Psychiatrist's Field Trip!!! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

44

Views

4.7k

Users

17

Likes

234

Frequent Posters

rose4ever thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21
Tia this one is more of a personal rant/venting out,please bear with me.
Have any of us ever commented personally on other members even if their opinions don't match with ours? No,right? We either don't comment or simply state our views on their threads.Then why is it that we are being called
1.Dumb 2.Reason for the absence of positive members apparently 3.People who only criticize and never appreciate aka negative. 4.We talk only bakwaas.5.Words like mental disorder & psychiatrists are being thrown around without understanding by us. 6.Ooh we don't have sense and don't understand what really matters in life.And of course feminism is thrown as well(You know I don't think we have used the word feminism as much as those members have)
This is only from today's posts by some members.
Previously some even used words like bullies,rude,mean,immature,questioning how we lead our life etc,etc.
Now their suggestions are that we stop watching the show.In that case,they should stop reading the such post,shouldn't they?
Now I read in a post a day back that forum members do not like other members being judged for their opinions.So does that rule apply only for some members and not for all?
Sometimes I feel they don't even read posts and only judge by the title.When positives are discussed,do they read these posts then?

I know we've discussed this before,but I couldn't stop myself from writing this.I can ignore this sometimes,but this personal judgments & comments have become way too regular🤔The only reason I would read these threads was to read things from a different perspective too but how can I when theses are the comments I find.
Edited by rose4ever - 8 years ago
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#22
Ha ha... Like Sona mentioned, her and Ranveer should have got written warning before signing marriage contract.

Here I'd like to mention something you wrote in your comment on Vibg's post. I am mentioning it here so that I don't clutter up her post with my rambling. Lol...

You wrote: From last 29 years Ishwari has deeply inserted a thought into Dev's vulnerable mind that only their family is destined for happiness.
Whole world is obliged to them to help them in achieving what they want and anyone not doing so will deserve a punishment.

and so was Dev's outburst on Sona,Ritwik and now on Ranveer.


Dixits are not normal like us .They are special and Sona is getting a feel of it.

Just like Article 370 - Dixits have separate rule book, special autonomous laws by virtue of their tragic past. Most importantly THEY HAVE SEPARATE HUMAN RIGHTS AS WELL such that anyone can be treated inhuman by them in their own interest.

At this point I think Dixits should put a flag outside their Ishwari Niwas and Ishwari Dixit communications so that anyone entering it knows that he/she is entering into a special law zone
and what mess he/she is getting himself into.(JANHIT ME JAARI,issued in public interest😉)

That I must say was an excellent analysis.

And yes, you are absolutely right. Ishwari's lessons on how family is only defined by blood relations, everyone else (including spouses) are outsiders and anyone who says anything that family objects to should be punished and put back into their place immediately, is now coming out in the form of her own daughter's ruined life.

I have mentioned Karma many times in my posts and it doesn't spare anyone.

I have often noticed that people who are overly religious are either like that because they truly are very much devoted to God or they know that they have done many sins and wants God to absolve them so they are basically bribing God.

Ishwari is the later.

She does no good deed at home, but keeps her all good deeds for outside to gain pat on her back and approval.

Originally posted by: Shilky88

Nice post 👏👏

The only sequence I could relate to your subject line was when Ranveer came to Dixits house to accept Dev's proposal and Neha- Ranveer marriage was fixed.

Dev said ' Welcome to family Ranveer'.

Imagine Dev saying in true sense
'Welcome to Psychiatrist's field trip Ranveer😉'

Enter on your own will and risk but we will ensure you will not leave unless all parts of your body stops functioning properly.

Brain which is spoiled by mad people like Neha/Dev and Ishwari
Stomach due to lack of food caused by lack of money and basic necessities being job-less
Heart and Blood pressure problems due to depression.

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
Rose, I am sorry to hear that you are upset. But think it this way. People who sling mud at other people, often get it thrown back in their face. If I were you, I won't take it personally.

