Feedback to CVs thread- Story distortion#2 - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

96.8k

Users

99

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

panchaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: SayaneeH.Lecter


Dharam ke naam pe CVs just push away karna from His Dharma .. they have forgotten that Duryadhana's friendship and Karna's gratitude towards Duryadhana was the only and Biggest Dhrma of Karna .. to make Karna good they don't need to put him in conventionally accepted right side.. The beauty of Karna's character is Karna remain with DHARMA even after standing by side of so called antagonists of Mahabharata.. like the lotus in mud. [though personally I am dead against of calling Dury Adharmi] .. This SP is just ruining the beauty of every character to make out a over simplified Hindi film like Good-Evil divide


If Bheesma can be ready to give up his Vow, then isn't it expected Karna would also want to give up Duryadhan's friendship 😕

Originally posted by: ...Diala...

Sayanee.. it is surprising.. this shows you are not following the show with dedication.. Knowing their level of understanding of their audience, we cant expect them to portray Karna's complicated Dharma that he defined for himself.. afterall we are brainless..

They are doing their best to gain him huge respect as if he is lacking it now.. and also huge fan following for he has zero admirers as of today.. I mean according to them..


Diala you forgot to put ROFL signs after your comment, which is crucially necessary 😆

at least the cvs should show a message before the serial starts- "all characters and incident of this program is imaginary, it has no connection with Mahabharat"
...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#52
Panchaali the first part is there in their Disky 😆.. why rofl? I was serious and sincere with my comment dear 😳
panchaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: ...Diala...

Panchaali the first part is there in their Disky 😆.. why rofl? I was serious and sincere with my comment dear 😳


This MB is a comedy show don't you think?😆

why increase your blood pressure🤓 being serious with it 🤣
Intrepida thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: -Shruti

Shubh kaam mein deri kaisi? 👍🏼


can this be part of the DeshkiFikr campaign? 😆
guenhwyvar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#55
I don't know where to put this, but since it's fitting the particular theme of this thread here goes:
So it was raining like crazy today (which is unusual where I live) and I had to go outside (no choice). I was walking to my car and since I was at college, there were other people walking. So it was raining ... and to the side of the concrete there was a tree with "acorns" (don't know what they care called) and dirt (now turned into what looked like mud). So since I was in a rush, I side stepped right into the muddy area to the side of the concrete. To my surprise, that wasn't a muddy area and my foot just sunk in (since it was "dirt"y water with the acorns floating on the surface). I immediately thought of the whole "ande ka putra anda" scene from BRC and laughed ... 😆😆

See CVs ... I can make a joke and fool out of myself and admit it... why can't you please do the same (again this is more about the logic in the episodes rather than actual distortion)!!
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: shyam09

Ok, watched yesterday and today together .. and I am furious!

People I'm angry at:
Star- (ie. all the following characters have the names "Star" attached to it.. for example "Star-Yuddhi"

Dhriti makes the promise that anyone who wants to go with Yuddhi can go ... that includes Kunti ... he can't stop her from going

Kunti just gives in ... uhh hello ... have you not read the Manu Samhita ... the women are first the responsibility of the father, then husband, then sons ...



I agree w/ everything else you wrote, but the real Kunti violated this rule on 2 occasions:
  • When she stayed on @ Hastinapur after the Pandava exile. She should have gone to her brother Purujit or Vasudev and stayed w/ them there for the 13 years, just like Subhadra lived in Dwarka, or Karenamati in Chedi. What she did living in Hastinapur was a violation of the Manu samhita
  • When she accompanied Dhritarashtra & Gandhari into exile after the war. Hello, dear, you're not Dhritarashtra's other wife, you belonged to your sons, as per Manu's Samhita.
I just find it impossible to respect Kunti, not only b'cos of how she treated Karna, but also due to how she had no shame living w/ Dhritarashtra.
guenhwyvar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: .Vrish.



I agree w/ everything else you wrote, but the real Kunti violated this rule on 2 occasions:
  • When she stayed on @ Hastinapur after the Pandava exile. She should have gone to her brother Purujit or Vasudev and stayed w/ them there for the 13 years, just like Subhadra lived in Dwarka, or Karenamati in Chedi. What she did living in Hastinapur was a violation of the Manu samhita
  • When she accompanied Dhritarashtra & Gandhari into exile after the war. Hello, dear, you're not Dhritarashtra's other wife, you belonged to your sons, as per Manu's Samhita.
I just find it impossible to respect Kunti, not only b'cos of how she treated Karna, but also due to how she had no shame living w/ Dhritarashtra.

dammit. nothing escapes you Vrish 😆
Surya_krsnbhakt thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: .Vrish.



