Onir 1:Warning Pg6&16:Mod note Pg17 - Page 7

Originally posted by: Kalapi

I am very dumb (I accept😃) so am asking a few questions😃;

1. Where does Purvi/Onir live exactly? Last they showed, Purvi and Onir were arrested by the police cause they thought Purvi was a keep and Onir was enjoying her. The assumption was based for by the police for they lived in the red-light district. Please enlighten me if the Cvs have shown they have moved after that incident?

2. What happened to Arovi baby? Was the baby mourned for or seen by that baby's bioparents? Last I saw, Onir nonchalantly gave the baby away to a wardboy??? I didn't see any hindu funeral happening? And if it happened, did Arjun do the baby's last rites??

Am I wrong...for it seems members are openly bashing here saying these were not shown? Please enlighten me; I am waiting to see which particular episodes I missed...

Originally posted by: sk11

I don't know. As mentioned earlier savita friend live near purvi so it can't be red light district and a lot of kakis live there too. Seems pretty normal to me. I've always imagined red light district as place with bars and hotels etc..not homes.

Who knows Savita's friend might have moved into a red light area...but the police did pick Punir up for they were living there - clearly shown. So, members are not hallucinating here, are they???😔

Next, nobody knows what happend with arovi baby. Nobody really talked about arovi baby excpet when purvi bashing was included. people claim purvi threw it out in trash and no one cared etc. I wish I could see this episode. Anybody got a link?

Arovi baby has been talked extensively about, especially becuase no one mourned, nor funeral was shown - where Hindus have specific rites for an infant where family do mourn. Purvi directed and Onir gave the baby to a ward boy - it was shown. No rites were ever shown - so the assumption that the baby was thrown in the thrash or organs were harvested as many hospitals do (in fact one story was recently in news about organ trafficking by Indian hospita). So, assumption based on fact shown - again, no hallucination by members - so why bash members when contrary was shown???

Originally posted by: Kalapi

Originally posted by: pari87

rayadallie - I absolutely get that...I have seen your posts and you make comments with your own reasoning behind it, that is why my question was directed to you...PR is far from reality and I know that...But I watch shows for entertainment too but also the story...and stories I like that are relatable...that is how PR started initially as a story that was something people could relate to, the middle class family background, the characters seemed like someone you could identify in your real world too...now PR is a mess...and it looks like something written and show while being high on crack...

What logic would I use to defend a character if not for reasoning based in reality? Is logic differently reasoned when it is on a show versus in reality...? So then, Indian shows can show all sorts of modern 21st century stuff like wife swapping and what not, as part of entertainment but will audience accept it ? No, the show won't work because at some level you wanna see some semblance of reality in your entertainment ( unless you are a sci-fi or fantasy buff)...That is why when I see PR, I like/dislike a character much like how I would like/dislike someone like that in the real world. And that is how I base my reasoning on their actions. It has to match up. showing purvi as the most sanskaari middle class girl with sanskaar bhashans but then doing things that don't match up with her own sayings, is what doesn't make sense to me. Show her to be a modern liberal thinking girl, and I get her actions.

Anyway, like I said, I was questioning you because of your reasoning which had points...I was asnwering SK11 based on what he/she said about how each character is ultimately dependent on CV's so why bother debating...I debate because that is what IF for me is for...

Originally posted by: sk11

Again this has been discussed numerous times. All based upon assumptions.

Just bc they were picked up from this area it's a red light district now? Oh. Makes perfect sense.

You're right arovi baby wasn't mourned but was purvis baby shown getting the Hindu rites too since it was shown purvis baby died? I don't remember seriously...Is there a link? But just as much you're right arovi baby wasn't shown given any treatment nor was any scene shown where purvi or onir or nurse/ward boy throw a dead baby into a trash bin.

And you're confusing reality (news) with PR serial. Again based upon your assumptions. And you even said it yourself...it's assumed,

Originally posted by: sk11

Again this has been discussed numerous times. All based upon assumptions.

Just bc they were picked up from this area it's a red light district now? Oh. Makes perfect sense.

You're right arovi baby wasn't mourned but was purvis baby shown getting the Hindu rites too since it was shown purvis baby died? I don't remember seriously...Is there a link? But just as much you're right arovi baby wasn't shown given any treatment nor was any scene shown where purvi or onir or nurse/ward boy throw a dead baby into a trash bin.

And you're confusing reality (news) with PR serial. Again based upon your assumptions. And you even said it yourself...it's assumed,

Originally posted by: rayadallie

@missscarlett bang on in your last post. Sometimes I too am tired of such arguments. It was not shown so why harp on it. In many of my post I would have mentioned that the CV's cannot show us each and every aspect in a character life in the show as it would take ages to get a twist an that would be at christmas each year when we get a new twist.

Originally posted by: Missscarlett

I think its high time that people accept that this is a tv show not reality. The cvs cant show each and everything that different people want. They have to cut back. I dont think that showing the baby's last rites would have done anything to move the story forward as they were concentrating on purvi and her antiques of baby donation at that time.
What surprises me is the amount of hate brewing in this forum for purvi! Lolz. Saying and assuming that a person threw a innocent baby in trash just because u dislike a character shocks and disgusts me!