Why? Because I think whoever they are talking about is not me because

1. My posts always attract intelligent adults who have agreed or disagreed with me, yet has been treated with respect as long as they are respectful.

2. There are also people who sometimes agree and sometimes disagree with what I write. I like each and every comment and respond with my own point of view. Unlike some posts who only like the comments that agree with them.

3. I always have healthy discussion happening with some very smart and strong women who are not so blind that they can't see from all point of view. We point out every character's good and bad qualities. So we are extremely unbiased.

4. I am a very proud Feminist... If that's what I am being called, thanks for the compliment. I am happy you think that I believe in equal rights regardless of gender and I am sorry that you think women are inferior to men. Your life must be so sad to be so disadvantaged.

5. If any of my comments hurt anyone, it doesn't take me two seconds to provide a public apology. I have still not seen any of them apologising for viciously attacking real human beings for fictional character.

6. If my posts weren't as attractive and my readers weren't so intelligent, I doubt they will bother with us. But they do. That means they have nothing intelligent to say, so they go by offence is the best defence method.

7. If they did not like our thoughts, they can apply their own advice and stay out of it. Practice what they are preaching you know. We are not responsible for their mental and emotional well-being. If they want to be positive, here's a positive idea - mind your own post.

I'd rather ignore them than stoop to their level.

Originally posted by: rose4ever

Tia this one is more of a personal rant/venting out,please bear with me.

Have any of us ever commented personally on other members even if their opinions don't match with ours? No,right? We either don't comment or simply state our views on their threads.Then why is it that we are being called
1.Dumb 2.Reason for the absence of positive members apparently 3.People who only criticize and never appreciate aka negative. 4.We talk only bakwaas.5.Words like mental disorder & psychiatrists are being thrown around without understanding by us. 6.Ooh we don't have sense and don't understand what really matters in life.And of course feminism is thrown as well(You know I don't think we have used the word feminism as much as those members have)
This is only from today's posts by some members.
Previously some even used words like bullies,rude,mean,immature,questioning how we lead our life etc,etc.
Now their suggestions are that we stop watching the show.In that case,they should stop reading the such post,shouldn't they?
Now I read in a post a day back that forum members do not like other members being judged for their opinions.So does that rule apply only for some members and not for all?
Sometimes I feel they don't even read posts and only judge by the title.When positives are discussed,do they read these posts then?

I know we've discussed this before,but I couldn't stop myself from writing this.I can ignore this sometimes,but this personal judgments & comments have become way too regular🤔The only reason I would read these threads was to read things from a different perspective too but how can I when theses are the comments I find.

Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago
rose4ever thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: tia.o

Rose, I am sorry to hear that you are upset. But think it this way. People who sling mud at other people, often get it thrown back in their face. If I were you, I won't take it personally.

Why? Because I think whoever they are talking about is not me because

1. My posts always attract intelligent adults who have agreed or disagreed with me, yet has been treated with respect as long as they are respectful.

2. There are also people who sometimes agree and sometimes disagree with what I write. I like each and every comment and respond with my own point of view. Unlike some posts who only like the comments that agree with them.

3. I always have healthy discussion happening with some very smart and strong women who are not so blind that they can't see from all point of view. We point out every character's good and bad qualities. So we are extremely biased.

4. I am a very proud Feminist... If that's what I am being called, thanks for the compliment. I am happy you think that I believe in equal rights regardless of gender.

5. If any of my comments hurt anyone, it doesn't take me two seconds to provide a public apology. I have still not seen any of them apologising for viciously attacking real human beings for fictional character.

6. If my posts weren't as attractive and my readers weren't so intelligent, I doubt they will bother with us. But they do. That means they have nothing intelligent to say, so they go by offence is the best defence method.

I'd rather ignore them than stoop to their level.


True,True.I get too senti sometimes I guess.😆Ignorance mode ON.🤗
dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#25
No not the part where Dev ousted Ranveer off his job..
but the scene where Ranveer sends notice to Neha - about mental torture.. Sona was referring to that as drama.. so i just hope it is not one of sona's ideas...

