What if Adhik's redemption was a facade to gain trust of AnupaMaa and Anuj?What if it was a scheme to erase all doubts of Shahs and Kapadias? And it involved with Pakhi being a villain in eyes of all and him being a good guy for Anuj?
When Adhik exposed himself and BarAnk on women's day out, Anupama was doubtful about him but Anuj trusted him. Later, even BB doubted that this guy was using his marriage for his gain. MaAn may never know but when Anuj was in coma, Adhik was dreaming about his cremation. I haven't seen even Pakhi doing that. Later, when BB tried to get the truth out of him, he suspected that she was recording him. His redemption was shown as sudden. He also said that by marrying P, his Didi could remote control Anupama. Even after his redemption, he and Maa had ZERO bonding. Even in her dreams, alongwith her three kids and Pari, she was afraid for Kinjal and even DIMPY but NOT ADHIK. She is shown to care more for Romil and even CA and Sara than for him. In this show, redemption has been given to those who either had past bonding with MAA or bonded with MAA even after being her nemesis. So, red flags were always there. It was easier to root for redeemed AB because he was shown as a good Dad and a good brother for a main character.
Then P became demanding and he started behaving like an outsider. Then, MAA was convinced that P was problematic (true as a bonus) but Adhik was a saint. Then, they spent months as a normal couple after P changed and he became the guy who changed a spoilt brat for better. Then crisis hit and boom. He got a better job and his sister was more involved than ever. Only his family lived in KM and ruled KE. Then Pakhi arrives and challenges their authority and soon , Anuj and Maa are back but he is still a good jamai but has started beating his wife in secret. And it should be a secret for him but then Romil arrives.