Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

4.4k

Users

29

Likes

364

Frequent Posters

dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: noor.21


But one day the truth will come out.

Also isn't Sona all about doing the right thing, not the safe thing.

Also I thought it was super stupid that both Dev and Sona believed that Dev threw them out. Because we all know from the past records that Dev is capable of doing alot of thing to people around Sona but nothing to Sona directly.



One would do the right thing if they expect fairness from the otherside...clearly sona lost that dixits can ever be fair when their wishes come into picture.. so why should sona risk doing the right thing only to lose her own daughter..
So yes the truth will come out one day and she is not hiding anything from her daughter and she clearly said if she wants to spend time with her father that is fine too .. she will call him and let him know..
I am sure when dev confronts her she wont lie .. she will tellm exactly why she did not tell him and all those are valid reasons..
Well sona did not belkeve that dev threw them out until dev himself admitted .. so i cant blame sona here..may be dev himself doesnt know what he is capabale of when he is drunk.. but clearly sona understood that she has fallen in the same category of ranveer rithik etc where dev wont even feel their pain before deciding to hurt them... so the wisest thing any living thing would do under such conditions is run away from that place and hide and not give any chances to the other person to hurt u more .. it is natural survival instinct
gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Kaustuv


Yes actually even in my real life I do not have patience to understand the hidden intent whatsoever ever. U r rude to me plain and simple . I don't use my brain to analyze why, how . I utilize my brain constructively.

He is rude to everyone who doesn't agree with his view point.😆
noor.21 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: sproutbean8


Thank you for bringing this up! I completely agree and was hoping the makers would have gone in the direction of letting Dev watch his kid grow up and be a part of her life. Sona herself said that Dev was a good person, so why not let him be a part of the child's life. If the Dixits had come for the kid the prenup would have negated their rights.

I thought the prenup would have been used to protect Sona but it looks like the makers are going to take the cliqued way out.

The one thing about Dev and Sona I had hoped that the makers would have kept was their ability to talk to each other after an argument. I think Sona could have dictated the terms by which Dev was to meet his kid , ie Ishwari is not allowed to know about her.

I give up, I feel cheated...



👏 There is just so much blind hatred for Dev in the forum. That ppl can't see something this wrong. Also GKB switching tablets is also a crime.

To ppl still questing, Imagine you had a child, before that you had a horrible fight with your wife and went separate ways, then you come to know after 7 years that you have a daughter. Wouldn't that break you heart? Sona was married to Dev, not the Dixits. How the dixits react is their biz, but Dev always wanted a child and sona knows this?
noor.21 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: dlavanya



One would do the right thing if they expect fairness from the otherside...clearly sona lost that dixits can ever be fair when their wishes come into picture.. so why should sona risk doing the right thing only to lose her own daughter..
So yes the truth will come out one day and she is not hiding anything from her daughter and she clearly said if she wants to spend time with her father that is fine too .. she will call him and let him know..
I am sure when dev confronts her she wont lie .. she will tellm exactly why she did not tell him and all those are valid reasons..
Well sona did not belkeve that dev threw them out until dev himself admitted .. so i cant blame sona here..may be dev himself doesnt know what he is capabale of when he is drunk.. but clearly sona understood that she has fallen in the same category of ranveer rithik etc where dev wont even feel their pain before deciding to hurt them... so the wisest thing any living thing would do under such conditions is run away from that place and hide and not give any chances to the other person to hurt u more .. it is natural survival instinct


Just a tiny clarification, Sona did believe that Dev did it. Before meeting Dev, she told Asha that she is sure Dev did it. Dev believing he did it is honestly very stupid.
sproutbean8 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: noor.21


👏 There is just so much blind hatred for Dev in the forum. That ppl can't see something this wrong. Also GKB switching tablets is also a crime.

To ppl still questing, Imagine you had a child, before that you had a horrible fight with your wife and went separate ways, then you come to know after 7 years that you have a daughter. Wouldn't that break you heart? Sona was married to Dev, not the Dixits. How the dixits react is their biz, but Dev always wanted a child and sona knows this?



Exactly, no matter what anyone thinks or what happened Dev and the kid were robbed of a relationship.