Originally posted by: tia.o

Exactly. Tit for tat... But I doubt even then Dev will notice anything. He will still think that has no similarities with Neha's situation because he had a sad past so everything should be forgiven.

No. I don't think it was a drama because Sona was genuinely surprised and upset to hear that Dev has thrown Ranveer out of his job.

She even goes to Bose house where Dev goes to woo her back.

If this was all a drama, then Sona won't have been so upset. She'd just pretend to support Dev so that Neha defends Ranveer.

But just like Dev, Neha can't see her own fault either.

Edited by dlavanya - 8 years ago
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
Tia 2 posts in a row too good😆
For today's episode I will watch once I reach airport (my bi-weekly travel to USA hits me bad 😔) but I can't wait till that to post my reviews.

I am shocked, shocked that Sona found it very unlikely of Dev to do something like this😆. Why ? Didn't Sona see Dev doing it twice with her and innocent people around her ? Oh she must have enjoyed that time since the intention of those actions must be to have Sona in precious Dev's life. But today she can't accept the same behavior when another innocent guy is victim who has nothing to do with Sona😆. I am amused at Sona's surprise.


I must say, this is one department where Ishwari scores better. Except for her possessiveness over Dev, she has never showed/insulted outsiders. She has accepted all insults from Bose Baba and even treated Ranveer with respect which Dev failed to do.


Psychiatrists's field day -

Ishwari - The issue is with Insecurity and possessiveness. Remaining all her actions I find more or less understandable or relatable. Once her possessiveness with Dev decreases, she would automatically get closer to her daughters.


Neha - The most needy patient. She suffers from acute depression and inferiority complexfrom lifelong deprivation of her rights, her mother's love, affection and care and had been made a mother when she herself needed one. Once she achieves mental peace and seeks for happiness within herself, she would be coming across as most sensible, unbiased and sweet girl. Only she has the ability to see things objectively, a quality Sona has for others except for Dev.


Sona - Suffers from the disease which in Jaane tu ya jaane na, the character of Meghna faced. Total ignorance to the reality and creating a dream world of her own where everyone's perfect and normal. This might be working as a slow poison. I hope somebody (may be Baba or someone from Bose, or even life) shows her the reality before it's too late and she becomes unable to face the ugliness of it.


Dev - The MOST injured child of all. Outwardly on the spot 2 problems can be identified - Anger issues and uncanny devotion towards a fellow human being to an extent which blocks judgement. If we go deeper, we will find complex layers of acute depression fed by guilt, guilt for being responsible of their dreaded childhood, guilt for not being able to protect his mother from the pain, guilt from depriving Neha of her rights, guilt for having their family face such terrible days - all of them are baseless and untrue, he did not cause all these, he has reasons to feel the sufferings, but has NO REASON to be GUILTY of those. Once he realizes how he alone with extreme struggle pulled the whole family out of poverty, once he realizes how he stood out in the crowd to grab every opportunity which came his way and got himself into Forbes List, how he has fulfilled his mommy's every dream, how he has grown up as a sensitive and respectful towards elders etc, he would know how much he has done for his family, he would realize that there is NO point of being in the guilt trip so often, that there is nothing more which as a son AND as himself a victim of poverty, could have done. Once he realizes that he should indeed be PROUD of himself and not GUILTY, he would automatically stop being so obnoxious and cruel to outsiders to do MORE for his family, once he realizes that, Ishwari will not be able to manipulate him so easily like she does now. And for all these, Ishwari is responsible, she has injected all these into each layer of his subconscious mind that he freaks out when he can't help his family. But everyone in your family is NOT your responsibility Dev. Don't lose your identity and individuality due to ANYONE else.