I agree w/ everything else you wrote, but the real Kunti violated this rule on 2 occasions:
  • When she stayed on @ Hastinapur after the Pandava exile. She should have gone to her brother Purujit or Vasudev and stayed w/ them there for the 13 years, just like Subhadra lived in Dwarka, or Karenamati in Chedi. What she did living in Hastinapur was a violation of the Manu samhita
  • When she accompanied Dhritarashtra & Gandhari into exile after the war. Hello, dear, you're not Dhritarashtra's other wife, you belonged to your sons, as per Manu's Samhita.
I just find it impossible to respect Kunti, not only b'cos of how she treated Karna, but also due to how she had no shame living w/ Dhritarashtra.

Which is why I like the Kunti of SB, in which she is wise and doesn't do the above said things. And she stays back with the Pandavas and doesn't go with Dhritu and Gandhari to forest. WHo was Purujit?
And I have not been watching the episodes regularly, but about KUnti detained in Hastinapura... WTH? Didn't she also live in Indraprastha? Or is that also only in SB? Coz I remember seeing her in the ACK.
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#59
Purujit was her brother, Kuntibhoj's son. Although Vyasa does a good job conflating father & son in a few cases, like Drupada & Prishatha (while describing Dhrishtadyumna), or Kuntibhoj & Purujit (while describing Arjun as Kuntibhoj's nephew in the battle descriptions).


You haven't been following this serial - it's nothing like the actual epic. A few major bloopers to date, since you haven't been paying attention 😳😆
  • Subhadra was Duhsala's classmate and introduced by the latter to Kunti. At that function, Arjun entertained her w/ a veena, and Duryodhan & Karna mocked Arjun. A livid Arjun drew his dagger, and Dhritarashtra threatened to execute him for trying to start a war w/ Anga. As an attempt to placate him, Vidura sentenced Arjun to wash Karna's feet 🤣
  • In Krishna-Rukmini's abduction, Arjun took the Brihannala disguise and fought Rukmi Bollywood style, while taking Rukmini by the hand 🤣 and running out of there
  • Karna had a major fall-out w/ Duryodhan since the house of lac, and has only been happy w/ him once - during the latter's yuvraj abhishek. When news of the Pandava deaths came, Karna was in mourning
  • After Bhima killed Hidimba, he became the king of the rakshashas, since their custom was that whoever killed their king became their king. So after Ghatotkacha's birth & instant growth, Bhima handed over the Bhupati title to Ghatotkacha and then moved on 😆 Bakasura episode was skipped 😡
  • Drupada refused to accept Draupadi as a daughter, and wished that she be subjected to a life of pain & suffering. The devas forced him to offer portions into the fire, and w/ each such portion, he wished ill of Draupati 🤢
  • After the swayamvara, Duryodhan demanded that Dhritarashtra abdicate, and he be made the king and allowed to do the Ashwamedha yagna. Bheeshma & Karna almost came to war over Duryodhan's rajyabhishek
  • Draupadi's marriage to 5 men was universally regarded as adharm. When the Pandavas returned to Hastinapur, they were mocked. First for Bhima marrying a rakshashi, and then when it was revealed that Draupadi married all 5 Pandavas, Gandhari dropped the arati thali and Bheeshma, Dhritarashtra & Gandhari walked out of the welcoming committee
  • Duryodhan insulted Draupadi in open court while handing back the yuvraj title to Yudisthir, and Arjun threatened to kill him. Dhritarashtra sentenced Arjun to death and ordered the Pandavas to be thrown into the dungeons. Bheeshma staged a coup and ordered them released 😆
  • Shakuni persuaded Dhritarashtra to placate Bheeshma. Bheeshma demanded that the Pandavas be given a part of the kingdom of their choosing, and Dhritarashtra offered it. Yudisthir picked Khandavaprastha, much against Bheeshma's advice - he wants to start from scratch. Dhritarashtra allowed them to leave, along w/ anyone who wanted to leave w/ them, but in return, he swore Bheeshma to lifelong loyalty to himself & Duryodhan 🤣 Also, he announced that Kunti would have to remain in Hastinapur w/ him 🤢 - that's what Shyam09's comment above was about
Oh, and this week & coming week, there is more:
  • Karna's future wife Vrushali is a maid of Draupadi 🤢 who accompanies her to Khandavaprastha. She is attacked by a snake, jumps off a cliff into the river, floats to Hastinapur and is rescued by Adiratha 🤣
  • Duryodhan tries to block Vrushali from going to Khandavaprastha, and Dhritarashtra bans Kunti from attending the Indraprastha nagar puja. Karna hands back the crown of Anga to Duryodhan in protest & takes Vrushali back to Khandavaprastha
  • Kunti sends a message via Karna to her sons to declare independence, and that she'll join them after that
  • Vrushali is sad to be parted from Karna, so Krishna and Arjun hand over Draupadi's maid to Karna for safekeeping 🤣
Now you are current 😆 Wanna get back to watching? 😈

Shyam09, legally, you are right - Dhritarashtra had no business detaining Kunti in this case.
Edited by .Vrish. - 11 years ago
Wistfulness thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Banner Contest Winner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
#60
I won't watch it anymore..I may switch back during the war. But currently that's way too distant in my vision.

I'll just read the updates from now. 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".