Adnan Sami is better Judge amongst all 3

Adnan sami has his first experiance in V channel super selector where he select the super singer from all india so he has good experiance and he was only judge... Other thing is that he is Singer , Composer and music director so he has much better experiace amongst all 4 judges

Do u agree me?

Anu malik is the best judge. he's been making music for last 24 years and he is also a good singer and he has been judging Indian idol for last three years so he is the best judge among all.

I dont think you can decide that based on one Gala.

Judges over the course of the competetion need to make tough calls. And I doubt Adnan could rise up to the tast.

JA is still tops as a judge and Anu second.

I think Anu Malik is the best judge among the current lot as he is a music director. He is the one who decides which singer will sing what song. He knows which voice will work and which will not. And he has been in the music industry and has survived for so many years. He also knows how to change singers voices as people must have noticed how different he sounded in gori gori. Also, one cannot forget that he is in the top 5 music directors currently.

Javed Ji is a lyricist, yes he is old and experienced but he does not make music. A music director knows much more then a lyricist since he is the one who makes singers sing.

Having said all this I feel Sonu Nigam is a better judge. He says what he means and always sticks to singing. Even in SVOI and the season 2 of II, his comments were the best. If someone made a mistake, he would tell them where to improve rather then yell at them and discourage them.

Adnan I have not seen judging so it would be wrong to comment.

I'm not sure about that. Perhaps Adnan Sami would be a better judge...he is definitely very talented. I believe Shaan might fall into the same category. He is a wonderful singer, has composed some of the music for his albums, and writes lyrics for all of the songs in his albums.

As far as the current judges go, I feel that JA is generally the fairest. AM might be the most fit to judge a music competition since he is a music director, but he is very rude and inconsiderate towards the opinions of the other judges. Overall, I think they all could be better though. No body has stood out as an outstanding judge.

AM n JA have by far been the most consistent judges this yr (barrin a few tyms which is acceptable coz they r also humans n can go wrong at times).. they have been spot on more tyms than not & had it not been 4 them v wud not b seein amit n emon in the top3(wud have lost them in the auditions itself) ... think who wud have been in the top3 othrwise..(cant imagine II3 without these 2)
among the celebrity judges only sonu n adnan were singers so i guess they were gud ... adnan is a gud n exp singer so am lukin fwd to his opinions on the contestants

u r right but i think anu ji is the beat judge!
don't get me wrong!

😊 😊 😊 .
😊 😊 😊 .

Javed Akhtar analyzes each of them convincingly on the show...!

Guys, this is my first post ever. I normally don't reply to any of the posts but enjoy reading them.
In my opinion they should call somebody from down south like SP balsubramaniam or Chitra who have immense experience in singing. SPB must have sung about 20,000 songs till date in Telugu, Malayalam , tamil and Hindi. So he is my choice.
I don't know if you wld agree. I have seen him judge some competitions in south and he was wonderful as ajudge and so encouraging and giving tips to the singers to improve.