Is he? Really a criminal? - Page 2

what dev is thinking of doing is wrong and he knows that very well and we all, but he is mr. dixit and we all know how implusive person he is. anyways nothing will happen as sonakshi will figure it out and dev will know the hard way of his foolish thinking. lets wait and watch how things unfold.

First of all it's illogical track..cvs have not done home work properly. The treatment for infertility is not easy and cannot be done over night. It would take min 3 months. To start medication sonakskhi shd get period first. After that only it starts.

Yes I agree to all of you. The way u guys present it seems like dev maybe called a criminal. But still somehow the term seems too harsh for him.

Originally posted by: YASHO1997

Yes I agree to all of you. The way u guys present it seems like dev maybe called a criminal. But still somehow the term seems too harsh for him.

Some of you points that I would like to elaborate :

Firstly I think we are trivialising his intention. It's not just so that ishwari will love sona. However it may seem to us it really is a really great deal for them. And why won't it be she was the one always against them tried to keep them away. So now they suddenly feel the acceptance and love... Isn't it obvious they are overwhelmed and want to hold on to it.( this is how dev and sona see it. I know this is not good enough reason but it maybe for them)

And also we are looking at situation through our eyes... Dev yet doesn't know it's fake love. He things his dream is coming genuinely true.

Secondly the cancer treatment example. The situation is different here. Here sona's life is not in any danger and I trust dev enough to always first assure her safety. If he is able to go through this(which he will 100% not be able to) then he would have never exposed her to any threat.

That's all I have to say now. I know this is not enough to remove the tag of criminal but I don't know still feel criminal is a bit too harsh. Though I do agree to all u people have said.

OK now u make him sound like he has this plan of torturing his wife. As I said I strongly believe he would never endanger sona's health. But this is still on the assumption it's ivf right?. We don't know that yet.

Originally posted by: YASHO1997

OK now u make him sound like he has this plan of torturing his wife. As I said I strongly believe he would never endanger sona's health. But this is still on the assumption it's ivf right?. We don't know that yet.

Ummm...You say that the term is very harsh? But my dear friend THAT IS WHAT IT IS. HARSH. because what Dev is doing is a criminal offense in India and many other countries. Like some one said such acts are justified only in the case of self defense or for preserving of life. Otherwise , the simple word for the person doing such an act is called Criminal according to law.

Originally posted by: YASHO1997

OK now u make him sound like he has this plan of torturing his wife. As I said I strongly believe he would never endanger sona's health. But this is still on the assumption it's ivf right?. We don't know that yet.

All we r saying is they have been married less than 2 months ... Why jump to serious fertility treatments where as he could simply tell that test is negative but this he will not wait for 5 yrs . Ish will be happy .he would have time and sonas consent to do the treatments if they cant conceive in 6 months.. Why does he not want to try.. Like i said in another posts my doctors told me i can not conceive with out treatments but i did on my own twice... So see doctors can only tell u what they think but that may not be true all the time... Jumping to operate on a pimple without giving time to heal itself is wrong on several accounts..

So yes he is not a criminal yet but he is on the path to become one.

I want to mention an incident shown in Crime Patrol here -


There were 4 people who would make a job out of kidnapping new born kids from parents to provide them to parents who either cannot become parents or cannot adopt child lawfully due to weird Indian laws (such as family income etc) or because they want a specific gender kid and is not having even after multiple try (both girl or boy). The receivers of the kids didnt know that the organization is kidnapping those kids and giving them. They just got the kids and are ecstactic and were asked 'aam khaao gutli kiun gin rahe ho' upon asking from where these kids are coming from. The kids started to grow in those new parents with much care and love and have lovely upbringing for a considerable period of time.


One day the gang is caught and all the kids were taken back from the rearing parents and were given back to their respective birth parents. Not just that, along with the gang people, the rearing parents were arrested as well for not abiding by the law. They were in emotional distraught since they truly loved those kids as their own but destiny snatched them away, but law doesnt take that into consideration so those parents are arrested too.


This is what we are trying to say, intention doesnt matter when it's a crime. If so, all the tortured and deprived people would start murdering all the evil people who tortured them throughout and the 'intention' would still be right. Even if you read the history of terrorism, they also had valid reasons to avenge the powerfuls. It's not the intention, it'd the action that matters. Yes intention can lessen the punishment in India (not in first world countries) but it cannot put one above law even if one is like the messiah of the whole world. 😊