Isn't Ishani behaviour Hypocritical

intruderfast thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#1

She sunaaos gyaan to everyone for not following the rules.

But what did she do to that sardarji daughter?

Was she following all the rules,? Yes she argues that when patient life is in danger, what rules will save them

As per this logic, even Sid is right. He was trying to save a poor child life. Yes by taking extra money from Rich clients.

But his patient life was also on line.

To.me this is clearly a hypocritical behaviour. One hand u have made it ur mission life to get Sid suspended for violating rules

Other hand , when a crisis comes , u urself dont follow protocols.

Cvs r messing up with Ishani character. TBH she comes and a kind of weirdo here.

Sometimes I feel usko koi pin karega aur wo bomb ki tarah blast ho jaaegi🤣.

Sid me baare mein kuch bhi kaho, uski buried yaa acchi qualities , his character has been consistent.

Hopefully Cvs do better justice to Ishani

Created

Last reply

Replies

55

Views

8.2k

Users

12

Likes

91

Frequent Posters

angel_nonu thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: intruderfast

She sunaaos gyaan to everyone for not following the rules.

But what did she do to that sardarji daughter?

Was she following all the rules,? Yes she argues that when patient life is in danger, what rules will save them

As per this logic, even Sid is right. He was trying to save a poor child life. Yes by taking extra money from Rich clients.

But his patient life was also on line.

To.me this is clearly a hypocritical behaviour. One hand u have made it ur mission life to get Sid suspended for violating rules

Other hand , when a crisis comes , u urself dont follow protocols.

Cvs r messing up with Ishani character. TBH she comes and a kind of weirdo here.

Sometimes I feel usko koi pin karega aur wo bomb ki tarah blast ho jaaegi🤣.

Sid me baare mein kuch bhi kaho, uski buried yaa acchi qualities , his character has been consistent.

Hopefully Cvs do better justice to Ishani


That is her character flaw. when it came to saving a patient she didn't think about rules. But for sid she did not see him saving kid(that viewers know not Ishani). She saw him manipulating a patient to do surgery on extra part which is like playing with patients trust & putting Sanjivani reputation on risk.

Ishani has her flaws and that is going to be character journey. She is not a perfect trp bahu who does not make mistakes. Dr Rishabh scolded her for her mistake and we all praised that this was needed lol.

Gayathri_10 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Ishani was perplexed when she was questioned by rishab that time. She was not hypocritical but she was written like that. It was not at all inconsistency. If that was inconsisteny there they wouldnt have given her reality check. And Hope makers do handle these many flaws in her carefully...

Here no one is doing sid vs ishani char flaws. Both have their flaws. And ppl who r discussing abt sid also want to see the progression.

Sid's flaws were not noticeable by many bcoz of his character nature so if we also didnt discuss they will make his ways as very noble doing.

Midnightsorrow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Yes she's wrong and Rishab lash out at her for that which was very much needed. He didn't in anyway praise her, he give her a reality check. Rishab is a guy who does his job well unlike Sid.

intruderfast thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: angel_nonu


That is her character flaw. when it came to saving a patient she didn't think about rules. But for sid she did not see him saving kid(that viewers know not Ishani). She saw him manipulating a patient to do surgery on extra part which is like playing with patients trust & putting Sanjivani reputation on risk.

Ishani has her flaws and that is going to be character journey. She is not a perfect trp bahu who does not make mistakes. Dr Rishabh scolded her for her mistake and we all praised that this was needed lol.

That's the problem again i feel. She hasn't given sid a chance to hear his story. She is very judgemental. She sees things only in black and white.

Yup let's hope that along with her journey, her thinking changes slightly

intruderfast thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Gdbs

Ishani was perplexed when she was questioned by rishab that time. She was not hypocritical but she was written like that. It was not at all inconsistency. If that was inconsisteny there they wouldnt have given her reality check. And Hope makers do handle these many flaws in her carefully...

Here no one is doing sid vs ishani char flaws. Both have their flaws. And ppl who r discussing abt sid also want to see the progression.

Sid's flaws were not noticeable by many bcoz of his character nature so if we also didnt discuss they will make his ways as very noble doing.

I am not defending Sid. He is wrong in many counts. What if for just ripping off rich ppl, he ends up suggesting some harmful surgery.

I was merely Pointing out that Ishani herself bends rules . Well may be not like sid. Sid has his won way. Ishani kaa apna andaaz😆

intruderfast thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: xAaliya

Yes she's wrong and Rishab lash out at her for that which was very much needed. He didn't in anyway praise her, he give her a reality check. Rishab is a guy who does his job well unlike Sid.

I agree. Rishab is right now a better doctor than sid

Gayathri_10 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: intruderfast

That's the problem again i feel. She hasn't given sid a chance to hear his story. She is very judgemental. She sees things only in black and white.

Yup let's hope that along with her journey, her thinking changes slightly

No she did gave him chance to explain...but he didnt take that seriously...

And when s'day he said he can give explanation she was not ready since she had proof so she might have thought he was going to pin the false story...

Parakkumthalika thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

When ishani is breaking the rules or protocols she’s been told that what she doing is wrong. First scene where she treated that child with hypothermia, nurse told her that he’s not her patient,but it was an emergency. Second occasion the surgery without confirmation of diagnosis by CT scan, again she was told off. So her flaws are being pointed out and highlighted

Contrast to that what sid is doing, Dr. Shashank told him what he’s doing for the poor pts is a good thing. So it’s shown in a positive light

Koel100 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

How is it hypocritical when Ishani is being called out & shown mirror of her flaws & makers have established that's what her journey is going to be in stark contrast to people be it dr.shashank or audience hailing dr. Sid for his wrongdoings.

Hypocrisy would be when Ishani is hailed & she is shown as Messiah for her wrong doing which isn't the case as contrast to people hailing sid

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".