Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: EDT - 41 (DT Note pg: 132) - Page 147

People who worship Neetu need to check their morals for real. Now they have found a new way to justify their support to her, "because of her, the plot is moving" I mean, the plot can move the way writers want, it can move due to other characters as well but we will mollycoddle Neetu Saluja because her intentions are right. People fail to see her actions always cause destruction for Mannat, Dua esp for Vikrant. Today the way she was obsessively saying the crude thing to Mannat like you have to stay with Vikrant due to Dua as she will have to stay with him due to court, that too infront of that traumatized kid and shamelessly wants to discuss it openly infront of everyone. Her own son wants to mend things with Mannat on her own will, not due to force but here we have this woman creating more hurdles. Its funny that today many were mad that Mannat dragged Neetu but tomorrow will celebrate Vikrant when he will blast her as well. Like out of everyone, Mannat has every right to berate her as due to her crappy mistakes, pre leap Mannat bore the brunt and this notorious woman still is on the same path, she has every right to blast her as its a matter of her own minor kid.

Originally posted by: Kidult104

People who worship Neetu need to check their morals for real. Now they have found a new way to justify their support to her, "because of her, the plot is moving" I mean, the plot can move the way writers want, it can move due to other characters as well but we will mollycoddle Neetu Saluja because her intentions are right. People fail to see her actions always cause destruction for Mannat, Dua esp for Vikrant. Today the way she was obsessively saying the crude thing to Mannat like you have to stay with Vikrant due to Dua as she will have to stay with him due to court, that too infront of that traumatized kid and shamelessly wants to discuss it openly infront of everyone. Her own son wants to mend things with Mannat on her own will, not due to force but here we have this woman creating more hurdles. Its funny that today many were mad that Mannat dragged Neetu but tomorrow will celebrate Vikrant when he will blast her as well. Like out of everyone, Mannat has every right to berate her as due to her crappy mistakes, pre leap Mannat bore the brunt and this notorious woman still is on the same path, she has every right to blast her as its a matter of her own minor kid.

Neetu Mata is busy taking Yashika’s side shamelessly forgetting she created the whole mess.

She is such a narcissist woman that she will see everyone's fault but not her own. Many a times she has put the entire blame on Vikrant as well. Till now has never said a single sorry to him for causing him so much pain pre-leap.

I really now want Yashika to eliminate her in some way so that Neetu realises kisse pala parha hai uska.

Madam ko izzat and bina pareshani wali zindagi raas nai aati. Let her deal with the real Yashika, i really hope. The day Yashika calls her 'budhiya'...similar to how Vishakha used to call her mother-in-law...and tries to do something to her..then only she will develop some brain cells...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2L8SZXt_7g

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

.

I dont understand why and how Mannat was wrong? Any action done with good intentions doesnt carry bad karma. It is so clear in our scriptures and history.

Dont think i am comparing Mannat to Lord Krishna. I m bringing the similarities only to showcase how the action is termed right or wrong based on intentions. Krishna broke every rule of war during Kurukshetra. Do you question him? If you do, I cant say much. But thats how you have to look at "Dharma". Dharma is not the same or equal at any time. For the same individual it changes. A lie is needed for good sometimes.

I was helping my kiddo with history project, where she has to learn and write about 13th amendment by Abraham Lincoln. 13th amendment is brought into US constitution to abolish slavery. While trying to bring the congressmen to vote for the bill, Abe lincoln uses several tactics to get the leaders to vote, including bribing them with govt positions. Though he believes in equality in men, he will NOT say openly that all men are equal irrespective of race. He tells his fellow congressman that he DOESNT believe in equality of races but only opposed to slavery and bondage. He has to say it because more than 90% of people in his own party think African Americans are not fully functional humans. He cant change their opinion overnight or can jeopardize the bill. So he says he doesnt believe in equality but only wants to abolish slavery. Does it count as lying, deceit when you see the outcome? For him, passing the amendment is the first step. Freedom is the first step. What follows later, is unimaginable. He has to open the door first. Watch Lincoln movie by steven speilberg to see his political mastery and understand what true morality is. It is judged by the intentions, not words.

