi or his character....but he is equally guilty in all of this. He should be the last person talking about 'morals'.....he's a hypocrite and a coward.
-Doppelganger- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: forbiddenlove

I totally and fully agree with Krystal and lnmdjrocksss!!

krystal - the part you said about prithvi's inconsistent character is very true. I noticed it many times but this time it really bugged me!!

lnmdjrocksss - You speak my thoughts exactly. In this whole scenario, even though Prithvi is the biggest hypocrite, no one says anything about him. He run's scot free and is shown as some sort of saint....and only Sameer is bashed 😲 Why?? Because Sameer consumated his marriage??? 😕

In a way, I am glad that they didn't show him repenting...it would have been unrealistic. He liked Avni but he was never IN LOVE with her. He always controlled himself when it came to his feelings for her. Whenever he would think that he was getting too emotionally involved with her....he would remind himself of his parents...then he would feel ashamed of himself for losing his focus from his goal of taking revenge. THIS is what I call 'keeping limits'. He was always in his limits. His each action was carefully thought out. I love what he says to Prithvi in the previous episode "hum apni maksad se bhatak rahe hai".

As far as Prithvi is concerned, he is already lost. He has easily moved on from his father death or his mother's illness. In fact, he is showing more concern for avni n her child...than he ever showed towards his own parents or brothers 😕 How can he feel so much for Avni (who he hardly knows) and so less for his parents??? Its a bit disturbing actually. And if he wants to live happily ever after, then he should have the guts to tell Damini the truth...lekin he wont do that also. He wants to hide...pyaar bhi karna hai....revenge bi lena hai.....mahan bhi dikhna hai... lol.

Having said all this, I want to say that none of us are AGAINST Prithvi or his character....but he is equally guilty in all of this. He should be the last person talking about 'morals'.....he's a hypocrite and a coward.

I 'm really glad that there are atleast a few people here who think this way...
Agree with you....lately this forum turned into a sameer bashing forum and no one says a word against prithvi or his actions
forbiddenlove thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#40
^ Haan yaar, I know what you mean. Everyone seems to be in love with Prithvi character...but I really can't understand what makes him so great.

I was also initially one of the people bashing sameer and cheering for avni...but looking at things from his perspective....the situation is totally different. He is the victim and not the culprit.
Edited by forbiddenlove - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".