unfair to give immunity ball in 2nd dance w/o seeing/ judging other? - Page 3

Originally posted by: SheDevil

There was one gal who was there live in show. She told in real shamita was last to perform and thts why they didn't wait to c others

I personally liked her performance.. Abhi tak kisi nai bhi wow performance nahi di.. I mean kisi nai bhi nhi.. Not in 4-5 weeks.. May b future k liye rakhna chahiye tha.. Though I loved shamita today

PS-the fact Yeh hai sab chahenge their fav should get it and kisi ko bhi milta beside their fav unhe biased hi lagta..

ok, so Shamita performed last and it means that the show changed order of performances...its the unorganized editing then...bcoz what viewers r concluding that judges ne jaldbazi me decvision liya...

Originally posted by: memad

ok, so Shamita performed last and it means that the show changed order of performances...its the unorganized editing then...bcoz what viewers r concluding that judges ne jaldbazi me decvision liya...

I liked her performance. It is not easy to do helen dance wid same grace.. So I am f9..

Agree 👍🏼

After seeing everyone's performance dey should give immunity ball.

she is one of my favorites in this show, cz she is such a beautiful dancer!
But i guess they could have awarded it at end of tomorrow episode when all the viewers have seen the performances too!

Like they mention - Performance of the week at that time, they should have done this immunity ball also same way.
And I wonder how Performance of the week became sm1 else and this went to some1 else..
That itself is a screwed up!

Just commenting on what I know happened on the TV today/tomorrow from articles and comments.

They r so messy, disorganized and insane in the programming front this year! :(

Originally posted by: memad

I am not fan of Shamita but never dislike her although I really love Deepak's choreography..

The Question here is not that whether Shamita deserved it/ not or how she danced or whether she did justice to Helen / not?

Question is PREMATURE AWARDING OF THE BALL...

She may have deserved it n danced good as u mentioned...n may be in the end, she would hv won the ball...
but without seeing others, one cannot declare that a XYZ person is the best...that too just in 2nd performance...

Sorry, I disagree...there was never a mutual decision about THE BALL...judges praised her...but never unanimously decided about the ball...and even if they had, i would still call it a rash decision...

P.S. .

secondly, i m not discussing here whether shamita deserved or not...my complain is only with hasty decision of judges...

abhi someone told na , that someone sittting there just told that her performance was last . Thats all editing problems but even if it was not last , it was fair . Because i have seen many shows , igt has golden budger , they dont wait for all the performance to get over to click on it .They click it on an awesome performance and they just have 3 of them at the most .But if they got another performance , jisse woh budger dena Hi hain ( this happened just one time , because always the one to whom they give are the besttt), than they introduced an extra golden budger . It's about which performance just took your heart to make you click on it . And Shamita performance was bang on , judges just felt like giving it to her and they gave .Its not some performance of the week , its which touched your heart ,they loved Shamita , they gave her . Even before dancing shoes were given like this only . So its very normal for me and not unfair or specially done for Shamita as people are claiming. I disagree that all judges don't want to give her , we may be watching different shows than I saw the enthusiasm in all giving her the ball .Shahid in front of him went to the ball and picked it .They found that performance the best for the ball and they gave it .

Originally posted by: SheDevil

I liked her performance. It is not easy to do helen dance wid same grace.. So I am f9..

As u mentioned, judges hv delivered the ball in the end after seeing all..
Now I would call ur opinion hasty...Shamita is good but did u see others?... atleast judges did...😕

looks like Shamita fandom speaking for u.😉...anyways, m not against Shamita n not even u or not mean to criticize u with my comments ...😊...

think rationally...hope u understand what m trying to say..

m against judges ki jaldbazi...

honestly, judges made Shamita's act discreditable / undeservedly over-creditable for me...wish editors hv shown it in last then it would had looked proper...

wo tumne sahi kaha ke sab apne fav ko jitana chahenge...,mujhe shamita se koi problem nahi...judges ki marzi...but ye sab sunday ko last dikhate to thik lagta tha..

@memad its not Shamita fandom speaking In any of us . She is neither a top telly celebrity nor a very successful Bollywood celebrity to have fandoms and all .All people speaking here are supporting Shamita for first time in this show only , especially here in india forums .So lets not go into the fandom thing . People are supporting because she danced gracefully and did full justice to it .You said its not about that if Shamita deserved it or not and the moment a person told you that she was last to perform , you started challenging that person's openion , judges decision ?...truly speaking had radhika for today's performance got this , I could have understand . But Shamita getting and that too after such a lovely performance is shocking .

Originally posted by: memad

As u mentioned, judges hv delivered the ball in the end after seeing all..
Now I would call ur opinion hasty...Shamita is good but did u see others?... atleast judges did...😕

looks like Shamita fandom speaking for u.😉...anyways, m not against Shamita n not even u or not mean to criticize u with my comments ...😊...

think rationally...hope u understand what m trying to say..

m against judges ki jaldbazi...

honestly, judges made Shamita's act discreditable / undeservedly over-creditable for me...wish editors hv shown it in last then it would had looked proper...

wo tumne sahi kaha ke sab apne fav ko jitana chahenge...,mujhe shamita se koi problem nahi...judges ki marzi...but ye sab sunday ko last dikhate to thik lagta tha..

Luks like u dont knw me even with ur RishBala DP.. I m vivian fan and kisi ko immunity ball milne se mujhe sabse zyada khushi hoti toh woh vivian hota.. I m more shocked ki u thought I m shamita pankha whn I myself saw ur comments many time in my post in MB forum.. I jst appreciate gud dance and not dumb blind fan gal..😆😆

And IGT mai Karan , kiran and malaika press golden buzzer jo performance unko acha lagta hai.. Toh kya woh wait karte hai ki nahi pehle let me c all performances tab golden buzzer press hoga.. 😆😆

PS- So no shamita was gud even if she was given immunity ball I have no problem and I even said they could have waited for future but fact is I mean it ppl will always b unsatisfied as long as their fav get the ball😉😆😆