Shaan also came twice... - Page 3

Originally posted by: slumdog

Himmesh didnt come coz he knows that his team member are far better than himself.

forget HIMESHJI'S songs selling the most, forget him being the only singer in bollywood performed at world international stadiums of 35 thousand seats in hOLLAND & WEMBLEY making INDIA proud,

maybe when SHANKAR SAYING IT IS BIG HONOR TO BE COMPETING AGAINST HR AND MOHIT SAYING HE IS SO SINCERE TALKING ABOUT LOVE OF PARENTS IN SPITE OF BEING THE BIGGEST MUSICAL AND SINGING STAR.

that 2 words should have reminded you of how big of a musical star HR is !

but you just want the follow the path of losers, that's ur way.

Oh dear...

Can anyone tell me good songs/albums in 2010 of Himesh, Shankar & Shaan?
I only know Shreya's because of her nominations/awards.

Originally posted by: bebe nanno

Oh dear...

Can anyone tell me good songs/albums in 2010 of Himesh, Shankar & Shaan?
I only know Shreya's because of her nominations/awards.

Well one comment on the topic od Shaan also came twice ....

Originally posted by: navaneeta

Well one comment on the topic od Shaan also came twice ....

- First Shreya came to sing

then it was Shaan team's turn to send someone ... Shaan already sufferred during Shankar's match due to this, so that time he came and performed .. Dus Bahane .... both got 9.5

In the duet round .... It was known Shreya is gonna come, so Shaan came against Shreya ... so fair play ... captain vs. captain ... this time Shaan was ready with his songs and the same event like Shankar's did not happened ....

While all other captains complete against contestant, please notice Shaan never has done that .. .when he sang his fathers song, that time also Shankar was on the opposite ....

Look into facts before putting comments .... Shaan comming twice had a concrete reason .. he just can make his team loose because on the opposite captains are performing ..... but never ever he performed against any contestant .... Shaan maintained his dignity and position .... truly respectable

Shankar protrayed his humility, he clarified that he considers himself equal to his members if you have seen the medley episode. All captains treat their teams differently in their own way, so there should not be an argument on who came twice. Shankar is just a member of the team who considered it appropriate to give lead to his team and the same THOUGHT was at the back of the mind of Shreya and Shaan when they came twice, its all for the team. and no one has lost their DIGNITY here. we should appreciate that the captains came and gave us the chance to listen to their lovely numbers.
The thought process is same, just the biased-ness towards one team makes one blur out the efforts of the other team. Nothing Unfair has been done here, it is a competition and the teams are here to win, and whatever strategy is adopted within the RULES, is perfectly applicable. thanks.

I cannot agree 100% with you .... Shankar telling him just a contestant does not work out .... that way judges shoudl give him marks and he get singer of the day as well ....

- so then no captain should come out because then everyone will say that it is because he has no confidence in his team!!! all the singers in Shankar's rockstars has won a SINGER of the DAY, so please do not use this plea that he does not have confidence in his team. He came there to ensure a lead for his team, whether it is of 1 mark or 0.5 mark. it is perfectly acceptable.

- Shankar has humility that he can come up whenever the need arises. Shaan does not want to come, it is his personal approach. but the simple thing is when the captains can come, so they can come, you should not raise an objection to this fact at least.,because Shaan has also come out to sing for his team, had he not come in, then i would have accepted your opinion.

- The basic strategy behind keeping this rule for the captain to come anytime by MKMM authorities, is that the teams can use this rule to call their captain to ensure a lead for them. This rule won't have any significance if you keep it between captains and captains, both will have the same score. So, Shaan has been given all the opportunities to come, if he doesn't then it is his choice. if shankar ji wants to come, it is his choice. I don't know why people exclude the captains from their teams, they are part of the team! just like a member! they have every right to come.

- The system of MKMM calls it perfectly fine for the captains to come, so who are you and i to say that it is not fair?. It is a competition for god's sake! it is not a search for the best singer of the nation, it is a selection of the best consistent competitive team.

- Listen, the judges are not some low-class people, they have struggled and learned so much and have now come to this stage. they know much better than you or me. so please i think you should not pass derogatory remarks on them. they have brains and had they given 5 or 7, i would have accepted it, and had they given 10, still i would have accepted it, because i do not consider myself equal to their abilities, so i cannot condemn them, it is their decision. please respect that.

Originally posted by: somone999

-

- Listen, the judges are not some low-class people, they have struggled and learned so much and have now come to this stage. they know much better than you or me. so please i think you should not pass derogatory remarks on them. they have brains and had they given 5 or 7, i would have accepted it, and had they given 10, still i would have accepted it, because i do not consider myself equal to their abilities, so i cannot condemn them, it is their decision. please respect that.

How true.
Very well written. 👏 👏 👏

@ Somone999 ......

i believe that if this was a GROOMING show, then captains should not have been allowed to come in the first place. but since it is a rule, captains can come, unfortunately then the team supporters would have to feel bad whenever the captain comes from the opposite team. it's natural sentiment i can understand.
Judges give out their own POV, that is why the audience vote is separate and judges vote is separate. no one is forcing the other. it is logical you see. it is not compulsory that the audience and judges have to match their score all the time.
Well, shouting has been done by a lot of other people as well.. so i don't want to get into that discussion. otherwise i can give loads of examples as well.

Anyways, Chill out and learn to see the teams by coming into their shoes as well. Extract the best things from all the teams not just one. Bollywood is not here because of one particular singer, all are here to provide variety, so enjoy the music that all the captains have to offer. I get happy whenever any captain comes, because as a Neutral Viewer, i love to listen to these great singers. and since, the captains do not have any objection to it, we all should also not object on this point. thanks.