Debate of the week!_Old vs New - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

89

Views

10.7k

Users

19

Frequent Posters

Fluidd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#51
Roja akka you started very well. Giri akka sooper. Atha alavukku yennala yezhutha mudiyaathu, but I had written what I know and cud to my level.

Reg. years for old and new songs: y 18 yrs for New songs (1990 - 2007) and 16 yrs for Old songs (1975 - 1989)?

Why not we can have Old from 1975 to 1992

and New from 1993 to 2007 (its is more than one generation for New songs)
jenim thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#52
Interesting topic.. and very good discussion so far.

I know I'm not part of any team here, but I have a song in mind for the old songs team. If not appropriate, please let me know, so I can remove it.

Vairamuthu's "Idhu Oru Pon Maalai Pozhudhu" - Wow.. What a karpanai from the poet, personifying the the sky at dusk as a blushing girl. I've heard this song many a times as I was growing up and the comparisons made in this song was always beyond me. When I finally figured it out, the music and the meaning almost made me ecstatic. I would classify this song under the "cheering up" category.

rojapoooo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#53
well done Fluidd - It is the turn of the other
team now, we shall wait. Meli, we should probably
move this debate to a new thread - minus the
discussions - so that the mod will find it easier
to sum up, what say?? And a word to all our team
mates. As per the rule, each of us get one chance
in the first round. The mod will give us situations/
topics in the second round and we can elect 3 from
our 7 to place counter/augmenting arguments. We can
PM each other and arrive at our conclusive post. Please make sure to wait for your turn, we have to make only
alternate posts. Jas, Kavi, Vinu, Jay and Jagdu - one of
u to post after our opponents post theirs.
jasunap thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: giriadimai

Hello everyone,

I am under the impression that this debate is on a lighter topic & it is supposed to provide us some fun and laughter like the patti mandapams we are forced with, by all our tamil channels during festival holidays. So I give my opening speech in tamil. Hope you will bear with me for this😳😃.

Madhippirkuriya naduvar avargale ,anbana periyorgale thaimaargale, enadhu katchiyai serndha Caryn, Karthikka, Usha, Netra, Vani, Pokkri anaivarukkum en vanakkam. Kazhudhaikku theriyumo karpoora vaasanai enru solvaargal. Adhu pola, indha pattimandabathil ennai pudhiya padalgal enra thalaippil pesa utkaara vaithu vittargal. Kazhudaikku unmaiyileye karpooram vasanai pidikka theriyuma enru ennakku theriyadhu, aanal pudiya paadalkalin vaasanaiyai moppam pidithu , adhil moozghi muthu edukka vandhullen😃.

Indha ulagathil engum niranbi iruppadhu Anbu. Adharkku pala parimanangal undu – kaadhal , paasam, nesam. Kaadhalai arumaiyaga velipaduthum pala pudu paadalgal irukinrana.


very true giri. what you say here is true..pala parimanangal endru sonnele that is true and is sung rather blatantly in the following song where the hero is in total distress and he has one question in mind that is bothering him in toto. So unable to withstand the stress he finally asks the heroine:

"Kalyanam dhan kattikittu odi polamaa?
Odi Poyi kalyanam dhan kattikalama?

and then you find out that the herione too had another very important question in mind and she replies by asking:

Thaaliya than kattikittu pethukalama?
Illa pulla kutti pethukittu kattikalama?

The above song is a perfect example that wonderfully framed phrase
..pala parimanangal undu – kaadhal , paasam, nesam and exemplifies the ethical or social dichotomy that exists in our current socities.

