feeling sorry for jalal that his love does not care for his condition

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Sindhu Menon

@SindhuMenon

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: mandyg

Do not get personal here I m hating the cvz for butchering the real akbar and making jodha mahaanta ki devi...now how much have u read about the real jodha in history as compared to akbar? And have u read anywhere that it was because of her akbar became great? If u have then show me!

Honestly I do not think they are making Jodha mahan here.

Totally agree that Akbar was great emperor etc. But so far it is a Journey from Jalal to Akbar. Initially he was surrounded by wrong people who gave wrong advises and he was influenced by it as well. Definitely he changed along the way and this is what they are showing. The change cannot be just because of AKbar deceided to change himself. If so he could have been what he was later from the beginning itself. Jodha definitely had a hand in changing him, I mean support him. There is nothing wrong with that. So far I have not felt that what ever Jalal did was because of Jodha. Of course she has guided him but she never even have proclaimed that she has done it all.

I think what is happening here is we all are fed up of this separation track. It has been long honestly I want my AKdha back AsAP. I guess we will have to wait one more week,

Quote

Sara

@smile.sara

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: biancay

whatever the reason she took poison .it was very brave thing to do even for rajvanish kartavya
don't belittle her for that .you must have found hundred more reasons to critisize her since the beginning of the show .

Mandy ...I always wonder ...she took poison didn't give her and her brother right to break rule and law like this ... She took poison doesn't give her right to go outside like this and lie to king ... She took poison. Can't give her brother to take a promise from her to hide things from her husband ...she took poison doesn't give right to her brother to enter Mughal harem as eunuch and her taking poison doesn't give her brother to slaughter hundreds of Mughal soldiers inside Mughal fort... Tht was no war ground... Those Mughal soldiers also gave their lives for kings order after tht king and queen didn't have any heart for those Mughal soldiers and their families who also gave their lives bec of foolishness of these bro sis

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ghalibmirza

@ghalibmirza

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#13

Sidhumenon, more than separation it is frustration with illogical tracks..for a historical play the facts should be clear, whatever happened in history should be justified with intellect and logical tracks in keeping with what actually happened! Now showing jalal faking his death is beyond my understanding! I cannot agree with something like this being done with a real historical character that also in front of so many people...!

Quote

Sindhu Menon

@SindhuMenon

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: mandyg
Sidhumenon, more than separation it is frustration with illogical tracks..for a historical play the facts should be clear, whatever happened in history should be justified with intellect and logical tracks in keeping with what actually happened! Now showing jalal faking his death is beyond my understanding! I cannot agree with something like this being done with a real historical character that also in front of so many people...!

Faking death I agree...Even I did not like that. WHat to do with CV's...

Quote

ghalibmirza

@ghalibmirza

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: smile.sara

Mandy ...I always wonder ...she took poison didn't give her and her brother right to break rule and law like this ... She took poison doesn't give her right to go outside like this and lie to king ... She took poison. Can't give her brother to take a promise from her to hide things from her husband ...she took poison doesn't give right to her brother to enter Mughal harem as eunuch and her taking poison doesn't give her brother to slaughter hundreds of Mughal soldiers inside Mughal fort... Tht was no war ground... Those Mughal soldiers also gave their lives for kings order after tht king and queen didn't have any heart for those Mughal soldiers and their families who also gave their lives bec of foolishness of these bro sis

Sara...lol..cannot agree more! Can the cvz for a change justify the characters and make them close to the real ones. ..but sara that is not possible because how will they make money otherwise...sad really sad! I wish it was not about my idol akbar...!

Quote

979039

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: smile.sara

Mandy ...I always wonder ...she took poison didn't give her and her brother right to break rule and law like this ... She took poison doesn't give her right to go outside like this and lie to king ... She took poison. Can't give her brother to take a promise from her to hide things from her husband ...she took poison doesn't give right to her brother to enter Mughal harem as eunuch and her taking poison doesn't give her brother to slaughter hundreds of Mughal soldiers inside Mughal fort... Tht was no war ground... Those Mughal soldiers also gave their lives for kings order after tht king and queen didn't have any heart for those Mughal soldiers and their families who also gave their lives bec of foolishness of these bro sis

i am not at all taking about the above scenario or what she did or her brother did

why is her taking poison have anything to do with above scenario you described .by the way i never liked potrayal of jodha's character .jalal is the only character i liked in the show because his journey was well showcased .

just why do you have to critisize one selfless act of hers for whatever reasons she did kartavya or whatever . it is like when a soldier died fighting for the country don't we pay tribute to him or just say what is the big deal he is being paid salary to do it .

healthy criticism is always nice .but not endless debate getting old scenarios . it is like fighting court case

this only this thing i really appreciated in jodha's character

i am tired of endless fans bashing eachother . it is like fighting a defamation suit against eachother

ps :- i am very much jalal fan but i can appreciate good things in jodha too

Quote

ghalibmirza

@ghalibmirza

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#17

I liked jodha as kajri and I thought that is how the real jodha would have been. .and after that her emotions went gajini way..and akbar the great is reduced to a helpless lover in devdas mode..now is that the shahenshah-e-hind we know!

Quote

Sindhu Menon

@SindhuMenon

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: biancay

i am not at all taking about the above scenario or what she did or her brother did

why is her taking poison have anything to do with above scenario you described .by the way i never liked potrayal of jodha's character .jalal is the only character i liked in the show because his journey was well showcased .
just why do you have to critisize one selfless act of hers for whatever reasons she did kartavya or whatever . it is like when a soldier died fighting for the country don't we pay tribute to him or just say what is the big deal he is being paid salary to do it .
healthy criticism is always nice .but not endless debate getting old scenarios . it is like fighting court case
this only this thing i really appreciated in jodha's character

i am tired of endless fans bashing eachother . it is like fighting a defamation suit against eachother

ps :- i am very much jalal fan but i can appreciate good things in jodha too

well said.

I love both Jalal and Jodha for what they are equally..

Quote

taslim sayyad

@luvRTpari

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#19

i read all the comments here and i know that everybody have there own state of mind to think that way is right or not

i will agree that know the show is only running for trp and ppl attraction

to gain popularity nothing else i feel bad that when you really want to show all fiction then why to form a base of historical foundation using the character name you r defaming the royal name too

all else make it offical that its fiction why to even combine to say that its fiction with historical historic only for name sake

why to spilt jodha wrong or right or jalal restless character in this track

this track would have been the track in JA if thay have shown and exceutivated in a good manner with pain and passion both the side