Isn't Ishani behaviour Hypocritical - Page 2

Originally posted by: intruderfast

That's the problem again i feel. She hasn't given sid a chance to hear his story. She is very judgemental. She sees things only in black and white.

Yup let's hope that along with her journey, her thinking changes slightly

I disagree. She did not take it as black and white.The first thing she did was to give him chance to explain. She clearly told him that if he can explain then do it otherwise she will complain. But he shown her attitude and told why should I tell you.

About judgemental, She sees Sid manipulating natasha to have surgery on more body parts so what do you think she should have opinion about Dr Sid? how is she being judgemental here because she did not do that with anyone else.

Even in yesterday episode when she made video he could have explained but he was more focused on taking phone and deleting it.

Originally posted by: Gdbs

No she did gave him chance to explain...but he didnt take that seriously...

And when s'day he said he can give explanation she was not ready since she had proof so she might have thought he was going to pin the false story...

yesterday also before he said he will explain, he had already tried to take her phone. rather than taking phone from her he could have tried to explain.

Originally posted by: Parakkumthalika

When ishani is breaking the rules or protocols she’s been told that what she doing is wrong. First scene where she treated that child with hypothermia, nurse told her that he’s not her patient,but it was an emergency. Second occasion the surgery without confirmation of diagnosis by CT scan, again she was told off. So her flaws are being pointed out and highlighted

Contrast to that what sid is doing, Dr. Shashank told him what he’s doing for the poor pts is a good thing. So it’s shown in a positive light

hey loved your reply. Yes her flaws are being pointed out and not appreciated. She will have her own journey to overcome them.

About Dr sid someone need to make him also understand that this way is wrong. About Dr Shashank I don't think he knows that what ways Sid is using otherwise Sid wouldn't have been worried that Ishani might tell Dr Shanshank. Dr Shanshank just thinks that he helps poor.

So can I conclude people aren't watching Ishani in first place or conveniently ignore things for their own narratives, like she did give sid a chance but she is still called out, what should she do, wait for sid the great to come & give his explanation when he deems fit.

Originally posted by: Koel100

How is it hypocritical when Ishani is being called out & shown mirror of her flaws & makers have established that's what her journey is going to be in stark contrast to people be it dr.shashank or audience hailing dr. Sid for his wrongdoings.

Hypocrisy would be when Ishani is hailed & she is shown as Messiah for her wrong doing which isn't the case as contrast to people hailing sid

Never have I said that makers r hypocrites.

I know she was told off but that's not the point.

I am talking abt the character ishani. I guess u missed my point.

Originally posted by: drbeth

For everyone who is saying Ishani was scolded for her breaking rules......no one is saying dt didn't happen.

Hypocrites are people who say something and do the exact opposite.

Ishani preached rules and regulations and den goes and breaks dem when needed. That's hypocrisy.

Exactly, not understanding this at all.

Whether Ishani was scolded or not isn't an issue.

Kindly please Google Hypocrites 😆Meaning

Originally posted by: angel_nonu

I disagree. She did not take it as black and white.The first thing she did was to give him chance to explain. She clearly told him that if he can explain then do it otherwise she will complain. But he shown her attitude and told why should I tell you.

About judgemental, She sees Sid manipulating natasha to have surgery on more body parts so what do you think she should have opinion about Dr Sid? how is she being judgemental here because she did not do that with anyone else.

Even in yesterday episode when she made video he could have explained but he was more focused on taking phone and deleting it.

Ok agree to disagree then.

To me she is just obsessed right now to punish Sid. The way she jumps at anyone and accuses , anyone wld feel bad. Her tone is always angry and accusatory.

Ek tareeka hota hai baat karne kaa. Uski haryanvi friend ko dekho, hamesha attitude dikhati hai wo usko. Wo bechari usse fship karna chachi hai bas.

Sid has praised her , tried to be nice to her. She knows he is an excellent doctor. But nahi, she won't consider that and is hell bent on destroying Sid.

Originally posted by: drbeth

For everyone who is saying Ishani was scolded for her breaking rules......no one is saying dt didn't happen.

Hypocrites are people who say something and do the exact opposite.

Ishani preached rules and regulations and den goes and breaks dem when needed. That's hypocrisy.

thats her character flaw that she herself did not realize that she have broke the rule to save the patient but that is not called hypocrisy. She even now havn't realized that she have broke the rule. That is her char journey.

Originally posted by: intruderfast

Ok agree to disagree then.

To me she is just obsessed right now to punish Sid. The way she jumps at anyone and accuses , anyone wld feel bad. Her tone is always angry and accusatory.

Ek tareeka hota hai baat karne kaa. Uski haryanvi friend ko dekho, hamesha attitude dikhati hai wo usko. Wo bechari usse fship karna chachi hai bas.

Sid has praised her , tried to be nice to her. She knows he is an excellent doctor. But nahi, she won't consider that and is hell bent on destroying Sid.

Where did she jumped on everyone and accused? She coincidentally have found Dr sid doing jugaad everytime and wasn't running behind him. With Asha, firstly Asha started in very friendly talks like babydoll & all after that she told her off for that dustbin scene.

I did not see her accusing anyone else other than Dr sid.

About showing attitude, its just 7 episodes lol & Asha-Ishani scenes came like either Ishani was going somewhere or she saw sid doing jugaad. Even Asha was jealous of her.

Dr sid did praise her yes because she was good but same Dr sid stopped her from assisting Dr shashank surgery in his jealousy even after knowing she is good and its about Dr shashank.

I did not see Ishani being angry or accusatory with Anjali Juhi shashank Vardhan rishabh rahul but only with Dr sid

Originally posted by: intruderfast

Hopefully Cvs do better justice to Ishani

Good suggestion, but no justice would satisfy the people because it is played by SC 😃.