Howmuch ever annoying it is to see another super-girl Bahu in telly world with shitloads of expectations from her to rectify everything with a magic wand, but still I truly hope Sona would be able to bring that change into them.
Edited by Pehchaan.Kaun - 8 years ago
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#27
Hummm... I'd have thought so except Neha's bhabhi would have come clean after Ranveer losing her job. But she didn't. Also, after Ranveer's rant, I don't think he was in any mood to listen. On top of that it was the same day as Chota Diwali i.e. the day before Diwali. Sona didn't have sufficient time to formulate a plan, convince Ranveer and execute it. But then I am talking logic.

If Saurabh can have interview in Diwali and Ranveer can get a lawyer and deliver notice on Diwali, then logic obviously gaya tel lene.

Originally posted by: dlavanya

No not the part where Dev ousted Ranveer off his job..
but the scene where Ranveer sends notice to Neha - about mental torture.. Sona was referring to that as drama.. so i just hope it is not one of sona's ideas...

mena_k thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#28
Indeed, Dixit family can be a great study material for Psychiatry curriculum.

Infact, looking at the complexity, every member is a great subject for Ph.d. and that too the analysis won't be finished just by one researcher. Chalo kuch to kaam ayenge ye pagley dixit's 😉 😆

Love is blind, proof is Sonakshi (although its more like she has literally turned blind), No no I did not generalize anything here. She has seen all sides of Dev till date, but still Dev's action is a surprise for her, how dear seriously how. Dev is all love for the people around till they do what he wants them to do. The moment they disagree, he turns into a savage, who can do anything, be it shouting at his wife any number of times, or spoiling career and life of people. Is this what he termed as "revenge" when he spoke to Ranveer. Struggle of life makes a person more compassionate, however, in case of dixits it turned them into inhuman characters.

Dev's anger on Sona means yet another romantic moment of Dev-Sona coming up.
lucky guy, the more he gets angrier, the bigger is his reward from Sona.

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

Tia 2 posts in a row too good😆

For today's episode I will watch once I reach airport (my bi-weekly travel to USA hits me bad 😔) but I can't wait till that to post my reviews.

I am shocked, shocked that Sona found it very unlikely of Dev to do something like this😆. Why ? Didn't Sona see Dev doing it twice with her and innocent people around her ? Oh she must have enjoyed that time since the intention of those actions must be to have Sona in precious Dev's life. But today she can't accept the same behavior when another innocent guy is victim who has nothing to do with Sona😆. I am amused at Sona's surprise.

I am totally surprised too. She is like "Aap aise nehin hain" and I was like what? Did you forget Sona that when he wanted you to become Ishwari's nutritionist, he blocked everyone of your job prospect? Did he think that your family is depending on you? And you didn't even hurt his family then. In fact you saved his mother's life and that's how he treated you. And here he perceives Ranveer to be the cause of Neha's happiness. Why is it so difficult for you to imagine that he can take away that person's job?


I must say, this is one department where Ishwari scores better. Except for her possessiveness over Dev, she has never showed/insulted outsiders. She has accepted all insults from Bose Baba and even treated Ranveer with respect which Dev failed to do.

True. She doesn't insult in front of people. She attacks from behind in private. I wonder which one is worse. At least you can see a frontal attack coming. Subtle manipulation is harder to grasp and almost impossible to fight back.

Psychiatrists's field day -

Ishwari - The issue is with Insecurity and possessiveness. Remaining all her actions I find more or less understandable or relatable. Once her possessiveness with Dev decreases, she would automatically get closer to her daughters.

You are right. But the million dollar question is when her possessiveness will decrease? For everyone's sanity, I hope soon. But I won't hold my breath.

Neha - The most needy patient. She suffers from acute depression and inferiority complexfrom lifelong deprivation of her rights, her mother's love, affection and care and had been made a mother when she herself needed one. Once she achieves mental peace and seeks for happiness within herself, she would be coming across as most sensible, unbiased and sweet girl. Only she has the ability to see things objectively, a quality Sona has for others except for Dev.

Neha has a lot of potential. But she is still a little girl looking in from outside. She has to get over comparing her happiness with others and like you said, she needs to find her happiness within her and not look in other people or material things.

