*Season 2, Week 31* Analysis Thread - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

138

Views

14.5k

Users

21

Likes

1.1k

Frequent Posters

Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: thedramaqueen

Not telling the father of the child that his wife is running a high risk pregnancy is irresponsible. We have not yet been told that Sonakshi needs complete cutting off from the world.. have we? Would a father, mother, mother in law, brother, sisters let a woman put her life in risk if that means the business suffers? Did the ob-gyn tell Sonakshi she needs to be listening to calming music, not working, not using her brain?

I am sorry Shaavi, you are extrapolating the story that has been shown.. All I said is, Dev should know. Sona knows and Ishwari knows.. If either of them choose not to tell him, they are both irresponsible. And before we try and decide who is more irresponsible, I am not interested in deciding who is more wrong

PS: I am sorry for the trauma your friend and her family went through. I hope they are all enjoying their bundle of joy.


DQ, till now Sonakshi as BD has always justified herself of not telling the truth to Dev. Even in that promo, she says "if I need to hold back my emotions, then I will do it". The doctor might not have as of yet asked her to cut off from the world. I was just giving a personal experience of how far the complications can go. I completely agree that Dev should know and have a say in it. But given how Sonakshi has been shown till now, will she let Dev have a say in it. I mean has she ever let Dev have a say in anything. And as I said Dev would definitely not want to put her through anything that can cause harm to her, but if Sonakshi chooses and says this is my choice, he will accept her choice. He will support her in whatever decision she will take. But there is one thing he will want her to do and not give her a choice. Maybe even ask her to promise him that she will take care of herself as well as let him take care of her. BD is someone who is not comfortable in letting someone "take care of her". And BD is hasty and one who makes decisions impulsively.

I am sorry that you think I am extrapolating, but was just analyzing and penning down my thoughts. Going by what they have shown so far as Sonakshi and her characterization. And was just wondering how she is going to handle that. And was just pointing out to that fact where she is placed now. It was not about right or wrong, it was more about my curiosity as to what will she do now.

P.S: although my friend's daughter was born a premie, she is now 6 years old and is a healthy child. And my friend is enjoying motherhood with her. 😃 . But she told me she will never have another child as she doesn't have the strength to go through a similar time again.


Edited by Shaavi - 8 years ago
thedramaqueen thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#62

We are talking cross purposes here... I am talking about this isolated incident. I have never said Sonakshi (or Dev for that matter) were 100% right or wrong.

At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I will again say, *if* Sona and/or Ishwari choose (or convince the other) to hide the risks of the pregnancy, it will be highly irresponsible. This has less to do with the responsibility she feels towards to Boses (if anything she would terminate the pregnancy to have less responsibility) and more to do with letting Dev live that experience (She was shown reminiscing the pretend pregnancy date they had)... That is where I have a huge problem

thedramaqueen thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: Shama95


Sona galat hai bass. Agar woh apne pati aur saas ki khushi ke liye risky pregnency le tab bhi galat hai. Unhe unke khoye sukh dene ke liye maut aur takleef ka khatra uthaye tab bhi galat hai.

Jaroor uska koi chupa reason hoga ya phir uske gharwalaon ka koi phaayda hoga. Nahin hoga to hum dhoondh lenge. Agar show Nahin dikhayega to hum imagine kar lenge. Kyunki Sona galat hai bass.

Kuch pade likhon see to mere jaisi chote sheher ki hindi medium pass behter hai😆

Dear @Shama95

I haven't seen you post on this thread before. Would like to request that you read the rules of this thread before you continue posting. Your post (underlined) breaks the following rule. I would request that you edit those parts of your post please.


4. BASHING OR PERSONAL INSULTS OF OTHER MEMBERS

This means we accept other people's viewpoints with respect, and don't call them names for not agreeing with us. Either we continue the argument calmly, supported by examples from the show, or we respectfully agree to disagree and leave that discussion alone.


Thanks

DQ

Harryfan011 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#64
I never encouraged or endorsed that Sonakshi should put herself in a life-threatening situation...
In fact, this is why, telling Dev the complete truth is all the more, important and necessary...

Sonakshi is someone who only focuses on the brighter side of things... In her mind, having the baby will not only heal the wounds that she remained with her since Soha's pregnancy, but it will also be her way of sort of... giving Dev a chance to be part of what he's missed...

She completely ignores the negatives, hence, in this situation, her only concern is the baby and not her own well-being...

And, Ishwari like the last time, has once again over-excited about the possibility of another grandchild (a boy, preferably)... But, unlike last time, she genuinely cares about Sona's health...

But, she is unintentionally creating a sense of dread inside Sona's mind on whether they will love her the same way, even if she decides to terminate the pregnancy (not that, she wants to do so)... I think, her experiences during the infertility track has still affects to a certain extent...

Last time around, it was Dev who promised her that she is more important to him than a baby but due to circumstances, he was never able to truly make her believe that he was telling her the truth... 7 years back, she was made to believe that the baby is far more important than her own self ('Mission Baby Dixit')...

And, Dev was never able to convince her that she mattered to him more than a baby...

This is where Dev's role becomes all the more important... He needs to make Sona realize that being Sonakshi Dixit is more than enough for him... That she doesn't need to put her own life at risk, just for the sake of his or anyone's happiness...

