An honest comparison between Shankar and Shaan

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

navaneeta

@navaneeta

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#91

Originally posted by: somone999
@ Killer007 and navaneeta

Please Relax. MKMM is going to end soon. I think we all should join our hands for peace and a good farewell for each other, rather than fight. Please Forgive Each Other for whatever you both said. End it.

@ someone999

Nothing personal about anyone .... I have even clarified one of your post on that .... your posts are never personal and directed to any forum members and expressions are your POV .... which is fine as a forum does not mean some would say something and others always say YES to that ... everyone can share their POV, idea, counter any comment in a proper manner and decorum rather can being personal to any forum members ... you must have seen so many posts in so many different manner .. some are healthy arguments .. some are fun filled sensations so that all enjoy good time reading and posting in the forum ...

Telling this obhiously people takes things personally when you see any member posting personal comments by name calling .. x, n, r, s, b, b etc and using bad words like chopped ...

- Enjoy the grand finale of Jala Do .. Bujha Do theme .....

Quote

somone999

@somone999

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#92

Originally posted by: navaneeta

- When other tell bad to others (except Shaan) - that's fun mood

- When Shaan team get less marks by one person - Those are respectful people

Well, i would like to just comment on the things that you have quoted against me and which i Openly accept as my Personal Point Of views.

First of all, i am not a person who has any grudge against Shaan, i am huge fan of his singing. When i say that what Shankar ji said, it was said in a fun mood, i genuinely felt that it was said in a fun way, because everyone smiled and laughed at that point. If you disagree feel free to do so. But that is my POV and you have your POV. It is not meant to be agreeable always. Xobile accepted my POV and i respect him for that.

Secondly, If i say that Javed Saab is a respectable person that does not mean that other judges are not to be respected. I said that because i saw a lot INTOLERABLE comments about his age, his psyche and god know's what not! That is what i wanted to say, That crticizing is fine, but Using such ABUSIVE words for such a talented experienced man, is really too much. That is what i felt and that is what I reflected in my posts.

Other than that, I have no association with what other people say and neither i have any linkage with any of your remaining stated points.

It is my POV and i am entitled to it. I respect your POV as well. Thanks.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

somone999

@somone999

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#93

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

someone999, I have nothing against your posts and I think that you put forth your points in a very civilized manner. You may have noticed that I have even supported you a few times.

Of course everyone has a right to argue their POV. As long as they do it in a civilized manner, nothing matters. After all, this is a forum and the purpose is to discuss one's POV.

However, there are a few people here, that try their best to instigate others. When someone sees a statement like this:
" Shaan's Fan ... x,r,n,s, b, b etc ... keep defending EVEN AFTER BEING CHOPPED" ....
especially from a newbie what is one supposed to decipher? Every x, very r, very n, every s, every b and every b who is Shaan's supporter will be forced to think that it is he/she that is being talked about. It only increases the unrest over here.

Both you and I would like to see the same thing. Peace in the forum! There is nothing wrong with healthy discussions and having some fun. As long as there is no name-calling or personal attacks, it is fine!

I agree with you bambooshoot. But, being Senior members we should be the ones who should handle this in a better way. This whole argument thing just spoils the whole atmosphere.
But anyways, i just wanted Peace here that is why asked them to end it. Anyways, Enjoy MKMM as it lasts! 😊

Quote

bambooshoot

@bambooshoot

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#94

Originally posted by: somone999

I agree with you bambooshoot. But, being Senior members we should be the ones who should handle this in a better way. This whole argument thing just spoils the whole atmosphere.
But anyways, i just wanted Peace here that is why asked them to end it. Anyways, Enjoy MKMM as it lasts! 😊

Yes of course! You may not see a huge number on my post list, but I've been on this forum for more than 4 years and have been following this forum for a long time although I haven't posted extensively.

I can tell you one thing. Not everything is under everyone's control. Sometimes someone suddenly popus up in the middle of a healthy discussion with some instigating comments that can completely change the direction of a healthy discussion. It takes time to learn the ways of this forum.

Yes, I do agree that there has been some name-calling with respect to his age etc. But I have always condemned them. I have never seen Navaneeta participating in name-calling. I have just seen her put forth her views along with having lot of fun. Having fun just helps reduce the tension out there.

Since we cannot control everyone and everything in this forum, all we can do is to ourselves try to stay healthy in our discussions.

Quote

redapple1

@redapple1

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#95

Thank God "All izz well" 👏👏 My sincere request, please don't quote 'x, r, n, b,b'...

Quote

somone999

@somone999

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#96

So, Everybody is cool right? FINALLY!! 😊

Honestly, keep things light everyone. This is not a matter of life and death. Just relax 😊

Yup, i really hope "aal izz well" now 😳

Quote

sharmila2009

@sharmila2009

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#97

I fully agree with you. I knew the drama going to be enacted on this stage. I think everything is fixed. But so far the regular viewers are concerned, atleast for their sake the captains like Shankar shold have shown some respect ,dignity towards their age, position & experience..... It was very annoying to see Shankar trying to show his own power of singing on this stage ( though I dint see the full lengt of his performance ever.)Who wants to hear him?????.. It was very funny & low to behave the way he did...He behaved like a desperate ....He was literally competing with the strugglers & infants in this profession.......I dint expect him to stoop so low......

For me I could hear Shankar sing as I used to switch on this prog only when there was the turn of Shaan's team...as i am a great fan of Anwesha...

But for Shaan, showing his anger was quite justified.. though he could have kept quiet as well...but at least he is honest & rightfully fought for his team... he was a team player .... given every opportunity to all his singers..... He dint come repeatedly like other captains specially Shankar just to win...Shaan may not be as good as Shankar as a singer but as far as listening I think people prefer Shaan over Shankar ...for sure...Like Alka I too agree difficult song should not be the criteria for judging a performance....it should touch your heart...

We respect Shaan for that ...No one is blind...everyone understands what is right & what is wrong...

Javed Akhtar may be a good lyricist, But I always doubted his judgement of the singers... .......like Farha ... she also was made a judge of some singing competition....funny......

No comment on other team as i never watched their show...

Edited by sharmila2009 - 15 years ago

Quote

nithyak

@nithyak

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#98

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

Yes of course! You may not see a huge number on my post list, but I've been on this forum for more than 4 years and have been following this forum for a long time although I haven't posted extensively.

I can tell you one thing. Not everything is under everyone's control. Sometimes someone suddenly popus up in the middle of a healthy discussion with some instigating comments that can completely change the direction of a healthy discussion. It takes time to learn the ways of this forum.

Yes, I do agree that there has been some name-calling with respect to his age etc. But I have always condemned them. I have never seen Navaneeta participating in name-calling. I have just seen her put forth her views along with having lot of fun. Having fun just helps reduce the tension out there.

Since we cannot control everyone and everything in this forum, all we can do is to ourselves try to stay healthy in our discussions.

No you dont condemn them but you encourage others to bash members and judges and you even reached to Javedji's wife.

Quote

navaneeta

@navaneeta

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#99

Nityak, a request for you ....

Please do not instigate fight.

The post which you have cut pasted was a fun post and none of the forum members were based out there ... would anyone get angry on a Jonny Lever type acto for fun for any actor/ celebs? and moreso this post is old for more that 1 week, suddenly bringing up this one in a different thread now would only instigate fight ....

On the post topic, it was pure fun on a desperate attempt to find out the logic of pre-finale medly of Shankar and that too that was on the seperate thread and not this one ...

We do have seperate threads on various topics, some discussions and healthy arguments and some fun posts. And the irrational marks of JA (which was ratified by all other Jury members) stunned all of us ...

I have seen various occasion when bambooshoot even requested members not to put bad comments againts other team and forum members and those request were for Shaan supporters only ...

If any issue we have we have posted (I have posted atleast) that for the show producer where as audience we fell dejected, and put forward our POV ... but no direct member bashing please ... It's a request from another IF friend ....

Please, the show has ended and we, the forum members are trying to enjoy the forum and keep a good experience of IF. Things have ended and none of us want the last lap to be bitter experience of IF forum members fight ... ending as someone999 said ... All Izz Well ....

Edited by navaneeta - 15 years ago

Quote

nithyak

@nithyak

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#100

Originally posted by: navaneeta
Nityak, a request for you ....

Please do not instigate fight.

The post which you have cut pasted was a fun post and none of the forum members were based out there ...

On the post topic, it was pure fun on a desperate attempt to find out the logic of pre-finale medly of Shankar and that too that was on the seperate thread and not this one ...

We do have seperate threads on various topics, some discussions and healthy arguments and some fun posts. And the irrational marks of JA (which was ratified by all other Jury members) stunned all of us ...

I have seen various occasion when bambooshoot even requested members not to put bad comments againts other team and forum members and those request were for Shaan supporters only ...

If any issue we have we have posted (I have posted atleast) that for the show producer where as audience we fell dejected, and put forward our POV ... but no direct member bashing please ... It's a request from another IF friend ....

Please, the show has ended and we, the forum members are trying to enjoy the forum and keep a good experience of IF. Things have ended and none of us want the last lap to be bitter experience of IF forum members fight ... ending as someone999 said ... All Izz Well ....