Sona knows Dev wanted a child with her from the beginning. I wish the makers had not destroyed Dev in the manner they did in the last episode of season 1. They story was still salvageable. That is the most frustrating part of all this ... They didn't use the prenup and the understanding between Dev and Sona effectively.
VIMAL.SM thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
Sona did a crime.When Dev comes to know.He should file a case against her.

Sona should also file a case on Dev for raising hand on her.Also for slapping her father.She should also file a suit for mental abuse.

CV's should have followed the law correctly.Even in 1st break up.Dev stalked Sona.Sona should have filed a complaint for stlaking.Dev tried to sabotage Ritwick career.For that also a complained should be filed on Dev.Dev created ruckus in Riwtick N Sona's engagement.By drinking n fainting there.Bose should have filed a defamation case on Dev for trying to spoil their image in public.

When these things of Dev was ignored.Because he loved Sona.When in the Pre-Nup it's clearly mentioned.That the Child has no right on Dev n his property.So Sona followed what is in the Pre-Nup.Yet it was so big of her to say to her daughter.Reg her dad.For once she did not bad mouth about Dev.Said he is good human.Also left to her daughter to decide that whether she wants to meet her dad or not.Yet Sona is wrong.She has done a crime.Wah what a logic.Female lead mistake his crime.Male lead crime is love .Superb logic 👏👏
HaiMiz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27
Legally, it is not a crime.
Ethically it maybe wrong. Coz Ethics is all about right and wrong. But once again..it is not a crime.

Morally...Sona is not wrong ...as right and wrong are oft decided by circumstances, especially when one is cornered. Doesn't Mahabharata stress this.

When Sona left Dev, she didn't know of her pregnancy. All she knew was that she was poor, Dev is rich. Dev had just lambasted her and had told that she would be an unfit mother. And Sona has seen Dev rid people of what is precious to them if it serves his needs ( Ranveer, Ritwik).

In such a situation, informing Dev of her child would be foolhardy for he may take her child away citing her as unfit mother who doesn't have the means to take care of her child.

Therefore, to answer your question...it is not a crime. It isn't even wrong morally. But ethically yes. But lets be forthright...cross our hearts and say, how many of us would be willing to risk the most important thing in our lives just so we can be ethically right...especially when you could lose the child that matters to you the most.

I cannot understand why the forum often divides into Dev vs Sonakshi. Lets stick to the question here. Was Sonakshi justified in keeping the news from Dev...In this case, I would say yes...only because in her position I would have done the same. Because my aim is to protect my child and me from my ex with whom I had a bad fall out with. It is survival. And Darwin's theory of survival of the fittest still remains very relevant in our world.
Edited by SandyAquarius - 8 years ago
Devakshilover thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: yyy

Whatever happened was between husband and wife .When you become a parent you need to keep aside your differences for the child's well being .By not revealing she wronged both her ex husband and her daughter.I don't see anything other than Ego here

No reason will justify Sonakshi's decision of keeping the child away from Dev but again she is Sonakshi Bose who can never be wrong .Her every action will be justified .

Let's see if the makers have the guts to show Miss Sonakshi Bose was wrong .

First of all when sona must have known about her pregnancy she was financially not very strong,she knew dev and his mother would snatch her baby from her because clearly the dikshits care only about the chiraag of their khandaan and would have thrown sona
dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: noor.21


Just a tiny clarification, Sona did believe that Dev did it. Before meeting Dev, she told Asha that she is sure Dev did it. Dev believing he did it is honestly very stupid.


She didnt believe it when vicky told her but instead she tried to call dev but the call was cut..so she could okd asha dev is indeed capable of doing anything for his mother ... she never thought dev would ask her to get out of the house as well .. but when his mom fell down .. he did ask her to get out and he did not stop her even after she asked him if he really meant it ... so u see trust and confidence is gradually lost..
Sona didnt want to take any risk with her kid or her family once she found out she is pregnant..

Why dev. Elieved he did it himself is stupidity.. he should never have gotten drunk during such a crucial time .. anyways .. we cant change the past so lets just enjoy the show
1101831 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#30
arey fictional serial hai, why so serious 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".