The 3 kids were right - Page 4

I don't support these three immature kids for their actions, how dare they say injustice has been done to them when week after week they have all been number one, and have been praised for their performances! What they did was uncalled for. They want to become professional playback singers, when they themselves were totally unprofessional that night. They should be ashamed of themselves!

Interesting : Read following from TOI
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1381721.cms
http://navbharattimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1381459.cms

I still think they were wrong, they should have told the show before hand and pulled out before the show went to air.

I PITY ANYONE WHO CURSES THE 3 KIDS FOR WHAT THEY DID.

I CONSIDER YOU IGNORANT FOR NOW UNDERSTANDING THAT THE REASON FOR WHAT HAPPENED IS THE FLAWED regionalist VOTING SYSTEM AND THE money-hungry MANAGEMENT.

hey, if u have a system where votes come in on the basis of language or region but not on pure singing performace, things like these are bound to happen now or later.
whats the use of cursing the 3. curse the system if u have brains

Originally posted by: trueandlovely

I PITY ANYONE WHO CURSES THE 3 KIDS FOR
WHAT THEY DID.

I CONSIDER YOU IGNORANT FOR NOW UNDERSTANDING THAT THE
REASON FOR WHAT HAPPENED IS THE FLAWED regionalist VOTING SYSTEM
AND THE money-hungry MANAGEMENT.

hey, if u have a system where votes come in on the basis of language or
region but not on pure singing performace, things like these are bound to
happen now or later.
whats the use of cursing the 3. curse the system if u have brains

PLEASE spare us the moral platitudes. The system was exposed as flawed
when Raktima, Swananda and Sharib were eliminated while Rajeev stayed.
Where was there protest then? I don't blame the kids as they are kids but
at least their parents apologized.

When Vineet and Himani get the max votes from Hindi/Punjabi language
regions, I don't hear any protests.

So, please spare your concern for our intelligence or morality. Listen to
the songs and vote for the best singer.

I agree. You concurr with the process as long as you benefit and start protesting when you don't. Double standards!!

Originally posted by: mdroy

PLEASE spare us the moral platitudes. The system was exposed as flawed
when Raktima, Swananda and Sharib were eliminated while Rajeev stayed.
Where was there protest then? I don't blame the kids as they are kids but
at least their parents apologized.

When Vineet and Himani get the max votes from Hindi/Punjabi language
regions, I don't hear any protests.

So, please spare your concern for our intelligence or morality. Listen to
the songs and vote for the best singer.

I agree. Any one with minimum commonsense and without a bias generated by irrational sympathy towards their beloved contestants shud agree to this.

Its time they start thinking of getting some top music directors to choose the winner with the remaining 3. Only by doing this will they be able to get back some of the lost glory of SRGMP. There were no complaints whatsoever before the challenge and now the criticisms are endless.

At this point of time, if they are going to continue with the public votes, it goes without saying that Debojit will be getting the highest no of votes and be chosen the winner. I dont think anybody will be interested to look forward if they decide to have SRGMP Challenge 2006.