Is he? Really a criminal?

OK. I had to gather up a lot of courage to even make this post and am still not sure it's a good idea given the kind of passionate discussions going on here about Dev's new stupidity. Yes, even stupidity would be small word for it. He deserves every word he is being called by people here.

OK. That he is guilty of thinking of make her undergo this treatment without her consent is true. I can't argue with that. But does the intention and motive really hold no value. Of that I am still confused.

Tell me something..lets say a woman is in coma and she absolutely wanted to have kids before she slipped into coma., Now the husband decides lets me perform all these procesures and impregnante her.. So that when she wakes up one day she would be a mother... Does it sound like a criminal offense or husband is only wishing to make his wife happy? May be it is a horrible example but atleast in this case the husband has legal rights to decide for wife even though the whole thing is inhumane and morally wrong...

In out case atleast sona is not in coma , so dev should actually try to follow the protocol and try to have kids naturally for atleast 6-12 months and then move to next stage. But he is taking a short cut and trying yo preserve this moms new found love for his wife.. Where as he is the one who should have actually facililated that ishu loved sona with out baby in the picture... Ohh but thats hard work and dev dixit doesnt believe in that especially when his mom is in pic. For him telling truth and trying for kids is also hardwork .. So he wants to just jump the line and start infertility treatments on his wife (is that even needed?? May be she would get preganant on her own!! ) why pump so many drugs into her body - there are many side effects of these drugs.. Ans that too with out her knowing what she is going to go thru... It is criminal offense if he ends up doing what he is planning..
In sonas words " acche intentions ka kya woh achar dalegi?".. Just tell ger the truth dude

I would just say let the track roll-out
For now we exactly don't know what he's actually upto

Yes but here he has been already branded a criminal who is playing with his wife's body, and he is being accused and treated like any other common criminal

Okay let's take a scenario. Say someone tells Sonakshi that Dev has cancer and he needs to get cancer medication. She doesn't check the reports (say she is not a doctor here), she doesn't tell Dev, she doesn't research the risks involved and learn anything about the procedure and she doesn't take a second opinion thinking that it will hurt Dev. So she just gives the doctor carte blanche to do an experimental medical procedure on Dev's body by giving him cancer treatment.

In India it's a crime to do anything with a patient/human-being without letting him/her know if it's an adult. Refer to Article 21 of Indian Comstitution. Not sure if big business tycoons like Dev will go into jail for this or not because power plays big role in India while implementing laws. Crime Patrol showed many such episodes where lower middle class and middle class people were caught and arrested.


In first world countries for such crime irrespective of your money and position in the society, you will definitely get punished. Consent is one of the key aspect here and doctors dont even touch your body without explaining what he is doing. That says a lot.


So yeah in all corners of the world where law and constitution exists, Dev is a criminal.