Let me tell you a situation, the lead pair gets married and on their nuptial night, they have a song and dance sequence

"Athikaai kaai kaai aalangai venilavae………..

kannikkaay aasaikkaay kaadhalkonda paavaikkaay
angaekaay avaraikkaai mangai endhan koavaikkaay…"

(Please don't jump on me because this is from a movie of 1960s😉. I am not trying to criticize the lyrics here, actually it creates a good ambience for the couple to get ready for the next day's kitchen duties).

have you listened to this this song from thirumalai???

dhimsu kattai ay ay dhimsu kattai ay ay
yaendi ennai keduthuputta?
koothu katta ay ay koothu katta ay ay
yedhukku ennai saethukitta?
pappaLa paLa pappaLa paLa pappaaLi pazhamey
thathaLa thaLa thathaLa thaLa thakkaaLi pazhamey
gumthalakkadi jumthalakkadi jootachu manasae
aythalakkadi aythalakkadi kettaachu manasae
honestly...hand in your heart, tell us what this prepares you for????😉😉

But in such a situation, were he to sing

"Goly gundu kannu (edhir katchi thalaivar ennai parthu idhu pola paaratti irukiraar😆), kova pazha odhadu, paala pola pallu, padiya veccha vagidu, aalai thinnum kannam, alatikkaadha kai, solathatta kaalu, sokka vaikkum vaai…"

This song also has milk, vegetable , maize crop.. 😃Still, wouldn't the lady be floored? This is taken from a movie Emtan Magan.

Idhu ponra manadhai mayakka koodiya paadal varigalai kondadhu, pudiya paadalgale enru koori , engal anikku valu serkka innum pala vaadhangalai en katchikaarargal veipaargal enbadhai ninaivupaduthi vaaippukku nanri koorugiren. Vanakkam😊


yes, you are right giri...but do compare the song you have mentioned with the lines i quote...a song sung by p susheela..(i dont know which movie tho)
unnaik kaanaadha kannum kannalla
unnai ennaadha nenjum nenjalla
nee sollaadha sollum sollalla
nee illaamal naanum naanalla (2)

ingu neeyoru paadhi naanoru paadhi
idhil yaar pirindhaalum vaedhanai paadhi
kaalangal maarum kaatchigal maarum
kaadhalin munnae neeyum naanum vaeralla

what more can you ask where romance is concerned????


P.S – We also ensure that we will not hurt the feelings of anyone, but do everything within our means to justify our stand😃.

supree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: Vinuthasri

where is supree? She participates in lyrics game thread and knows lot of old songs.
vaanga supree. :)

Vandhuten Vinu, Vandhutten!! But late-a... 😊

Somehow missed this thread and just now saw it. Very interesting topic. And you are right, Naan correct time-mukku vanthirunthal..... Old songs pakkam than poga idea!. 😉 So far, rendu side-um summa thool kilappittanga 👏 👏 Will enjoy reading!

girivanam thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: rojapoooo

Meli, we should probably
move this debate to a new thread - minus the
discussions - so that the mod will find it easier
to sum up, what say??

Please don't move, instead copy the arguments. We need to refer back and forth😃.

Caryn, Karthikka, Netra, Vani, Pokkri, Madhu.. enna orutharaiyum kanome? Enna thaniya vittu poiteengala?😕

Fluidd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: supree

Vandhuten Vinu, Vandhutten!! But late-a... 😊

Somehow missed this thread and just now saw it. Very interesting topic. And you are right, Naan correct time-mukku vanthirunthal..... Old songs pakkam than poga idea!. 😉 So far, rendu side-um summa thool kilappittanga 👏 👏 Will enjoy reading!

Supree my dear Super e vaanga vaanga 🤗🤗🤗, ungal romba miss panninom lyrics thread la naanum Vinu vum (yenna Vinu seri thaane), yenga poiteenga?

Neega illama old songs aa? late aa vanthaalum latest aa vantheega. waiting for ur kalakals.

Fluidd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: Fluidd


Reg. years for old and new songs: y 18 yrs for New songs (1990 - 2007) and 16 yrs for Old songs (1975 - 1989)?

Why not we can have Old from 1975 to 1992

and New from 1993 to 2007 (its is more than one generation for New songs)

Pls. Judges consider the yrs. If u say 1990 is new, all yrs less than 1990 is old only, then why 1975 restriction. We have extremely excellent songs with lyrics are there? I hope Vinu, Supree and Jas will agree with me.

287618 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#59
Yes I was wondering the same fluid , but our viewbie said that ppl might not know songs before that ?
usha_pooja thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#60
Hey guys, my part of the debate will come this weekend or next week end of due to exams. So, I see what i can do. Sorry guys.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".