Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.4k

Users

18

Frequent Posters

Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#21
can''t believe this happened, it is a matter of great shock, actually I missed this show. I am now regretting defending Abhijeet in previous posts (on this issue) at least.
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#22
These judges are promoting slavery😆 or testing their disciples.😆 Himeshji lives for his fans and the audience.😆
Edited by Summer3 - 17 years ago
sangautam thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#23
when the results of a reality show is left to the public you should respect the publics opinion. If the public feel rajashree should be on the show till the end, then so be it - they are the ones that are keeping the show on air and I think they deserve to get what they want. The judges have no business to talk so rudely to the participants and expect them not to explain themselves. If India is not ready for reality shows they should not try to ape the West and run these shows. I was watching a show in US called "So you think you can dance" One pair was given Bollywood dance as their routine. They put all our so called divas (ahmed - you should watch this and hang your head in shame) to shame. I think you can watch this on youtube. The judges appreciated inclusion of our culture in the west. The very same week we saw the kantankerous Abhijeet refuse to give Mussarat marks. The west is picking up where the east is leaving. I think it is shameful that we have a bunch of incompetent judges making a mess and insulting the public because of whom they are here today. I would really appreciate if this topic is brought up on teh show and the judges are made to fall on their feet and apologize to the public who are spending their time and money to make this show something worth for them to watch.
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: sangautam

when the results of a reality show is left to the public you should respect the publics opinion. If the public feel rajashree should be on the show till the end, then so be it - they are the ones that are keeping the show on air and I think they deserve to get what they want. The judges have no business to talk so rudely to the participants and expect them not to explain themselves. If India is not ready for reality shows they should not try to ape the West and run these shows. I was watching a show in US called "So you think you can dance" One pair was given Bollywood dance as their routine. They put all our so called divas (ahmed - you should watch this and hang your head in shame) to shame. I think you can watch this on youtube. The judges appreciated inclusion of our culture in the west. The very same week we saw the kantankerous Abhijeet refuse to give Mussarat marks. The west is picking up where the east is leaving. I think it is shameful that we have a bunch of incompetent judges making a mess and insulting the public because of whom they are here today. I would really appreciate if this topic is brought up on teh show and the judges are made to fall on their feet and apologize to the public who are spending their time and money to make this show something worth for them to watch.

Yes the dancers in that show are truly fabulous. But it is a pure dancing competition. Judges there too can be terrible at times and rude, but none behave so unprofessionally like in ESBE.
bhidesm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#25
Judges have stooped low to make their favourite contestants winners. When judges made comments about Rajashree, they should have shown civility to hear her view. Rajashree showed determination in performing after all this controversy. It's good for her that she quit.
In 3rd August episode, both the judges agreed that Sayantani danced less, still she got 9 undeserved points.
Both the judges should be disqualified for consistently irratic judging.
Summer3 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: bhidesm

Judges have stooped low to make their favourite contestants winners. When judges made comments about Rajashree, they should have shown civility to hear her view. Rajashree showed determination in performing after all this controversy. It's good for her that she quit.

In 3rd August episode, both the judges agreed that Sayantani danced less, still she got 9 undeserved points.
Both the judges should be disqualified for consistently irratic judging.

No one can sack the two Hitlers and go against their bullying tactics. They have no respect for the contestants and behave worse than school teachers. I think perhaps they are getting bored, tired and feeling all the strain. 😆
goodstuff thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: ChicksDigMe

First Ahmed gives a 1 out of 10 for Amit Paul!!! A 1 out of 10. Then justifies it by saying that a 1 or a 10 doesn't matter. Amit Paul, the gentleman that he is, tries to come to terms with it by saying that 1 is his lucky number. In a way. Doesn't say anything back that might "upset" the "Respected" "Almighty" judges.

Rajashree (and a billion others I am sure) are confused by this 1 mark thinking to themselves - who the hell gives a talented, graceful singer like Amit Paul 1 mark. The puzzled look "upsets" the "Respected" "Almighty" judges. They say things like "Rajashree kuch bhhi bol deti hai", "we don't want any attitude" etc. They get more upset as they continue to shout and make weird faces.
Rajashree like a billion other servile Indians comes back and says she's sorry for her "behavior". The "Respected" "Almighty" judges are not totally placated but nevertheless try to contain their displeasure.
Amazingly, Rajashree finds her inner courage to perform immediately after the drama. She does well but by then the "Respected" "Almighty" judges have made up their minds towards Amit Paul and Rajashree. Chances are they made up their minds long back.
Sanchita comes in, sings in some strange voice which is not even her original voice. Doesn't matter because in between the performance you can clearly see in Abhijeet's eyes and body language what his feelings are for Sanchita. The marks are predictably 10.
The things I would like to do with these two judges - unprintable!

You're biased, that's why you're exagerating. We all are to some extent lol. Rajashree does have an attitude problem, and I would understand if she was one of the best performers, but she isn't. So when judges give her bad comments/marks she's offended, but when they give her good marks she doesn't even show a sign of appreciation. That's what the judges were getting at. You can't be a spoiled brat and expect no criticism and only praise. But I'm gonna agree with you on giving Amit 1 mark, because the poor guy didn't deserve to be caught up between Rajashri and the judges' fight. As for Sanchita, I actually think she's become the best singer on this show. I used to under-estimate her but she really did sing well when she got the ten, and thereon. So if her and Kushal end up in the finals, and are good performers, how is that a bad thing? lol. The judges are blunt, which people have a problem with. But that's honesty, and does more good for a person and their improvement than faking a "why, aren't you a great singer :D".
i think aneek-shayantini, and kushal-sanchita should go to the finals. both singers and dancers are strong.
Minal ruins it for Abhishek..Mussarat still needs to warm up to the stage and Sanober could use more grace..and while Jasweer is very consistent, I think Raja has his limits to a good song, nothing extraordinary.
goodstuff thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28
and i think it's about time abhijeet stopped appearing in reality shows lol this guy is like a big kid. poor mussarat.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".