Isn't Ishani behaviour Hypocritical - Page 5

Originally posted by: drbeth

Oh god i'm so tired of explaining did to you. She pinpoints every rule that's broken because she knows it in her subconscious that it's a rule. And she doesn't even think twice before breaking the same rules.

Rules are der in hospitals for certain reasons. You can't just jump dem because you care for the patient . Point is she broke a rule...... conscious or subconscious...... dt doesn't make it disappear.

Where did she broke rule other than those two critical patients. She followed Dr sid rule even when it was so uncalled of Dr sid to now allow her to assist Dr shashank knowing that she is a good doctor. But still she did what she was asked for. So no where she broke any rule knowingly. both time decision has been made in haste when patient was in critical condition and thats where she makes mistake so its her flaw not consciously made decision to break the rules

ok you yourself are confused with your definition hehe

anyways for you she is for me she is not :)

Originally posted by: drbeth

I'm very clear with my definitions and understanding . But it's pointless to explain it to people who are not ready to understand . You are never going to accept that Ishani is a hypocrite . Hypocrisy is hypocrisy ......no subconscious involved in d definition. But you won't understand that since you love the actress and will defend her character endlessly even when she is wrong.

Oh by the way read a lil bit about subconscious before attributing the so called " character flaws " as " subconscious " issues.

First you call it character flaw and when you can't defend dt.....you go on to ' subconscious ' things......Lol. First stick to one.....den we will talk.

A hypocrite preaches one thing, and does another. You're ahypocrite if you criticize other people for wearing fur, but pull out your big mink jacket as soon as it gets cold. - this is the definition.

so now I wonder when Dr sid did not allow her for Dr shashank surgery without any reason then why did she not break the rule if she really is a hypocrite. If she is really breaking rules knowingly then she could have done here too. and this has nothing to do with love for actress. Today that throwing water was uncalled for and I nowhere defended that and nowhere I claimed that Ishani is perfect. she is very much flawed, makes mistakes but it will make her hypocrite when she knowingly deliberately breaks rule in any other situation than when a person is critical and can die if not attended.

This is becoming too much now. Let's agree to disagree and move on. For some Ishani is hypocrite for some she isn't.All cannot have same views about the same thing. Like we can't call every critic of her character a hater, in a similar manner we cannot call any supporter or defender of her character an obsessed/ blind fan. There is no need to go personal over a tv show and its characters. None of us are uneducated here, so it can be presumed that everybody know very well about what they are typing or writing. Nowadays this forum has become a fighting zone instead of a place where healthy discussion and debates takes place.

Meri thread hit ho gayi. 7 pages wow😎😆

Originally posted by: drbeth

I don't agree.

Just because one time she followed rule , I can't ignore the fact that she broke it two other times.

The reason she listened to Sid was she had no other option.You cannot forcefully attend a surgery when you are not allowed to. If it wasn't a senior's surgeon's surgery in which she needed permission to be present......den probably she would hv barged in and done the surgery herself......like she did previously .

The two situations are completely different. When she has a chance to toss the rules out ......she does dt without even a second thought. Sounds like a hypocrite to me .

lol Dr Rishabh was with her in previous surgery so I wonder why did he not stopped her and performed surgery with her. She did not perform surgery by herself. and no she is not barging in any OT to do surgery. That kid was critical and his attending doctor Dr sid was somewhere else so as a doctor when she saw him critical she handled the patient. Second time she was going to make her discharge papers as asked by Dr rishabh but that lady became critical so she asked wardboys to prepare for surgery but that was done with Dr rishabh and she did not do it alone lol

she very well had chance to toss rule, if not assist then she could have left Dr sids work which he gave to her to check on his patients and would be attending Dr shashanks surgery instead

Originally posted by: Sparklingstar22

This is becoming too much now. Let's agree to disagree and move on. For some Ishani is hypocrite for some she isn't.All cannot have same views about the same thing. Like we can't call every critic of her character a hater, in a similar manner we cannot call any supporter or defender of her character an obsessed/ blind fan. There is no need to go personal over a tv show and its characters. None of us are uneducated here, so it can be presumed that everybody know very well about what they are typing or writing. Nowadays this forum has become a fighting zone instead of a place where healthy discussion and debates takes place.

I don't think I went personal anywhere but yes as you said I will stop here

Originally posted by: angel_nonu

I don't think I went personal anywhere but yes as you said I will stop here

It wasn't meant for anyone particular. It was a general comment. Let's all try to keep the forum from getting toxic together. We all come here to discuss and have a healthy argument over the show and its characters. Positive criticism and healthy debates are always welcome,and If we find any comment too offensive or hateful, we can always report and ignore. So there is no need to fight.

Originally posted by: drbeth

Tell me something first......did you read the thread maker's post ????

It was about Ishani and that's y we are discussing about her. I never said that others don't hv flaws or can't be hypocrites. I based my comments based on the original posts. Did you see me praise anyone else ??

About Rishabh ... It's not wrong to keep paperwork for later in case of emergency. Emergency means all hands at work. You need to focus attention to things that are important.

About Anjali.....I hv missed dt part . What did she do ?? Shout on Juhi for delaying a life threatening surgery for 5 long hrs ??

Vardhan........is supposed to be the villian of the show .....what else do you expect from him. I expect lots of character flaw ....not just one. And head of a hospital can suspend a doctor if found guilty of doing something unethical.