wow this forum is really a gost town!!!

merrydock thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
this forum really is empty. i think most people and perplexed by this version of Mahabharata according to karn.
personally i'm a huge Arjun fan. and as Arjun is the hero of the Mahabharata then karn can only be describe as the tragic anti hero of the epic. even though he hanged out with the villains of the epic, i never believed he was truly bad. like just dealt him a bad set of cards, but he made all the wrong choices.

if he had made friends with the pandavas, karna would have actually been a greater hero than Arjun.
but alas is bad fate. Arjun rose on every level.

i wish the producers had told Arjuna's story instead, they wouldn't have had to make up so much of the story.

Arjuns achievements, struggles and life is well documented in our folklore in so many different regions of our country.

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.8k

Users

13

Likes

34

Frequent Posters

Shiningstar2014 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Dis forum is not completely empty coz ppl do share their views on some threads...karn was equally famous like arjun its just he was on d wrong side...anyway every characters of mahabharat have grey shades nobody even lord krishna wasnt milk stained...there were some cheatings from d dharm side too
minzuuuu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
MAHABHARAT BIG Epic Story so Mahabharat's every characters R Very Good & Very Wrong & yes Lord Krishna also...
only & only 2 characters ABHIMANYU & GHATHOTCHACK R VERY VERY GOOD characters .
adiluvu thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
So Sad Mahabharat ARJUN also Gost so u come Gost town .
FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
I think the Hero of Mahabharat was none other than Bhishma and villain was Shakuni, no other character (male) actually was such without whom the story could not have progressed
Nandita_Siddian thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
ist of all welcome to the ghost town...😛
2. karna is not less popular than arjuna...i am not saying that becoz i am a karna fan..but it is a fact...i think he is the only antagonist whose popularity can be compared with the protagonist of the story.😳.

3. Karna is a very popular topic among the indian writers and poets..there are many famous and popular novel and poems on him in different languages around the country ...there are hit flims on him...so it is not like that ke ppl can not make or can not take his story..😊

4.And in mahabharat every character is winner and looser simultaneously...its depend on the ppl's POV that whom they consider a winner or looser...and that is the greatness on this epic...an epic where god himself loose his everything their how can we classified someone as a looser or winner!!!!!!

5. It's totally SidT 's own choice that he have made "suryaputra Karn " rather than "indraputra Arjun"..so there is no use on debating/discussing on that topic here.😊

6. SidT does not care about any documented story for anyone...if he wanted he can show imany documented stories on karna and easily made an one year long daily show...But sid T is not interested in real fact ...he showed wrongs facts on his famous Star bharat and he is showing wrong facts here also...so that is also a topic which is totally out of our control for us.😃


Edited by Nandita_Siddian - 10 years ago
TheWatcher thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: merrydock

this forum really is empty. i think most people and perplexed by this version of Mahabharata according to karn.

personally i'm a huge Arjun fan. and as Arjun is the hero of the Mahabharata then karn can only be describe as the tragic anti hero of the epic. even though he hanged out with the villains of the epic, i never believed he was truly bad. like just dealt him a bad set of cards, but he made all the wrong choices.

if he had made friends with the pandavas, karna would have actually been a greater hero than Arjun.
but alas is bad fate. Arjun rose on every level.

i wish the producers had told Arjuna's story instead, they wouldn't have had to make up so much of the story.

Arjuns achievements, struggles and life is well documented in our folklore in so many different regions of our country.



So you're saying that this forum is empty because Arjuna's story can be portrayed better.

This show is not that popular due to the bad story telling by the makers, not because Karna's story is not well-documented. Karna is still the most written/talked about character from Mahabharata (Excluding Krishna obviously).

It is the show which is poorly made not Karna's lack of story.


br200910 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: merrydock

this forum really is empty. i think most people and perplexed by this version of Mahabharata according to karn.

personally i'm a huge Arjun fan. and as Arjun is the hero of the Mahabharata then karn can only be describe as the tragic anti hero of the epic. even though he hanged out with the villains of the epic, i never believed he was truly bad. like just dealt him a bad set of cards, but he made all the wrong choices.

if he had made friends with the pandavas, karna would have actually been a greater hero than Arjun.
but alas is bad fate. Arjun rose on every level.

i wish the producers had told Arjuna's story instead, they wouldn't have had to make up so much of the story.

Arjuns achievements, struggles and life is well documented in our folklore in so many different regions of our country.


Welcome Gost Town - 😊

Mahabharat is a EPIC not family drama not a sasbahu drama n not a love story . 😆

So we all come this forum n post Topic but not more coz MAHABHARAT is a Big EPIC there are many different languages around the country n they r use only VedVays Mahabharat not any new story ..
so there is no use on debating/discussing on that topic here.

My self... Mahabharat's every characters Very Good & Very Wrong & yes Lord Krishna also... coz MAHABHARAT is TODAY LIFE ...

KARN n ARJUN both r most Imp characters . i love Both.😊

Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: merrydock

this forum really is empty. i think most people and perplexed by this version of Mahabharata according to karn.

personally i'm a huge Arjun fan. and as Arjun is the hero of the Mahabharata then karn can only be describe as the tragic anti hero of the epic. even though he hanged out with the villains of the epic, i never believed he was truly bad. like just dealt him a bad set of cards, but he made all the wrong choices.

if he had made friends with the pandavas, karna would have actually been a greater hero than Arjun.
but alas is bad fate. Arjun rose on every level.

i wish the producers had told Arjuna's story instead, they wouldn't have had to make up so much of the story.

Arjuns achievements, struggles and life is well documented in our folklore in so many different regions of our country.



Actually, Arjun's achievements are overrated by modern mytho CVs, who know little about the epic and make up stuff out of thin air.

Like in this serial, just like in ⭐️B, Arjun is shown as a born archer & champion, which is bakwas. When the Pandavas were kids, Arjun was about as innocent as Nakul or Sahadev, and it was really Bhima who protected them from the Kauravas. It wasn't until at Drona's gurukul that Arjun started to shine on his own.

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

So you're saying that this forum is empty because Arjuna's story can be portrayed better.

This show is not that popular due to the bad story telling by the makers, not because Karna's story is not well-documented. Karna is still the most written/talked about character from Mahabharata (Excluding Krishna obviously).

It is the show which is poorly made not Karna's lack of story.




This serial might more appropriately have been called 'Kuntiputra Karna' rather than Suryaputra, since it embellishes Kunti's behavior in toto and creates imaginary enmity b/w Karna & Dury. Not just that, it villifies all the perceived or real 'rivals' of Kunti's mamata - both Radha and Madri. Radha was depicted as an evil stepmom who only started loving Karna after he saved her life, while Madri, who in real live was never a villain, was depicted as insulting Karna as a sutaputra in the imaginary encounter that Karna had w/ Pandu.

Given what they have changed in this story, if they do show Karna as joining Dury, then that would blacken Karna's reputation in this serial. In the real MB, Karna was driven into the arms of Dury since the Pandavas took the initiative in insulting him w/o any real provocation. In this serial, Karna is loved by both Kunti and Pandu, so if he turns against the Pandavas, he'll look at best as another Shalya, and at worst as an ingrate. Totally wreaking havoc on his reputation.

This serial might as well show Karna as joining the Pandavas and fighting for their rights against Bheeshma & Dury, instead of his usual role as one of the members of Dury's coterie.
jmoyee200 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: shipreeta

I think the Hero of Mahabharat was none other than Bhishma and villain was Shakuni, no other character (male) actually was such without whom the story could not have progressed



Total Agree with u ...Only Hero Bhishma & Villain Shukuni ...do all think.

Arjun very poor person coz all time lord Krishna teach him.


Dear merrydock we all gost it mins u also gost 😃ooo welcome ...😆 😆 😆
Edited by jmoyee200 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".