Shaan also came twice... - Page 2

Originally posted by: ts9787

I just watched the Shaan vs. Shreya match yesterday. I know the discussions the last couple of weeks have been about how much of a cheat Shankar is for coming to sing twice, but there is NO mention of Shaan doing the exact same thing in his match against Shreya? Even Shreya sang twice. Why is it cheating when Shankar does it but not when Shaan does it? Are you guys that blind after Shaan? And don't say it was because Shreya herself went to sing because Shaan had to be prepared for the song (as evidenced by the background dancers being there to dance). And the second time Shaan went, he went FIRST! I like Shaan too, but the blatant favoritism of Shaan and the use of bad words for Shankar, Shreya and the other judges is ridiculous!

Originally posted by: apparaohoare

I agree that Shaan came twice against Shreya's team but the situations were totally different. When Shaan came, he was competing against another captain. Shaan was not competing against Ujjaini or Rahman. He was competing against Shreya (both times and same goes for Shreya).

However, when Shankar came to sing twice, he was competing against a 16 year old Anwesha and a chupa rustam Shadab. So, that was not fair on Shankar's part. I am a big fan of Shankar too, but I found his act disgraceful.

It was disgraceful the way Shaan reacted. If it was shaan who did the same Shankar would never have reacted the same way.

Originally posted by: saq123

I certainly have no complaints. Always have njoyd the captains' performances wenever dey came. Most singers have had good exposure earlier also. Wish chupa rustams could have got more chances though. All r very talented and if they remain focused, grounded and most importantly make the most of the chances that come their way, they will achieve great success. Maybe, we will see some of them judging such shows in the future. I think it is important that captains supported their teams and tried to get them to the finals because the major exposure will be in the finals only. So, the singers who get to sing then will have no complaints about their captains hogging the limelight earlier. Me rooting for a Shaan-Shreya final personally. Love them.

Originally posted by: SidraLuvMayurBL

<font color="#ff00ff">@bold: EXACTLY! it was fair by all means... but in shankar's case.. that was an unfair move... that was an unfair lost that shaan had... =(</font>

Shankar didn't know whether the caption or a singer would come

All the songs are rehearsed with both the teams and the orchestra before the final shoot.Both the captains and team members know who is going to sing what. Superb planning by the producer, good execution by the judges and their team members.
We fight here over a scripted show. Exactly what the producer wants. More publicity for his show. 😆

Originally posted by: KaJen1

Shankar didn't know whether the caption or a singer would come

Both times Shankar came to sing in the second position. First Shadab sang then came Shanker. Then Anwesha sang and Shankar came after that.

Originally posted by: rahul_02006

It was disgraceful the way Shaan reacted. If it was shaan who did the same Shankar would never have reacted the same way.

Not a single judge has a problem with the fact of coming TWICE.. there are three captains who came twice in a show, so Since they do not have a problem with that, so we all should also not discard it as an UNFAIR act. please control yourselves when talking about the great singers of the country. they can employ the strategies within the Rules.
Shankar ji considers himself as a part and member of the team, it shows his humility, he wants to achieve success for his team, respect his humble feelings. and Shaan is similarly doing a good job for his team and so is Shreya. So their should not be an argument on that.
Just enjoy the show and its musical entertainment as it lasts! Chill out!. thanks

Originally posted by: slumdog

Himmesh didnt come coz he knows that his team member are far better than himself.

this shows what u will say or do to fool urself. how low u can go down to bring down urself to lowest of the lowest! there is no such thing as brain for u i guess!