Hating a character - are the reasons justified?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

alina.b

@alina.b

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#11

@Cutelady thanks for trying to answer my question. And yes cvs have gone mad!

Quote

DushtDanaf.

@DushtDanaf.

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#12

oh yeah, boo-hoo he has a tragic past.

if RK's past doesn't excuse him for his actions; i don't see why Sultan's should.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

alina.b

@alina.b

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: DushtDanaf.

oh yeah, boo-hoo he has a tragic past.
if RK's past doesn't excuse him for his actions; i don't see why Sultan's should.

Round of applause everyone!! Well said! 👏

Quote

kshows_fangirl

@kshows_fangirl

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#14

Okay, I haven't visited this forum or watched Madhubala for a while now. Instead have just been reading the written updates. But, I have got to say this, that you have very maturely pointed out the truth! And, I loved your post! I wish you would make such kind of posts more often, when u get time..This forum has always been a very violent one. It is either extreme hate or extreme love for a particular character. So, I don't even want to say anything much on that part. But, I fully agree with your post. In reality, a woman would never go back to a husband like RK, but since this is a fiction show and we know that RK and Madhu are the leads, so they have to somehow end up together. I disagree on that part.

I want for once for the CV's to show the reality as to what happens as a result of the sadistic, over obsessive, rude, arrogant, obnoxious behavior of a man like RK on a day to day woman like Madhu. I want this to change in Indian Television, that the "so-called leads" must end together no matter what kind of behavior is portrayed by both the leads. I am not siding with Madhu or RK. If madhu would have done the same to RK, I would have said the same thing. I mean what is so bad about Sultan and his character?! It is utter nonsense and foolishness on one's part as a fan to hate a man like Sultan. Just because he is a gangster doesn't mean one should hate him. From the moment he entered the show, I haven't seen any inappropriateness in his behavior towards Madhu. He has always been respectful and now he has come to admire her as a woman. I would really like to see them being close friends where they can share their concerns and worries with each other.

It is not necessary that Madhu should end up with RK. Honestly if I was a writer of this show, I would never let Madhu go back to RK no matter what! Because from where he is now, he has basically crossed all the boundaries that it is now hard to go back to where he could have been forgiven. If I was a writer, I would end their story tragically. Because, honestly that is the only thing that should happen from my point of view. And, I am not forcing anyone to agree with me on that. So, please don't bash me. Even though I don't want for one of them to end up dead, but the way the CV's have been going about this and making it much more worse, this is the only ending I believe is justified.

Thanks for making such a great post! 😊

Edited by nikita59 - 12 years ago

Quote

cutelady

@cutelady

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: DushtDanaf.
oh yeah, boo-hoo he has a tragic past.
if RK's past doesn't excuse him for his actions; i don't see why Sultan's should.

So both male character's have a tragic past but one turned out to be a superstar and the other a gangster. I don't see much of a difference in their past, they both lost love ones. Despite their past experiences they have turned out to have completely opposite personalities. I am only pointing out what is being shown. RK's past can excuse him for his bitterness towards the Bathiya family and even his mother but not for what he did to Madhu. He played her and that's the truth. Now we have seen glimpses of him remembering the moments he spent with Madhu and could be seen as the light at the end of a dark tunnel (his can be redeemed). But he needs to reach to the light himself and not force Madhu into the darkness.

Quote

DushtDanaf.

@DushtDanaf.

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: cutelady

So both male character's have a tragic past but one turned out to be a superstar and the other a gangster. I don't see much of a difference in their past, they both lost love ones. Despite their past experiences they have turned out to have completely opposite personalities. I am only pointing out what is being shown. RK's past can excuse him for his bitterness towards the Bathiya family and even his mother but not for what he did to Madhu. He played her and that's the truth. Now we have seen glimpses of him remembering the moments he spent with Madhu and could be seen as the light at the end of a dark tunnel (his can be redeemed). But he needs to reach to the light himself and not force Madhu into the darkness.

i like that, that's a nice way of putting it; but the fact remains that normally the people criticizing RK's actions are the very same people making excuses for Sultan's crimes. When those are two very different things. Betrayal and outright murder don't even begin to come under the same basis for comparison, and some people just refuse to acknowledge that.

Quote

cardio21

@cardio21

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: shweta2728
The only question I have...which is to the CVs is...do you forget your own story? Did you forget what you showed? Madhu was very uncomfortable wearing that blue gown in the studio but today she has no problem wearing that black gown, which is as revealing as the other one, and dancing in it in front of other people.

Is this the first time, they have forgotten, that wat they ave showed earlier?? I have made umpteen posts on their memory lapses.. Infact this post is also the result of one of their biggest memory lapses..

TM.. Please don't be offended with my statement.. I agree with most of this things u said.. But I can't overlook whatever I saw for 6 months.. So was forced to answer like it..

If u don't like it, I will edit or delete it..

Quote

ElOqUeNcE

@ElOqUeNcE

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#18

Totaly disagre! Rk nvr a vilian n wil nvr cros his limit! I hat charctr mb as her so called ethics is only for rk nt for gangster sultan!her chrctr degrading day by day!she is d sam girl who fel uncomfrtble wearing revealing dres n slap rk for no strong reason n sudenly today she fel no hesistnt to dance wid sam dres infrnt of evry1

Quote

cutelady

@cutelady

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: DushtDanaf.
i like that, that's a nice way of putting it; but the fact remains that normally the people criticizing RK's actions are the very same people making excuses for Sultan's crimes. When those are two very different things. Betrayal and outright murder don't even begin to come under the same basis for comparison, and some people just refuse to acknowledge that.

You are absolutely right. I admit I have been criticizing RK's behaviour towards Madhu and justifying Sultan's presence in Madhu's life. The fact that he is a gangster cannot be overlooked. But as of yet, we don't know the details of his work and exactly what crimes he has committed except for when he admitted murdering the man who killed his mother and when we saw him attempting to kill Bujang during Holi for selling drugs to children. Apart of me dislikes these actions of Sultan but another part of me can understand where he is coming from. Similarly, I have liked RK from the beginning and there are many actions that can be excused and those that cannot.

Quote

armummy

@armummy

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: cardio21

Is this the first time, they have forgotten, that wat they ave showed earlier?? I have made umpteen posts on their memory lapses.. Infact this post is also the result of one of their biggest memory lapses..

TM.. Please don't be offended with my statement.. I agree with most of this things u said.. But I can't overlook whatever I saw for 6 months.. So was forced to answer like it..
If u don't like it, I will edit or delete it..

Agree to memory lapses -- sultan using son as a bait, kidnap a lady and take her to house , pile up dead bodies .. we excuse all that..Also people forget all the scenes where rk is shown normal , respectful or trying to make upto madhu

The fact is rk fans will see what they to see, sultan/madhu fans will see what they want to see.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Hating a character - are the reasons justified? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics