Jodha Akbar 9th April 2015..Sweet and Bitter...LONG analysis upd Pg-1 - Page 3

Originally posted by: sweet_diksha

those punishments were way too harsh for a 7 year old kid... i m not justifying Salim , but Akbar also was not right the way he always punished Salim... Akbar was always like a shehenshah where salim was/is concerned, not as a father...

and Salim was the one who was always kept away, nor other kids... there r many ways to make a kid understand, and make him apologize for his mistakes... only harsh punishments r not always only way to deal with it... but if a kid is always punished for every mistake whether done intentionally or unintentionally, then there r only two ways he will react... either he will finish himself thinking nobody needs him, or he will revolt against this parents and everybody else whom he will feel responsible in snatching away his rights...

Abhay, it was indeed a bitter and sweet episode. Thanks for the update.

I just can't still understand the writers even if they are full of men than women ( why do they lack the ability to remember their own dialogues from previous write ups)?

Since the birth of Salim, Jalal had set out to make him the best next King. What has he done so far in actions to bring this about?

If my memory is not like theirs I remember they showed their character Jalal arguing with their character Jodha that by sending Salim as 9 years old would make him a good warrior King as compared to Jodha's suggestions that he should be corrected and be trained at home step by step as he grows.

Jalal was more interested if I remember the dialogues well of Salim becoming a rebel first and then a noble second so now what is his problem? Why is he questioning whether Salim is fit for a King?

Now that Salim has become a rebel Jalal wants to act as a father and show Salim discipline to become a noble how will this work as a the rebel heart is full of roots of evil seeds, hate, harden heart that has already been created so whose fault is it that today Salim is displaying an unfit characteristics as the next King.

Has he ever giving MUZ as a mother a chance to be a mother to her son without bringing in his famous 'think like MUZ' and today he rejected simple counsel to treat this matter in close doors just because his idea of bringing to book his son is different and always (foolish) that only leads to more complications than solutions.

These writers of Jodha Akbar should really stop insulting the office of a writer! Their way of presentation is so pathetic and illogical. How insulting to this wonderful office and talent.

Originally posted by: overactor

today's episode had the Jalal i love 😎 where he behaves as a shehenshah and not a husband of jodha😡 he was awesome i loved it when he said door hojaye to hojaye👏 and that murad is more capable⭐️ sometimes jodha appears selfish🥱 why should salim be the wali ehed when he doesn't deserve it👎🏼

i wish murad had called anarkali's name instead of saying kaneez only

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon

Thanks Abhay. Just took time to watch the episode...

My comments on the episode. The pooja scene was a treat to watch and loved the dialogues by Jalal and Jodha. The way jalal explained to Jodha why he does not want her to convert. At the same time Jodha asked Jalal too, if he is able to fast and follow Hindu traditions being a Muslim, she can do the same even if she converted. That said Conversion should not happen forcefully which Jalal pointed out .👏


Coming to Salim I have nothing to say except he is mentally weak and like Jalal said is he even fit to be a King. Murad was right in his Place. Anar should have Kept quiet she should not have interfered.

Coming to DEK scene, Salim should not have confronted. Murad said that Salim insulted him in front of a Kaniz. Very good. That said, Abhay I have a question for you..I would have Preferred first Jalal to talk to Salim in front of HB, SB, Ruks, Murad etc and not in DEK. Earlier initially during JJ separation, Mamaga was interrogated privately first and then brought to DEK. Why are CVS so inconsistent here. Why do I feel that Jalal was as a father here today and was overstrict with Salim.

Precap, I will wait for tomorrow to watch and then comment. As normally everything is shown opposite to what we see in Precap.

AM sure Salim refused and Jalal may have given some punishment. I hope it is that salim is send on a war. Rather than a fight among JJ in Precap, I see a worried wife cum mother who is worried about father son MU.

Abhay am venting today am not impress at all, really upset with the writers after the God track. They should be mindful of building up a story and stop giving us half-baked and shirt and blouse tracks for goodness sake! We surely deserve better after sticking with their sorry- ...es for all this while.😡

Anytime they touch on 'family dynamics track the writers disappoint me 🥱

IF after coming back to the family' after his training as a warrior Jalal had taken the pains to make Salim understood the "Kingship responsibilities" and have put him through some form of one on one mentoring through some episodes then this crisis arise and he is trying to solve the problem in a tricky' way so Salim might learn later and decide to hide this I will not be upset with his methods towards his son. Here the writers sucks big time. As a viewer I could then say that after all the investment done by Jalal as a King and a Father to bring out the best in Salim he has failed to live up to the expectations.

However the Scenario painted by the writers is different and therefore both Jodha and Jalal sucks as father and mother and their son sucks as a son period (dysfunctional family in the name of drama).

His training as a warrior was not even done by Jalal but by Man Sigh and since he came back all the writers have shown is nonessential issues that has not involve son and father mentoring! What has their character Jalal invested in his son so far apart from shouting, hiding things from him with the notion of protecting him(how will he learn to deal with complicated situations when everything should be hidden from him (who at all writers this kind of meaningless crap that only raise bp) and slapping him for supposedly taken afeem which at the end Jalal was made a fool too. Seriously! 😕

Up till now the "all knowing, all smart, all powerful, all teda, all loving, all sharp perceiving King" has not yet realize that what happen years back has put a stain on his son's perception of him as a father and does not understand that his behavior is retaliation only nor does his many informants in the palace able to tell him that his son is seeing a royal dancer or in love with her nor he is a drug addict instead of solving this old track they leave them hanging and bring in more nonsense. (now if that is not stupidity of the writers in building they character Jalal's image I don't know what it is anymore).

This formula of character Jalal creating his own troubles with his own intelligent' decisions my f..t and then later characrter Jodha bears the heat of it despite her putting in her suggestions as a mother, wife etc is becoming very, very boring and annoying. It is time for the writers to think out of this box.😡

I wonder whether there are specialties among them freaks because it looks like only one person writes for positive (sweet) tracks so it is limited.