congratulations abhi?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

nitarata

@nitarata

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: -mina-
You are right that Pragya's responses put constraints on Abhi. Nonetheless I believe Abhi still had the choice to act as an objectively moral and responsible person. She told him she didn't want an answer - but it would have been more mature of him to be honest with her that he didn't know his own mind and couldn't give her an answer. Playing hide and seek and then overreacting (at the Welcome Back party, at Purab's place) were immature. You can argue that Abhi is not moral and not mature and you would be valid to do so. I still think his lack of better choices deserves critique. Just because Pragya doesn't expect more from him doesn't mean I don't. At the end of the day he is what he is within the limitations of the story, but my own standards come to bear on whether I admire or approve of him or not.

Again I don't agree with the critique here. Abhi does think and think over Pragya's confession even though she didn't want an answer. He first needs to clear in his head what he needs to tell her na? He takes one or two days for it. And please remember he was injured with a bullet and had gotten back from death. He was so overwhelmed.

And there is a scene in which he tells her he is confused. He thinks she is listening, but she is gone!

And soon, Purab/BB and Pragya start off with their get Abhi to confess mission, blowing things.

Also, the welcome party overreaction can't be looked at as Abhi's mistake. It's very immature of BB to spread a rumour that AbhiGya romantically kissed.. and Pragya did nothing to stop it. Of course Abhi would be offended to hear a life saving act turned into a kiss.

Quote

Zaalima_5

@Zaalima_5

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#32

good post mina👏👏

had the same feeling about abhi' s char, since beginning i never liked his char

but now i can start liking him becz he is changing and improving his char little bit...

somebody is saying that he always stood by her and took bullet also but i don't think it is as painful as pragya felt due to his action...

ek biwi hi wo dard samajh sakti hai jab uska shoher use nahi kisi aur ko pyar kare aur wo bhi uske samne, mujhe lagta hai ye dard aisa hai ki shayad insaan marte waqt bhi mahsoos nahi karta hoga shayad bullet lene se bhi zyada...

but that's called destiny, they were destined to be together...aur kismat hamesha maherbaan nahi hoti kabhi kabhi kismat imtehaan bhi leti hai ...😉

so all the best for abhigya

but now he realized his mistake and pragya is also ready to give him one more chance then thats okay...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Mina

@-mina-

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#33

Kulsum!! Seeing you after so long. Hope you had an easy Ramadan and joyous Eid (if I remember right you were observing...sorry if I'm wrong).

Beautifully said. Some pains are not comparable to others. And some are immeasurable and forever unspoken.

Quote

nitarata

@nitarata

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: -mina-
So Tia you're saying CVs have left it a mystery what Abhi intends to do? All these months in our time and weeks in KKB time, Abhi gets a free pass from having an opinion on the biggest problem of his life?

I don't know an answer to this for sure.

See, this pregnancy track should have been focussed on Abhi. Because it is his problem. But CVs involved Pragya before him, and even denied a monologue from him when he got to know Tannu is really pregnant. And like I said, no TaBhi scene at all that discusses this matter.

The whole focus has been on PraNu early on and AbhiGya relationship/Pragya pregnancy etc. They haven't dealt with Abhi's reaction properly.

He shows his anger on Tannu. Why is he angry? Is it because she tricked him or because he doesn't love her/loves Pragya? Why does he not think of his love for Pragya which he realized a few days ago? We are left to judge by his interactions with other characters and facial expressions. They are confusing.

Quote

Mina

@-mina-

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: -Tia-

Again I don't agree with the critique here. Abhi does think and think over Pragya's confession even though she didn't want an answer. He first needs to clear in his head what he needs to tell her na? He takes one or two days for it. And please remember he was injured with a bullet and had gotten back from death. He was so overwhelmed.

And there is a scene in which he tells her he is confused. He thinks she is listening, but she is gone!

And soon, Purab/BB and Pragya start off with their get Abhi to confess mission, blowing things.

Also, the welcome party overreaction can't be looked at as Abhi's mistake. It's very immature of BB to spread a rumour that AbhiGya romantically kissed.. and Pragya did nothing to stop it. Of course Abhi would be offended to hear a life saving act turned into a kiss.

At the end of the day I think Abhi is a jerk and Pragya is a saint but your views are quite different. Nothing will make us agree. The beauty of critique is that all sides can be considered wrong or right but since it's only about fiction the contradiction hurts no one.

Quote

nitarata

@nitarata

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#36

yeah Mina, Abhi is a jerk indeed to take a bullet and give his life to Pragya. Arguments end here.

Quote

Zaalima_5

@Zaalima_5

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: -mina-
Kulsum!! Seeing you after so long. Hope you had an easy Ramadan and joyous Eid (if I remember right you were observing...sorry if I'm wrong).

Beautifully said. Some pains are not comparable to others. And some are immeasurable and forever unspoken.

yes i was observing but never replied becz without watching show how can i give my point of view

and i had best eid this year...

thank you...

Quote

vivkriti

@vivkriti

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: -Tia-
"She is pregnant due to my mistake and I intend to support her" why does he need to say this, Mina? She is pregnant due to her mistake, not his! Should a woman marry a man if he got her pregnant when she was under alcohol?

<font color="#333333" face="Helvetica Neue, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif">He also should tell Daadi he married Pragya under a Aalu driven MU.. not completely due to Daadi's force. And would Pragya share with Daadi the MU continued with her saying she is in love with Purab etc.. as he boasted Tannu???</font>

<font color="#333333" face="Helvetica Neue, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif">But mostly he won't say all this, because whatever it is, the mistake is still his, given the way a baby thing gets looked at.</font>

Well said Tia Pregnancy is not Abhi but Tanu fault as he was under alcohol as per Tanu claim he should clear that to dadi n all . Acoording to him he never had any physical relation with Tanu when he was in senses after marriage.

Quote

Mina

@-mina-

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: -Tia-
yeah Mina, Abhi is a jerk indeed to take a bullet and give his life to Pragya. Arguments end here.

For you, not for me. His near death doesn't erase all of his life's actions. Even if he had died his wrongs would still be wrongs. We just wouldn't talk about them.

He's not a jerk to take her bullet. He is a jerk for other things.