Shaan also came twice... - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

68

Views

5.9k

Users

24

Likes

133

Frequent Posters

redapple1 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#31
<sarcasm>
The captains and team in this show forgot to make a pledge.
We agree to:

Treat our opponents and the officials with respect
Encourage & expect fair play from our teammates
Accept defeat with grace and be humble in victory
Make the team more important than ourselves

</sarcasm>
LOL
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: redapple1

<sarcasm>
The captains and team in this show forgot to make a pledge.
We agree to:

Treat our opponents and the officials with respect
Encourage & expect fair play from our teammates
Accept defeat with grace and be humble in victory
Make the team more important than ourselves

</sarcasm>
LOL



Wonderful👏👏👏..
Go Amul Shaan Strikers⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️..

bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: nithyak

All the songs are rehearsed with both the teams and the orchestra before the final shoot.Both the captains and team members know who is going to sing what. Superb planning by the producer, good execution by the judges and their team members.
We fight here over a scripted show. Exactly what the producer wants. More publicity for his show. 😆

@nithyakji
Your words remind me so much about someone. He used to open such nice topics for everyone to discuss. He also used to give us some insider information. I miss him soooo much😭😭😭.
Another person had also given us insider information after this show that during the round where Anwesha sang, Sharib was supposed to come against her. Instead Shankarji came!
I don't have any regrets about this as he found Anwesha worthy of competing with, and also we got to hear his brilliant singing. But I do feel very bad about Sharib who lost an opportunity to show us his talent and portray his abilities.
nithyak thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#34
@bamboo,

Whom do you miss? i did not get you.
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: nithyak

@bamboo,

Whom do you miss? i did not get you.

Since you really want to know, I miss Raghuraj. His thoughts were very similar to yours😃.
Anyways, here's hoping for the best outcome.....
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

@nithyakji
Your words remind me so much about someone. He used to open such nice topics for everyone to discuss. He also used to give us some insider information. I miss him soooo much😭😭😭.



😳
nithyak thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: bambooshoot



Since you really want to know, I miss Raghuraj. His thoughts were very similar to yours😃.


Anyways, here's hoping for the best outcome.....



Now I understand what you mean . I have already received PMs from 3 Shaan supporters including Safeena, indirectly asking if Nithyak is Raghuraj.

I feel am being harassed.

So let us set things straight.

I request the moderator @ -anonymous to check and clarify if the members nithyak and raghuraj are the same persons. Please check the IP address of both these ids.

Here are profile links of both the ids:

Nithyak:
http://www.india-forums.com/member_profile.asp?PF=482425

Raghuraj:
http://www.india-forums.com/member_profile.asp?PF=322180
bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#38

@nithyakji

You say you got PMs from 3 Shaan supporters. Since you have named safeena, please name the other 2 persons as well.
See, there is nothing against either you or Raghuraj. It's just that we had got very used to some intelligent topics and miss those discussions, and your words remind me of him. There is nothing wrong with missing old friends, and remembering them, is there? 😃
baghabayen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: bambooshoot

@nithyakji
Your words remind me so much about someone. He used to open such nice topics for everyone to discuss. He also used to give us some insider information. I miss him soooo much😭😭😭.
Another person had also given us insider information after this show that during the round where Anwesha sang, Sharib was supposed to come against her. Instead Shankarji came!
I don't have any regrets about this as he found Anwesha worthy of competing with, and also we got to hear his brilliant singing. But I do feel very bad about Sharib who lost an opportunity to show us his talent and portray his abilities.



I also feel the same, their posts are very similar to each other.And i miss raghu ji much much more than you do bambooshoot.Come back raghu ji.😉

Edited by baghabayen - 15 years ago
PIPC thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: ts9787

I just watched the Shaan vs. Shreya match yesterday. I know the discussions the last couple of weeks have been about how much of a cheat Shankar is for coming to sing twice, but there is NO mention of Shaan doing the exact same thing in his match against Shreya? Even Shreya sang twice. Why is it cheating when Shankar does it but not when Shaan does it? Are you guys that blind after Shaan? And don't say it was because Shreya herself went to sing because Shaan had to be prepared for the song (as evidenced by the background dancers being there to dance). And the second time Shaan went, he went FIRST! I like Shaan too, but the blatant favoritism of Shaan and the use of bad words for Shankar, Shreya and the other judges is ridiculous!



Very nice topic...But, you overlooked some very important things...
Abhi hum bolega to bologe ki bolta hai... 😆 😆
But, bolna to padega, bhai.........

Firstly, none called Shankarji a 'CHEAT' as you mentioned... Shankarji is a very talented and revered musician of our country. Whoever respects music will never call a great musician cheat.
However, his actions were termed unfair due to some reasons...Some of the fellow members have already said it...I am gonna reiterate my POV so that we stop comparing two totally different situations here.

In the holi episode, it was Shreya's call to decide who will sing in the Tata Docomo round and she decided to come and sing...Did you really expect Shaan to send Debojit, Harshit, Anwesha or Shadab to sing in that situation? Throughout the MKMM programme, whenever a captain from a team sang, his/her counterpart from the other playing team came to sing himself/herself because
that's the most just and sensible thing to do in that situation ....

Jab ek raja yudhh ko aata hai, to dusra raja khud ladne aata hai...Agar nahin aata to yeh dusre raja ke shaan mein gustakhi hoti hai...Har cheez ka ek decorum hota hai mere dost...😊


ok..next comes the 'muqabla dil se' round....It was Shaan's call this time and he chose to sing with Anwesha. It was his prerogative to decide who would sing from his team and he decided to do it himself.
It would have been unfair if Shreya sent a contestant from her team other than herself and Shaan chose to compete against a contestant. Shreya came next with Aneek to sing in this round....

So, first round was Shreya versus Shaan and second round was Shaan+Anwesha versus Shreya+Aneek....So, where do you see the anomaly and disparity my friend? Where did Shaan go wrong? It was a fair competition.

Nobody has objection to Shankarji coming twice to sing. I would love to listen to Shankarji's singing till eternity and beyond..
But, don't you think that it was an unfair competition when Shankarji pits himself against Anwesha or Shadab? If you think it is fair, then I rest my case..
Shankarji against any of these judges will win hands down, let alone any of the contestants....

There were very important and very logical dynamics involved when Shankarji was called unfair on account of coming twice....
Shankarji and Shaan both came twice...But, still Shankarji was very unfair in doing so and Shaan was very fair in doing so....HOW?
The answer lies in the sentence written below:
It has got a lot to do with the reasons that caused the captain to come on stage and not the same number of presence and performance of the captain on the stage.

Love the fact that Shaan's supporters are sensible and not the blind supporters who want to justify their captain's act by comparing situations which are totally different altogether...
Edited by PIPC - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".