Sona - Suffers from the disease which in Jaane tu ya jaane na, the character of Meghna faced. Total ignorance to the reality and creating a dream world of her own where everyone's perfect and normal. This might be working as a slow poison. I hope somebody (may be Baba or someone from Bose, or even life) shows her the reality before it's too late and she becomes unable to face the ugliness of it.

Yes, sometimes Sona plays excellent ostrich specifically when it comes to Dev. She sees everyone else with full clarity but got strange tunnel vision and selective memory when it comes to Dev.

Dev - The MOST injured child of all. Outwardly on the spot 2 problems can be identified - Anger issues and uncanny devotion towards a fellow human being to an extent which blocks judgement. If we go deeper, we will find complex layers of acute depression fed by guilt, guilt for being responsible of their dreaded childhood, guilt for not being able to protect his mother from the pain, guilt from depriving Neha of her rights, guilt for having their family face such terrible days - all of them are baseless and untrue, he did not cause all these, he has reasons to feel the sufferings, but has NO REASON to be GUILTY of those. Once he realizes how he alone with extreme struggle pulled the whole family out of poverty, once he realizes how he stood out in the crowd to grab every opportunity which came his way and got himself into Forbes List, how he has fulfilled his mommy's every dream, how he has grown up as a sensitive and respectful towards elders etc, he would know how much he has done for his family, he would realize that there is NO point of being in the guilt trip so often, that there is nothing more which as a son AND as himself a victim of poverty, could have done. Once he realizes that he should indeed be PROUD of himself and not GUILTY, he would automatically stop being so obnoxious and cruel to outsiders to do MORE for his family, once he realizes that, Ishwari will not be able to manipulate him so easily like she does now. And for all these, Ishwari is responsible, she has injected all these into each layer of his subconscious mind that he freaks out when he can't help his family. But everyone in your family is NOT your responsibility Dev. Don't lose your identity and individuality due to ANYONE else.

You are absolutely right. It may seem that Ishwari did the most damage to Neha by depriving her from education and neglecting her, but actually she did maximum damage to Dev. His every action is motivated by his family's comfort and happiness. If he thinks that he can't get his family's well-being or happiness, then he takes ruthless steps to ensure that person pays for what he considers his failure.
I was almost scared by his obsessive looks today.

Howmuch ever annoying it is to see another super-girl Bahu in telly world with shitloads of expectations from her to rectify everything with a magic wand, but still I truly hope Sona would be able to bring that change into them.

I certainly hope so.

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#30
I know right? How does he gets rewarded every freaking time for wrecking havoc in other people's life and livelihood?

If a person had gone through the pain of being blind, would they make fun of another people's blindness? If a person has been abused, would they support another person being abused?

Then how could Dev, who went through poverty and starvation, play with another person's livelihood for his own whim?

That is incredibly insensitive.

It's anything but love.

Instead of focusing on Neha's happiness, his focus is in how to punish Ranveer. He never once thought that Ranveer's family who always treated Neha well will also suffer because of Dev.

Sorry, I have always protested Dev playing God with people's life using his money and I am still not okay with it.

Originally posted by: mena_k

Indeed, Dixit family can be a great study material for Psychiatry curriculum.

Infact, looking at the complexity, every member is a great subject for Ph.d. and that too the analysis won't be finished just by one researcher. Chalo kuch to kaam ayenge ye pagley dixit's 😉 😆

Love is blind, proof is Sonakshi (although its more like she has literally turned blind), No no I did not generalize anything here. She has seen all sides of Dev till date, but still Dev's action is a surprise for her, how dear seriously how. Dev is all love for the people around till they do what he wants them to do. The moment they disagree, he turns into a savage, who can do anything, be it shouting at his wife any number of times, or spoiling career and life of people. Is this what he termed as "revenge" when he spoke to Ranveer. Struggle of life makes a person more compassionate, however, in case of dixits it turned them into inhuman characters.

Dev's anger on Sona means yet another romantic moment of Dev-Sona coming up.
lucky guy, the more he gets angrier, the bigger is his reward from Sona.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".