Whose personal property??? - Page 6

Originally posted by: Cleo12345

Agree with very word Maddy... Seriously, no accountability...and the audacity to say that don't hv expectations from the show👏...we all know the future of such people with little talent and tons of ego...a decade later, they will politely remembered as " one film/ show wonder"...We will find them standing outside production houses with JA as the only worth reading thing on their CV...I really hope that these talent deprived arrogant people don't sink the careers of the few talented actors on the show. I hv no idea what is happening on the show these days... Is Ruk still hogging the screen space or do they hv a new irritating favorite who has been assigned the task of testing viewers patience?

Originally posted by: MaddyO

Hi Radhika 😃
Do you remember your thread after Jodha left Agra when Jalal asked her to leave (in Sujamal in haram track)? I remember it had such intense heated discussions ran to 50 odd pages with wonderfully written posts giving pro and anti arguments! The wonderful long post of Kaana who was a newbie then on that thread.

I used to read newbie threads & when I loved a post used to mark it for sharing on Sunday. Our late night 12 a.m. PMs discussing the episode! The long discussions - all because we loved Jodha Jalal so much. I also love Jodha more - for me it was always Jodha's Jalal that I loved.
I remember the Jalal pray for Jodha's life episode - the episode when Jalal Jodha have the discussion at night when she wakes up. There are so many episodes & scenes which are still everfresh in my mind.

How much Paridhi & Rajat lived JA roles - it is like they ARE JA. What chemistry their single eye lock had!

How much each JA forum member loved JA - to see it reduced to this level for the lack of creativity of CVs is painful. Wish they had just followed the story & viewers attachment with JA would have still kept it on top. You are right, I don't even care what is happening anymore.

Hope we meet on some other serial forum soon.

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon

Thanks Maddy for this Post. Got to read posts from many of our old friends today. Happy new Year to all of you. Hopefully soon we can meet up somewhere...

Originally posted by: Charu.S

I hardly interact on the forum these days Cleo.

It is really sad that this forum once a medium for lively discussions based on Jodha and Akbar is now dull and lifeless, thanks to EK.

There was absolutely no need for her to have taken the leap. There were still many historical aspects, social achievements, political and religious policies of Akbar, his relations with the Rajvanshis, the Portuguese, the expansion of his empire, the growth in his family etc,etc, to mention a few that could have been addressed in detail for a whole year, without having to be subjected to this utter nonsense in the name of leap.

To make matters worse, Jodha and Akbar do not look old enough to be parents of a grown up Salim. The storyline, screenplay, dialogues, everything is poor and I foresee a bleak future for the present track.

I've nothing against the new actors playing various roles. All of them are trying hard to prove themselves. However, Jodha and Akbar have left an indelible impression in our minds with their personalities and performance and it is impossible to see any other pair take their place, with a new story that is still being shown under the title of Jodha and Akbar.

Ekta could have treated the characters of Jodha and Akbar respectfully, by decently ending the serial post the birth of Salim. She could have then started the love saga of Salim/Anarkali. This would have been more acceptable and bearable.

Originally posted by: history_geek

@ myviewprem

How can i teach any thing to anyone, because i am still a learner & will continue to be so as no one is perfect, just trying to learn more from where ever possible. < With this thought i asked you something. If you read clearly, the word i used in my comment was a CLEAR "REQUEST made to you" in the very starting. Please see again.

If you think it was sarcasm , then let me assure you, it was not intended to be so. It was a genuine comment. I wanted to know more, as it is said knowledge can be taken from any place, hence the comment.

It is not a crime to quote anyone , as it was a post on open forum. Any ways, Ok. I will resist asking more questions to you in future. :D But, being an open forum one can comment on ANY THREAD, quote any one , as per COC , and i did it quite respectfully. I don't think one can moral police / advice / tell , not to comment / quote.

And, about the Kids details, that is not the part of discussion of this thread. Each to his own. I did not stop / tell anyone not to question me. Please do question me at the designated place (but not on this thread). Along with that, neither i commented on variety of details being posted here on many of your threads, though i have details contrary to what is being posted there.

Lastly and finally, I simply asked because, normally, i find my readings divergent from yours, though i also read from the "same" sources mentioned by you, but unable to find what was mentioned in your last comment.

PS :No where i said there is any "history" in your comment. I happened to read your comment first, on this thread, and hence could not resist the temptation to reply. I have already mentioned in my previous comment, we can use the sticky on forum for giving history references, as per forum rules. I do the same. :)

Originally posted by: deejagi

Hi Maddy thanks for giving me an opportunity to come on this (JA) forum and write something. I have totally stopped watching the show and even for the sake Paridhi & Rajat, it doesn't appeal to me to watch. And even though I come on IF, I try to avoid this forum because, it gives a sense of void to see nothing good in the serial and I can't imagine watching a lifeless JA. It hurts to remember a dead person and it is same feeling with JA for me. There is nothing left for us to dissect from their eyes, unsaid words, their distancing and their feelings for each other even when they were miles apart. Now I can't see that unquestioned togetherness even when they stay together. This Jalal whom we loved and nurtured didn't learn respect and trust his soul-mate (is what we thought) Jodha even after their kids were ready to learn warfare. The fierce Jodha whom we loved for her self respect and her dignity completely forgot the ABCD of that immediately after she thought she fell in loved with her husband. The great warrior didn't even thought of utilizing the same to teach her son the best warrior skills. She completely became a puppet which dances accordingly to the whims and fancy of her husband. The one who fought for the benefit of a orphan child and a small girl forgot to save her son from the clutches of the witch. Instead she walked her son directly to the den of a witch while she became an object of entertainment to her husband. I can't digest these two people whom the CVs are throwing on us.

Thank you Maddy and thanks to all my friends who agreed with my views earlier and also disagreed with my views ad that was such an healthy atmosphere and plot form. Hope we meet again sometime, somewhere. Goodnight friends and Happy New year.😊😊

Originally posted by: Donjas

Hi Maddy,

So nice to your post after a long time. Your post made me think, surely there should be accountability, historical figures need to be treated with respect.

As for the mystery of the leap, to me it is crystal clear, political pressure was put on Ekta to cut short the serial otherwise why would anyone in their right mind pull the plug on a top rated show. I may remind you that the Jodha Akbar situation was extensively used in the UP election(in context of Love Jihad) and it became a political hot potato.

So, Ekta, to preserve her other business interests, switched on the self-destruct button on Jodha Akbar.

It happens, I have accepted it and moved on but I still like to come to the forum once in a while.

Originally posted by: preetgurti

Was reading something
interesting expression is art which reflects the inner turmoil of human being
jodha akbar parijat gave us alot and was always want us asking more of them

Chehra woh aina hai jispe har lafz pada ja sakta hai
face is a mirror where u can read all

Parijat as akdha were so good that we love reading it that every word which there eyes said
ankhen bolti hai inki jiska har lafz hum samjhe


I don't know why what when the destruction happened and it was so evident with the quality of it getting down daily

kya din agaya hai amer beautiful palace now in a banjara tent house or rather I say north india shaadi ka tent
humare yahan aise hi hote hai