Book Title: The Highwayman (Series: Victorian rebels # 1)
Author: Kerrigan Byrne
Year Published: 2015
Genre: Historical Romance, Victorian Era Romance, Angsty romance
Trope/s: Second chance romance, marriage of convenience, Romance in captivity (sort of?)
Maturity Rating: Adult for sex scenes, violent acts
Book rating (out of 5): 2.75? (I feel like 2.5 is a bit low and 3 is too high so settled on this 😆)
Synopsis: Farah Leigh Mackenzie, a widow and Scotland Yard employee has just been proposed to by her employer after a solitary, lonely existence of 17 years when she's kidnapped by a notorious highwayman, Dorian Blackwell, and brought to Scotland - to the place she grew up and spent her adolescent years in. Dorian has a proposition for her: he will marry her to help her gain back her lost inheritance and in turn she will help him avenge his friend and her husband, Dougan Mackenzie. Farah and Dougan had married when mere children in the orphanage where they met, and Dougan, in a bid to protect her killed a priest and had to go to prison where he eventually died a tragic death. Dorian is an enigma to Farah, but she does marry him and the rest of the story is about them reconciling with their respective pasts and coming to terms with their feelings.
Review:
I was really eager to pick this one up, its a popular and well-loved HR & I had to wait weeks in queue before it became available at my library. I expected to like it and I did in some parts.
Byrne's writing is exquisite in places, she wrenches out the emotions in her MCs and dresses them up in perfect prose. But idk why it left me cold after a point. Dorian is a tragic MMC, he has faced so much and it made my gut clench the way he describes what happened to him and the torture he was subjected to. His resultant abhorrence to any kind of touch is quite understandable - even if its tender and loving. Farah has a mountain of emotions to navigate herself - dealing with her love for Dougan, his tragic death and Dorian's emotional baggage on top of it. She is smart and gutsy and shows spunk too. But idk why I just could not connect to either of the MCs. I feel like the angst went on and on and finally it just left me drained and desensitized. I knew they were in pain and had dealt with a lot of tragedy but at one point I was like - get over it already! Especially since after the 'revelation' Dorian still continues to push Farah away. It got tiresome. Also, it felt unnecessarily contrived for the narrative to keep hiding while hinting at the truth, when everyone can plainly see it and only the FMC can't. And when she does see it - she's like I must have known it somewhere deep inside. Yeah, I eyerolled so hard! 🤔 Their owning up to their feelings mainly Farah’s for Dorian & how its tied to the past also felt very contrived and required a lot of suspension of disbelief (for me!)
I don't enjoy angst for the sake of angst and it seems to me that Kerrigan puts her MCs through the wringer just to evoke sympathy and garner pity points. Well, it had the opposite effect on me! Besides, second chance romance is not my favorite trope at all.
Still, this book does have some redeeming features so if you enjoy a well-written (I mean the prose, not the narrative) angsty period romance, maybe this one is for you!
Now reading: Hook, Line and Sinker by Tessa Bailey
Edited by LizzieBennet - 1 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount