A paheli called anandi - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

66

Views

5.2k

Users

16

Likes

215

Frequent Posters

Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#61
How can shiv's act be compared with anandi's foolish act ?
shiv saved hundreds of lives who might have died in bomb blast.

Who was going to die in child marriage? If anandi had used her presence of mind and left her daughter home, what damage would have happened to pooja?

Okay the marriage would have taken place, but could the child bride be not rescued later?

If she cannot do it after marriage, then why did she give her card to mangala and frighten her saying she rescues child brides?
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: aparnauma

There was absolutely no need for Shiv to do what he did.The police were there and they had arms with them and he was unarmed.If he wanted to help he could very well helped in evacuating people from there or some such thing.
Well terrorist/terrorism is a threat from outside while evil social practices destroy the society from within.

She took all precautions informed the police and wanted to leave her child at home but was pressurised by Sarita. She as a mother could understand the other woman's desperation so she went to help the other woman save her child. Through out she stayed out of line of danger as opposed to her past ways where she would confront armed people and ready to face the bullets.
She almost succeeded in getting away from there with her baby.
Nobody can say she has been careless or foolish.


The fact was for their story Shiv had to die and fo the child of Anandi Shiv had to be kidnapped. The only way Anandi and Shiv's daughter could be made into Balika Vadhu is through most bizzare twist.


Taking a child in a place where you are trying fight against a strong-rooted issue and involves police is not foolish?! If tomorrow Mangala tells Anandi to give up Shivam in exchange of Nandini would she do it because she understands the motherly feelings of Mangala?!
Stopping a child marriage is not some walk in garden! If it involves police, chaos and bullets will be involved! Would you take your child somewhere there is a strong possibility of things going haywire? Its a lame excuse that Anandi could not predict it because she has been involved in many cases regarding bal vivah! Not to mention almost losing her life in one of them!
Besides if some civilians gets hurt then police is largely blamed for it! Hence presence of civilian is nothing but unnecessary disturbance for police during such crisis! If criminal had caught the victim and asked police to drop gun or lose the victim's life then police could have done nothing because if the victim does get shot police would be blamed for it more than the criminal!
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: aparnauma

The police in this case were not shown making mistakes.
It was clearly a matter of taking things into ones own hands which was unnecessary.
The desire was to do his bit to help.
It has never been a wise decision on his part.
He died unnecessarily .The risks which he took were not necessary too.

He too didn't think of his wife and children when he was doing all this.

The intentions behind both their actions were noble.

In Shiv's place had Anandi been there she too would have put her life at risk and done her bit to nab the terrorist but only difference is that if it is Anandi she would have been criticised as stupid and foolish even after she died.
It is the latent as well as blatant bias against Anandi that is prevalent in this forum.

People blame Anandi because her acts are indeed foolish even if their intentions are not wrong! Besides someone has to say the truth when CVs are busy glorifying each and every act of Anandi to such an extent that they compare her lack of practical ideas with Shiv's bravery! đŸ¤Ē
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#64
The fact remains that Shiv did take unnecessary risks with his life when there was no need to just like Anandi gave in to pressure by Sarita and went there along with her baby.
There was no need to take things into his hands.

Yes that bravery was unnecessary on his part. He had no business to put his life at risk when he knew that his wife and children needed him when he knew very well that his family knew only how to take from them and never be there when they are needed and Anandi was wrong too for taking her child there.

There were police to handle the terrorist.He had no business taking the matter into his hands.That was heroic but TOTALLY UNNECESSARY and yes it was thoughtlessness towards his family on his part.


Edited by aparnauma - 10 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: libsrocks

People blame Anandi because her acts are indeed foolish even if their intentions are not wrong! Besides someone has to say the truth when CVs are busy glorifying each and every act of Anandi to such an extent that they compare her lack of practical ideas with Shiv's bravery! đŸ¤Ē

Oh yes and all the people including viewerswho think that is chivalry on part of Anandi are retards 😛


Stalwart. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves


Difference between their acts. If Shiv had waited, there was this possibility of the terrorist escaping and creating havoc elsewhere. He did not want to let go of the terrorist at any cost. In anandi's case its only a Bal Vivah which is not life threatening and could be annulled.


Shiv shouldn't have risked his life in order to prevent the terrorist from climbing helicopter. At that point terrorist wasn't harming anyone but just trying to escape. Shiv can fight and kill him on terrace but he would never be able to catch remaining terrorists in the helicopter high above in the sky. Those in the chopper need to be caught by the defence forces at any cost before they harm people down or escape. Even if the terrorist whom Shiv confronted climbed into it and escaped it wouldn't have made much difference. Alerting the concerned authorities about that chopper and terrorist escape would have been a better option and I guess someone did that later. Since they didn't mention any further destruction after his exit they must have caught it/ destroyed it. But Shiv lost his life.