Dev has to become Sona's emotional anchor this time around... He has to make her realize that having her presence by his side, is all he needs for his happiness... He has to finally fulfill the promise that he made to Sona...

And, at the same time, he needs to be the one who also needs to tell Ishwari the negative impacts of her over-excitement related to this pregnancy... And, how wrong she was to indirectly pressurise Sona to go through with the fertility treatments (for the 7% chance)...

And, I am sure that once she controls her excitement, then, she will be able to assure Sona that irrespective of Sona's decision, she will still mean the same to her... And, her health and happiness is far more important than a grandchild...

We have to realize that when she was pregnant with Soha, she was acting more like Bijoy's daughter... Someone who still continued to push herself, despite knowing the complications and risks to her own well-being... Her responsibility towards the Boses was far more important..

But, hopefully, this time, she will finally have the courage to think first for her own well-being and her own happiness, rather than her responsibility towards the Boses...

In the end, it has to be her own decision to prioritize being Sonakshi Dixit than Sonakshi Bose...

-Suyash.
Edited by Harryfan011 - 8 years ago
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: Harryfan011


In the end, it has to be her own decision to prioritize being Sonakshi Dixit than Sonakshi Bose...

-Suyash.


Suyash, looks like you are able to read my thoughts. 😆 . Sorry not meant to hurt you, but this is what I was trying to convey in my posts, but failed miserably. 😃 . And the above sentence is where it all comes to. Where Sonakshi embraces her role as Sonakshi Dixit wholeheartedly and Sonakshi Bose takes a backseat indefinitely. That just like how Ishwari released Dev from his guilt and responsibilities towards her and her daughters. Sonakshi be released too by Bijoy and say "jaa Sonakshi jaa, jee le apni zindagi". 😆 😆
sp12 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#66
Well, today's episode left a bittersweet taste at least for me. On one hand I really liked the Rakshabandhan scenes especially loved that Dev still had the same love for Elena even after some of her rude and bitter behaviour with him. Loved the Sonakshi-Asha eyetalk and then the revelation.
But amidst all this I was a bit annoyed the way Ishwari talked to Sonakshi especially telling her that What's the point in talking when you kids have decided on the decision, I somehow felt that by talking about Niki's birth and then subsequently talking to Sonakshi about her decision she was emotionally manipulating Sonakshi so as to keep the baby. I really hope that Sonakshi reveals about the complications to Dev. Please Sonakshi do it, he deserves to know about it .
I also did not like the way Sonakshi-Ishwari were playing hide & seek with Dev regarding revealing the pregnancy. In fact I found it a bit creepy & awkward that Ishwari was peeping into their room when Sonakshi was trying to reveal the pregnancy to Dev. I was hoping it would be a special husband-wife moment but alas it was not to be . I understand that Sonakshi-Ishwari's bond has become stronger but this is one moment whcich is really special for any couple and I was really hoping to see that. Now my only hope is that Sonakshi reveals everything about her pregnancy to Dev and both mutually take the decision.

Apologies for the long post, just my POV.
dramebaaz.af thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#67
So I am thinking that by the end of tomorrow's episode, Dev would know about the pregnancy being high risk and he would be proactive in terms of explaining to Sonakshi that that itself doesn't mean much to him without her by his side. Today's episode wasn't as fast paced as last two but I really hope that there is a closure to the other two tracks besides the pregnancy one. It seems, Elena already knows about company being handed by Dev. and as for Saurabh-Sonakshi-and-mrs.mondol's track, it can be easily referenced in monday's episode.
Calvin341 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: areeba_blossom

So I am thinking that by the end of tomorrow's episode, Dev would know about the pregnancy being high risk and he would be proactive in terms of explaining to Sonakshi that that itself doesn't mean much to him without her by his side. Today's episode wasn't as fast paced as last two but I really hope that there is a closure to the other two tracks besides the pregnancy one. It seems, Elena already knows about company being handed by Dev. and as for Saurabh-Sonakshi-and-mrs.mondol's track, it can be easily referenced in monday's episode.


What is this "Saurabh-Sonakshi-and-mrs.mondol's track" ?🤔
I thought it was more like Sona-Saurabh-Bejoy track..
dramebaaz.af thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#69
^^yep yep, Bijoy included. I guess it can be a Bose track instead of just using names. 😆
thedramaqueen thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: Shaavi


Suyash, looks like you are able to read my thoughts. 😆 . Sorry not meant to hurt you, but this is what I was trying to convey in my posts, but failed miserably. 😃 . And the above sentence is where it all comes to. Where Sonakshi embraces her role as Sonakshi Dixit wholeheartedly and Sonakshi Bose takes a backseat indefinitely. That just like how Ishwari released Dev from his guilt and responsibilities towards her and her daughters. Sonakshi be released too by Bijoy and say "jaa Sonakshi jaa, jee le apni zindagi". 😆 😆


Quick question... What in your views are the traits of BD(Bijoy's daughter)? I think this is where the discussion is going haywire. and while we are at it.. thanks to tonight's lovely(not!) episode, what are the traits of ID(Ishwari's Dev) and IB (Ishwari's bahu)?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".