Vaishali, soirabhee and Ravi

Page

Next Last

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Vaishali Mhade...she wasn't charizmatic and i heard she got actiev support from political parties, but saregama's winner thsi season stands head and shoulders above the other 2(just like aneek stood head n shoulders above ismeet n prashant) well that's sareagam for you. No matter how bad it was, it CANNOT have a besura singer as winner. Vaishali was quite deserving though some others had ebtter persoality, but vaishali's singing alone made it.😃

Sourabhee deb barma...ameteur singer, better singers will be found in every nook n cranny of India. But well, a girl, complete package. lets just forget her singing as we cleebrate these 2 things😆

Ravi shukla...bad singer, ok perfomer. made it bcoz of Vote bank alone😕

That's the 3 shows...saregama, VOI n Indian idol

saregama all the way👏

Quote

Frequent Posters

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Every year we see singers from saregam moving ahead of the other 2 shows

Time Indian idol n VOI actually retrospect n think on which is more imp- singing or money

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Damini

@akash99

Rocker

Posted: 17 years ago

i never like Ravi

vaishali was good only at the end

but saurabhee was really a deserving candidate

Quote

Rida

@Mysterygirl_me

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: akash99
i never like Ravi

vaishali was good only at the end

but saurabhee was really a deserving candidate

i agree with u completely😊 apart from being a good singer u need to be a good performer as well and sourabhee was just that and the judges also praised her and her singing throughout the competition so according to me she was the best from all the previous winners this year...!!! Vaishali was a very good singer but lacked that persona on stage and ravi was just trying too hard he wasn't a good singer...!!!! i hope i have not offended anyone😊

Quote

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Rvi and sourabhee are equally bad singers...diff is sourabhee has a stge presence which ravi lacks

Quote

ruchika

@indomie

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Its always been like that..saregamapa has an edge over the other shows...the final threeare always equally good and whoever wins it is always a victory for Good singing.Sometimes we get disappointed coz our favourites don't win..But we never had any complaints about the winners singing talent..👏.

Why not the same happens in Indian Idol...how come the audience chose bad singer for idols only...The judges should give such final twelve singers , that we should not have any problems whoever wins...It never happened with Idol..

What is the problem with Idol..Judges, vote bank, bad projection or regionalism...high time..Sony should think about it..This is the third time they are delivering an ordinary singer as an idol...😲

However they break the trend and we got a female idol..Congrats.

Ruchi

Quote

Rani

@April2007

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Sourbhee is no match for Vaishali. Vaishali will leave her way way behind. If it very enjoyable to listen to Vaishali, I many times go you to youtube to listen to Vaishali sing, while Soubhee is very very ordinary singer, i have many times fast forward her performances. Actually Sourbhee is no match for Yashita either. I find Yashita way better than Soubhee.

According to Shanker, He has never ever seen a better female singer than Vaishali in all the music reality shows he has ever judged, and he has been special judge on many shows.

Complete package or not Soubhee lags way behind in Dancing. The great dancers are part of 'Dance India Dance" Soubhee is no match. I find Soubhee extremely thin and for me her extreme thinness ( stick like arms) come in the way of enjoying her performance. Since we are discussing complete package, Sourbhee's extreme thinness and total lack of curves is an extreme disadvantage in being a complete package. She is too thin therefore lacks body to be complete package.

Edited by April2007 - 17 years ago

Quote

Rani

@April2007

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: indomie
Its always been like that..saregamapa has an edge over the other shows..

SRGMPA is way ahead of all the other shows. I think it is the judges nothing else.

In 'Chote Ustad' Sony had better judges and we had 'Ashwariya and Anwensha' they both were very good. No such luck with rest of the shows.

Quote

413342

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

SRGMP's Vaishali, Pratibha and Yashita are head and shoulders above all the Indian Idol contestants. Then there were other contestants like Soumen, Naina, Kaushik, Tarun and Shashi who could have topped most Indian Idol contestants. May be all of them.

SRGMP somehow (I don't know how) consistently draws a quality crowd to participate. Something about that "manch" that attracts the classes. This despite biased, over-the-top judges like Himesh and Ismail Darbar (at least till last season).

SRGMP's class of 2005 is handsdown, the best ever.

Quote

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

I totallya gree with all of you

i guess the people who vote in saregama vote for the ebst singer, transcending regionalism and petty stuff like who looks good

In indian idol top 14, the girls who were only good-looking made it directly, rem. Bhavya n shini were wildcards. But in saregama it is the voice alonbe that matters. i am sure Rajdeep/prasenjit/shini would moved higher in sraegama!!

I was dissapointed when Naian and Shashi didn't amke it in saregam, but it is true that Vaishali was a very good singer and i am happy a deserving on won

as for VOI, i loved the first season. they had some quality singrs like Abhaas, Arshpreet who are astounding. Toshi, abhilasha and Irfan were also very good. However an ordinary singer won there...though he has a good voice quality.

I think shows like VOI n Indian idol pabder too much to the masses, not classes. not that saregama was far behind ith Aasma alst season. But still quality triumphed in sareagam.

Quote

1 2

Ravi

Vaishali, soirabhee and Ravi

Related Topics

Explore Topics