unfair to give immunity ball in 2nd dance w/o seeing/ judging other?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Rafangirl

@Rafangirl

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: Komal.S
Unfair ... I would love if my fave got(sanaya) but I know there are others who deserves more than her but that contestant wasn't shamita

It was either raftaaar or mohit

They should have waited for all the contestants dance if they wanted to give today or they should have waited for several weeks like last season

yes, it could be anyone...
it seemed a hasty decision to immediately prize Shamita...

Quote

LazyBing

@LazyBing

Stunner

+ 11

Posted: 10 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: memad

really? performances r not shown in order...that's a revelation for me to be honest...😲

even if Shamita had performed at later stage unlike 2nd as seen in the episode and they handed ball in the end after watching all performances, WHY THEY SHOWED US THAT BALL HANDING PART NOW..TODAY...IMMEDIATELY AFTER SHAMITA PERFORMANCE?

it is poor editing then, i must say...bcoz their partial juding is projected to the viewers...

yes. I agree..JDJ is seriously messed up this year. CVs have gone completely crazy. For instance: last week was suppose to be a face off with both groups and the only face off that was clearly shown was Faisal and Vivians. All the rest was done in any order. That is ridiculous! 😕

Edited by Ashvikian_AK - 10 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Rafangirl

@Rafangirl

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: _innocent_
Undeserving acts acquire undeserving scores on this show! And this has been the case from the beginning, so what is if the problem if the same partiality is being used? Is it only fair when its conducted on one or two contestants and when others acquire the same treatment, then it becomes unfair?😆

😆😉...kya karen...it is the tragedy of the show..

Quote

surbhi tyagi

@EtherealRati

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#14

Shamita danced beautifully and completely deserved the ball for recreating Helen on stage .She was so graceful and elegant .And it was not like that it was just ganesh decision .KJO shouted I loved it even before manish approached him .Shahid was the one who went and picked up the ball for her .Lauren was impressed to core and then ganesh gave her the ball . A mutual thing between judges , she completely completely deserved it .And I am very happy for her and I am not a fan or something but I loved the way she danced. Such a spotless performance it was , the alone part just blew me off and so did the ending . She actualky did complete justice to Helen .Its not that easy to perform Helen .She was so much into the skin . Fantastic performance . Hatrs off to Shamita and their choreographer . They deserved the ball completely .

Quote

Rafangirl

@Rafangirl

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: Ashvikian_AK
yes. I agree..JDJ is seriously messed up this year. CVs have gone completely crazy. For instance: last week was suppose to be a face off with both groups and the only face off that was clearly shown was Faisal and Vivians. All the rest was done in any order. That is ridiculous! 😕

yes right...that face off was big joke..😕

Quote

Resh

@SheDevil

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#16

There was one gal who was there live in show. She told in real shamita was last to perform and thts why they didn't wait to c others

I personally liked her performance.. Abhi tak kisi nai bhi wow performance nahi di.. I mean kisi nai bhi nhi.. Not in 4-5 weeks.. May b future k liye rakhna chahiye tha.. Though I loved shamita today

PS-the fact Yeh hai sab chahenge their fav should get it and kisi ko bhi milta beside their fav unhe biased hi lagta..

Edited by SheDevil - 10 years ago

Quote

viji2111

@viji2111

Dazzler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#17

They could have given her the dancing shoes like in previous seasons.

Quote

Paytonlee

@Paytonlee

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#18

When is it ever fair in jhalak.

Quote

Rafangirl

@Rafangirl

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: EtherealRati
Shamita danced beautifully and completely deserved the ball for recreating Helen on stage .She was so graceful and elegant .And it was not like that it was just ganesh decision .KJO shouted I loved it even before manish approached him .Shahid was the one who went and picked up the ball for her .Lauren was impressed to core and then ganesh gave her the ball . A mutual thing between judges , she completely completely deserved it .And I am very happy for her and I am not a fan or something but I loved the way she danced. Such a spotless performance it was , the alone part just blew me off and so did the ending . She actualky did complete justice to Helen .Its not that easy to perform Helen .She was so much into the skin . Fantastic performance . Hatrs off to Shamita and their choreographer . They deserved the ball completely .

I am not fan of Shamita but never dislike her although I really love Deepak's choreography..

The Question here is not that whether Shamita deserved it/ not or how she danced or whether she did justice to Helen / not?

Question is PREMATURE AWARDING OF THE BALL...

She may have deserved it n danced good as u mentioned...n may be in the end, she would hv won the ball...
but without seeing others, one cannot declare that a XYZ person is the best...that too just in 2nd performance...

Sorry, I disagree...there was never a mutual decision about THE BALL...judges praised her...but never unanimously decided about the ball...and even if they had, i would still call it a rash decision...

P.S. .

secondly, i m not discussing here whether shamita deserved or not...my complain is only with hasty decision of judges...