isnt javed bit a harsh? - Page 2

He is an honest judge and sometimes honesty appears to be harsh to people who want to be mollycoddled.

Suhit improved a lot and sings much better now. But Javed Saab was kinda rude. no offense

You call Javed harsh...wonder what would you call Simon Cowell?? 😉

I don't think he was harsh...atleast he is giving useful comments, unlike Alisha and Udit who are just warming their chairs. 😊

He isnt harsh.... he is being honest... he is much better than Alisha, who on day one says "you are a show stopper" and "What a performance" blah blah blah and then on day two says "the janta protected you, despite yesterdays performance being not so good"

If she were indeed supportive of him, she would stick to her guns and words.... not go ping pong on them like this. She is actually disturbing the morale of the singer.... putting him on a high on one day and then pulling him down the other day...

i think ppl shd accept criticism..a judge cannot be nice all the time..if suhit truly sang well..javed ji wldnt have a reason to criticize suhit..he is improving, but he is nowhere near the other contestants
javed ji speaks the truth..i respect him for tht 👏 👏

nope hes not harsh....the truth hurts!

JA ji is the best judge and he is there to judge. Not to be nice to feel some contestant's ego by lying. He has job to do and he gave constructive criticism. Alisha and Anu malik needs to be consistant about what are the criteria of II contest. If singing is not the most important thing than just removed that off and make contest abt looks, performance etc.