I am not a great fan of this show's writing as everyone might have known here. But Mannat is decently written. I would have done the same as what mannat did with Vik during that time. Even hiding Dua. There is no mistake from her side. Making DK the father, no mistake either, given her circumstances. Supporting him throughout, no mistake. Only thing I didnt like is how she is unbothered about his future. They could have shown her worrying about his future.

Originally posted by: sadiltl

I dont understand why and how Mannat was wrong? Any action done with good intentions doesnt carry bad karma. It is so clear in our scriptures and history.

Dont think i am comparing Mannat to Lord Krishna. I m bringing the similarities only to showcase how the action is termed right or wrong based on intentions. Krishna broke every rule of war during Kurukshetra. Do you question him? If you do, I cant say much. But thats how you have to look at "Dharma". Dharma is not the same or equal at any time. For the same individual it changes. A lie is needed for good sometimes.

I was helping my kiddo with history project, where she has to learn and write about 13th amendment by Abraham Lincoln. 13th amendment is brought into US constitution to abolish slavery. While trying to bring the congressmen to vote for the bill, Abe lincoln uses several tactics to get the leaders to vote, including bribing them with govt positions. Though he believes in equality in men, he will NOT say openly that all men are equal irrespective of race. He tells his fellow congressman that he DOESNT believe in equality of races but only opposed to slavery and bondage. He has to say it because more than 90% of people in his own party think African Americans are not fully functional humans. He cant change their opinion overnight or can jeopardize the bill. So he says he doesnt believe in equality but only wants to abolish slavery. Does it count as lying, deceit when you see the outcome? For him, passing the amendment is the first step. Freedom is the first step. What follows later, is unimaginable. He has to open the door first. Watch Lincoln movie by steven speilberg to see his political mastery and understand what true morality is. It is judged by the intentions, not words.

I am not a great fan of this show's writing as everyone might have known here. But Mannat is decently written. I would have done the same as what mannat did with Vik during that time. Even hiding Dua. There is no mistake from her side. Making DK the father, no mistake either, given her circumstances. Supporting him throughout, no mistake. Only thing I didnt like is how she is unbothered about his future. They could have shown her worrying about his future.

Bhai, isko leke bahut argument hua discussion hua but it all circles back to 1 point - sab Mannat ki galti, A to Z everything.

Aman truth toh she herself kept begging RoTu to tell but Neetu darling did suicide drama. In such a case what else Mannat could have done ?! DK bhi pagal bana firr raha tha that he would go & tell the truth that too when marriage rituals were going on...why would a girl allow him to tell such a big truth to Vikrant and traumatize him & also get the wedding environment destroyed for which both ManVik fought tooth & nail to get together ? Either marriage se pehle discuss karo ya after that tasalli se...

.....and I have mentioned in the earlier threads as well that Aman's truth was not for her to tell, neither she had proper proofs with her nor she was even born when this happened to substantiate the claims...just like Dua's truth wasn't for Neetu to tell, only Mannat had the right..and in both cases Neetu ruined & created a mess due to her own narcissistic personality...

She really needs help..no 2nd doubt...

Someone who claims to love her child doesn't hurt him/her emotionally this way.

She is a control freak who wanted control over her son.

Ayesha summarized it so well...she struggled a lot to explain which I can totally understand

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDqTKfUhWJU

Chalo bhai DCP kah waqt pura hua! Aaj toh DCP neh apna farz ours kiya , Vikrant koh finally shine karva diya!!

The scene where DCP was questioning Mannat and Vikrant entered giving lecture to DCP was absolutely hilarious….. sau khoon karke janab chale haz peh… Vikrant who pushed Mannat at the altar, left her with CA is giving lecture and wants to fight for Mannat’s rights!!! Wah kya baat hai!!!

my sarcastic self couldn’t control!!

On a serious note Dua and Vikrant scene was a tearjerker! Poor baby!

Aaj toh makers koh Achanak seh yaad ata that this story is about ManVik …. Toh bas Mannat ekdum melted wax… unfortunately I don’t feel ManVik vibes anymore.

I said yesterday Ayesha screaming for Vikrant about hearing the accident was not felt… Ayesha khud convinced nahi hai …. Kedah ManVik?!

Mere DCP keh liye oolltiii ginti shuru