unfair to give immunity ball in 2nd dance w/o seeing/ judging other? - Page 5

Originally posted by: EtherealRati

Shamita danced beautifully and completely deserved the ball for recreating Helen on stage .She was so graceful and elegant .And it was not like that it was just ganesh decision .KJO shouted I loved it even before manish approached him .Shahid was the one who went and picked up the ball for her .Lauren was impressed to core and then ganesh gave her the ball . A mutual thing between judges , she completely completely deserved it .And I am very happy for her and I am not a fan or something but I loved the way she danced. Such a spotless performance it was , the alone part just blew me off and so did the ending . She actualky did complete justice to Helen .Its not that easy to perform Helen .She was so much into the skin . Fantastic performance . Hatrs off to Shamita and their choreographer . They deserved the ball completely .

@EtherealRati : Completely agree. To emulate Helen, you need to hav excellent footwork and the song she chose was apt. The expressions and costume was so much in sync. Shamita was fab and as rightly pointed out, it was Karan/Shahid and them the ball was thrown to Ganesh...it was deserving.


-Rekha

Originally posted by: SheDevil

ya in my post u did😳
No problem at all
I said I have no problem shamita that got ball but ya I d agree they used it too early.They could have waited for more weeks😳 In fact I was more shocked ki aaj introduce kiya and aaj hi de diya😆😆 but ab kisi ko bhi diya usse I have no issue

but now i would remember u..😳...
by chance, at any point, did u hv madhubala or vivian dp? i think u did...don't u? 😛

haha...seriously...aaj hi ball ko de diya...😆😉...

ab kal dekhte hain...kya hota hain...see u soon somewhere on the forum...glad to hv reconnected with u😳😊

Originally posted by: memad

yes, m not to discuss whether shamita deserved or not...m sure there r many other threads discussing that...all im is against judges fast n rash decision...which is injustice for others...

yes, I am challenging judges decision from the beginning much before when some1 said she was last to perform...which is again not confirmed bcoz we don't know if it is coming from a reliable source...

be its radhika/ shamita or whoever...but giving away immunity ball within 15-20 min was really a joke...

that's not the performance of the week . It is not necessary it is given to performance of the week even .This has been happening in many other shows and jdj itself .Even their judges can't guarantee ki isse badiya aage aayega Hi nahi but they do give to whom they love .Performing an Helen and nailing it kisi bhi judge se ball dilwa sakta hain . Because it's too difficult to justify a Helen act .And if there will be someone more better , than they know what they have to do .May be they will introduce two balls for that particular seek or something . In all performers who today performed , Shamita deserved it the most . Performance of the week and ball is different . Woh alag baat hain jab act faisal ke last time Jaisa Ho , toh dono ek ko Hi mile .I feel she deserved and as it has been a format and not something new introduced . I found it normal as a viewer . Shoes bhi aise Hi dete the last season's yeh log .Aise toh jdj mein sab Hi unfair hain , because Jo bhi jeet jaata hain , he is never the best dancer among all . They kind of use train dancers to attract audience , now a non dancer wins over the most awesome dancer of season . Is that fair ??? But it does happens ,as it always has been happening . Thus even when I love faisal , I know anybody but faisal will win . As faisal is the best of the lot , he will never win .

Originally posted by: SheDevil

I didnt went there. But the lady who shared everything said tht shamita didnt performed.He performance is later and tab tak raftaar, sanaya, mohit,vivian, faisal perform kar chuke thai😳
Editing huyi thi to match the episode ..Iss baar bahut kuch chaos hua hai.. Again agar hua bhi hai toh iske baad bas 1-2 performance bachi thi
Judges in begining itself said they can give this ball anytime. After or before performance.

Same thing happen with Golden buzzer in IGT and last time bhi yeh ball thi😳

Even I fell it is unfair with other contestants they should wait and honestly I didn't feel it was solo good for immunity

This season I am not understanding how they score and on what basis faisal performance was not good but it was not that bad that they give him 8

I didn't watch the episode yet. But this time the judges are dumbfounding me with their injustice and unfairness. Their marking are not right and their partiality for some contestants are very much visible.

Agree... I was like first see all the performances then decide, who knows someone else could be better than them. 😕

Yes the judges shud hav watched all the acts before giving the immunity vall,moreover shamita was not that good that she got the immunity ball

Shamita was good but she was definitely not the last one to perform. She was sitting on that golden sofa during faisal's performance.

Originally posted by: EtherealRati

that's not the performance of the week . It is not necessary it is given to performance of the week even .This has been happening in many other shows and jdj itself .Even their judges can't guarantee ki isse badiya aage aayega Hi nahi but they do give to whom they love .Performing an Helen and nailing it kisi bhi judge se ball dilwa sakta hain . Because it's too difficult to justify a Helen act .And if there will be someone more better , than they know what they have to do .May be they will introduce two balls for that particular seek or something . In all performers who today performed , Shamita deserved it the most . Performance of the week and ball is different . Woh alag baat hain jab act faisal ke last time Jaisa Ho , toh dono ek ko Hi mile .I feel she deserved and as it has been a format and not something new introduced . I found it normal as a viewer . Shoes bhi aise Hi dete the last season's yeh log .Aise toh jdj mein sab Hi unfair hain , because Jo bhi jeet jaata hain , he is never the best dancer among all . They kind of use train dancers to attract audience , now a non dancer wins over the most awesome dancer of season . Is that fair ??? But it does happens ,as it always has been happening . Thus even when I love faisal , I know anybody but faisal will win . As faisal is the best of the lot , he will never win .

OMG, i cannot imagine performance of week n ball to 2 different people. I mean on what basis they do is really perplexing...

anyways ball is already awarded...lets see if today any1 can perform at such a high level to make judges repent their own decision..