Anandi called the police but she didn't wait for them. How can someone think the child is safe by just holding it in their arms? Will not the bullets hit. If she clasp her child and jump from a cliff is it safe? Also what made her run blindly somewhere when the police advised her to sit in the vehicle? Sure she didn't behave selfish but her act was foolish.



Edited by Stalwart. - 10 years ago
BeautyBabe thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Anandi should have been a hero , inspiration but sadly she is not even a true representation of a mere human. I detest this need to put FLs on a pedestal but somewhere Anandi had to be inspirational because of the social message attached to the story. Sadly she couldn't be any of it , her words kept getting diluted and she became a white blank canvas who doesn't even have basic human traits- no wants, no desires, no emotions .. nothing. She is told to be this Mary Sue who is given the right words to mug and sprout . Kinda like our politicians , those ones that never inspire but keep sprouting a mugged up speech without backing it with actions.

Young Anandi was ambitious , eager and thought of herself too. Her marriage was an internalized concept. I kept waiting to see her struggle, her slow realization about the wrong which she was subjected too. But they chickened out..rather than making her the face of child marriage and it's ill effects ,they glorified it by making the Singhs' all white and Jagya took the brunt..because he apparently strayed . See that was the turning point. Jagya broke out from his environment and his perspective changed, very understandable given he was also raised with different experiences but then what perturbed was Anandi here, she saw, heard and was given the reality about her scam marriage and yet her fight was never made for her own freedom. It became about Jagya's cheating and not about the horrors of child marriage. How the young kids can outgrow the phase and want different things in life.


She probably would have resigned herself in that haveli even without a divorce which was propelled by others not her own want- see thats how they nullified Anandi, the only time when her basic desire and fight should be there for herself ..they made it all about Singhs'. How do they even go scout-free, she lived on their pity, guilt or what.

I would have loved her to move out, go to her poor parents , lived with them, fought for her own independent identity which is not marred by some badi haveli or a collector sahib. But Alas.

She should have been progressive, financially independent and exploring world and situations but because saas bahu drama sell they kept her in the BV. Made it abut Gauri vs Anandi . Pathetic.


I hated her marriage with Shiv. Simple because here is a girl who should be reeling from the trauma of child marriage and her own skepticism about marriage . There should have been more self-awareness about who she wanted, conversations about basic things like life, ambitious , goals, fears. nada they made it emotionally manipulative with Anandi doing it for her mom, dadisa and the whole khaadan . She wasn't ready for marriage at all.. why couldn't she convince her mother , fight for her wants and space. She just had a bad bad marriage breakdown , was started to live her life and again pushed in an arrangement where honestly how they fell in love, why and the space was missing. He was the tailor made Prince Charming, dadisa wished and viola shaadi. Wow how inspirational, no lesson learnt no thought about the past and what she needs in her marriage, no self-realization.
Worse she was shipped to another place, where again it was saas-bahu with added drama of a SIL . Just what Anandi always needed.

They kept her profession so hollow that one can eye roll at all her social service antics.

She went from being BH's canvass for angst to Singhs' smokescreen for their angst. Who was Anandi?

Worse, after her husband's death, she again returns back to the haveli where her ex-husband lives with his present wife. Holy hell, where is the integrity. Reasons or explanations- dadisa ke liye.

She made decisions for others based on her skewed information and perception . Weirdly then her 'I" is reflected.

How ridiculous was the way she lost her kid..again giving benefit of the doubt..how does this woman goes around living so normally, indifferent , not panicking every minute for that kid .

A social worker is persistent , engaging..uneducated women needs pursuing to change their things, but she gives up on Mangala and doesn\t even react at all .


She comes across a rich haveli wali who does social service for timepass, has no job , hasn't struggled at all. And is afraid to change and live out alone and carve an identity independent for herself.

An argument presented again and again.. oh well she lived for others, worked for others ..goodness etc. Well so did the Tulsis, Kekta bahus .. whats the difference , infact worse she never took charge of any thing. Dadisa didn't change for her , she was a culprit who till date tries to downplay her guilt . Saanchi- umm token lip service. what about her parents , her kids ( such an indifference there)


At some point in life, if you cannot voice your OWN emotions, desires , wants and carve out an identity for yourself or be self-aware. You are not brave .

Rest of the token goodness and lip service is an escape from your own problems and issues.

Anandi is just that.. a label and stale.

Oh but she is a leader .. very real one at that. We have seen her type in various political parties ,wear a saree , mug up a speech and go talk the talk. 😆

brilliant post
These are all the reasons i never found Anandi an inspirational character Nor i appreciate her She is beyond me

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".