Moderation/Section Feedback :) - Note 49 - Page 7

That's another problem. Let's not 'assume' things so quickly because they cause arguements and piss most members.

Originally posted by: nureat01

I have a question....has it occurred to anyone in here that by labelling one thread as the creatives 'appreciation' thread, it is automatically giving a negative connotation to the other thread as if it was made for the sole intention of 'bashing'.<br><br>I thought feedback on what needs to be worked on in this show was the whole purpose of the critics corner....anyways, whatever works....although I do think a better name for the seperate thread would be the 'song suggestions' thread since that's what seems to mainly happen in there. <br>

oh well...a lot of people suggested opening another thread for suggestions was the best option... n critics review thread was meant for critque...its another thing tht people hardly know trhe difference between critiqu and bashing..but tht the least of my concern...

also i dont mind it being called a suggestions thread and taking out the appreciation part..coz we hardly did that there till now any ways 😆 😆 😆 also I wont quite call it a song suggestion thread..just coz its been open for 2 hrs.. n ppl talked of songs...i am sure scenes and other suggestions would come up too...

so I think these 2 threads are best kept separate for forum peace 🤣 almost sounded like global peace 🤣

Originally posted by: sonali.19281

oh well...a lot of people suggested opening another thread for suggestions was the best option... n critics review thread was meant for critque...its another thing tht people hardly know trhe difference between critiqu and bashing..but tht the least of my concern...

also i dont mind it being called a suggestions thread and taking out the appreciation part..coz we hardly did that there till now any ways 😆 😆 😆 also I wont quite call it a song suggestion thread..just coz its been open for 2 hrs.. n ppl talked of songs...i am sure scenes and other suggestions would come up too...

so I think these 2 threads are best kept separate for forum peace 🤣 almost sounded like global peace 🤣

@bold: To each their own definitions :-) I think there was mainly critiquing only going on in there but if you choose to think of it as bashing, cool😆😆😆

My main question was about the 'appreciation' part of the thread....glad to see we can agree on that much :-)

Originally posted by: nureat01

@bold: To each their own definitions :-) I think there was mainly critiquing only going on in there but if you choose to think of it as bashing, cool😆😆😆

My main question was about the 'appreciation' part of the thread....glad to see we can agree on that much :-)

Why r u assuming she thinks that critique in that thread was bashing?? 😆😆 I dont think she said that people posting there were bashing...LOL misinterpretations yet again!😆😆

Originally posted by: nureat01

<br><br>@bold: To each their own definitions :-) I think there was mainly critiquing only going on in there but if you choose to think of it as bashing, cool😆😆😆<br><br>My main question was about the 'appreciation' part of the thread....glad to see we can agree on that much :-)<br>

I didnt say bashing creatives..but eventually it did turn to bashin each other..n the war of words...started..

somehow..i get a feelin its not about SG vs MN or criticism vs bashing either anymore..its about every individual person tryin to prove their flair with expressions...in the meanwhile losing sight of the context 🤣 but then again..its again my INDIVIDUAL perception..so who am i to talk 🤣

about appreciation...m sure it was a consequence of someone;s suggestion 😆 😆 😆 .😆 ..but I dont see myself doing that... 😆 😆 😆 and on agreeing..oh well we could agree on a lot of stuff...its again a matter of perception and interpretations 😆

Originally posted by: sonali.19281

oh well...a lot of people suggested opening another thread for suggestions was the best option... n critics review thread was meant for critque...its another thing tht people hardly know trhe difference between critiqu and bashing..but tht the least of my concern...

also i dont mind it being called a suggestions thread and taking out the appreciation part..coz we hardly did that there till now any ways 😆 😆 😆 also I wont quite call it a song suggestion thread..just coz its been open for 2 hrs.. n ppl talked of songs...i am sure scenes and other suggestions would come up too...

so I think these 2 threads are best kept separate for forum peace 🤣 almost sounded like global peace 🤣

true thats what i said...I dont wanna appreciate right now either.😆
But then someone people may want so maybe it shuld be left in there and who knows, maybe we will wanna appreciate later on...hope so!

I dont think "critics thread" gives off negative connotations cuz critics point out flaws but also mention the good things too...its not like theres a positives and negs thread

Originally posted by: MohitSanayaFan

Why r u assuming she thinks that critique in that thread was bashing?? 😆😆 I dont think she said that people posting there were bashing...LOL misinterpretations yet again!😆😆

LMAO....then kindly do enlighten me with your superb interpretation skills how else a sentence which says, 'it's another thing that ppl don't know the difference b/w critiquing and bashing' is supposed to be interpreted?😆😆😆

I'm sure seeing your recent interpretation of why Rati appreciation topics were opened, your analysis on this will be totally correct as well😆😆

Originally posted by: sonali.19281

somehow..i get a feelin its not about SG vs MN or criticism vs bashing either anymore..its about every individual person tryin to prove their flair with expressions...in the meanwhile losing sight of the context 🤣 but then again..its again my INDIVIDUAL perception..so who am i to talk 🤣

Sonali, if that is the explanation that comforts you, you are most welcome to it....and do continue to enjoy ROFL to it as well....I think I'm going to remove myself from this pointless conversation now. Have a nice day.

Originally posted by: nureat01

LMAO....then kindly do enlighten me with your superb interpretation skills how else a sentence which says, 'it's another thing that ppl don't know the difference b/w critiquing and bashing' is supposed to be interpreted?😆😆😆

I'm sure seeing your recent interpretation of why Rati appreciation topics were opened, your analysis on this will be totally correct as well😆😆

And I apologized for pointing that out and jumping to conclusions.
I have an ego but its not that super inflated that I cant accept my mistakes. plus, I also had my reasons based on past posts Ive read from certain folks here...Theres a lot implied in praise sometimes here..

So go on and enjoy your laugh...I'm glad I could make u laugh...

Originally posted by: nureat01

I have a question....has it occurred to anyone in here that by labelling one thread as the creatives 'appreciation' thread, it is automatically giving a negative connotation to the other thread as if it was made for the sole intention of 'bashing'.

I thought feedback on what needs to be worked on in this show was the whole purpose of the critics corner....anyways, whatever works....although I do think a better name for the seperate thread would be the 'song suggestions' thread since that's what seems to mainly happen in there.