IP REDUX; Confluence !!! - Page 58

Created

Last reply

Replies

902

Views

45.7k

Users

67

Likes

4.4k

Frequent Posters

redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago


Character sketch - one can always argue that khushi was always like this, hiding small issues, small pranks, small lies, sacrificing everything for her family.

But my point was how khushi stands when i measure her using my moral yardstick.Khushi has evolved from silly non harmful lies to pretty big ones. Thats a fact!. And for a viewer(and i do believe Indian audiences, especially telly, are not matured enough to handle a grey shaded female lead), I have issues digesting the lies she is churning out and many more.

If you ask me, From story POV who is responsible for khushi's worries? - I would say she herself is responsible for the kidnapping mess. Had it been handled in a different way, things would have looked so much brighter. But earlier my answer was different - I used to say Shyal\fate\ASR played with her life. This is the difference in scenario i pointed out.

btw what is g club?

G CLub

Gul
Gautam
Gorky
Gandhi

😉

wanna join ... ?

waise i wish Koel was here .. she wanted me to stir the hornets nest today ... 😉
Jhalak29 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
GM Chicka's
Hows the world of RRREEEDDD UUUXXX today?
--Anna-- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sree07


Character sketch - one can always argue that khushi was always like this, hiding small issues, small pranks, small lies, sacrificing everything for her family.

But my point was how khushi stands when i measure her using my moral yardstick.Khushi has evolved from silly non harmful lies to pretty big ones. Thats a fact!. And for a viewer(and i do believe Indian audiences, especially telly, are not matured enough to handle a grey shaded female lead), I have issues digesting the lies she is churning out and many more.

If you ask me, From story POV who is responsible for khushi's worries? - I would say she herself is responsible for the kidnapping mess. Had it been handled in a different way, things would have looked so much brighter. But earlier my answer was different - I used to say Shyal\fate\ASR played with her life. This is the difference in scenario i pointed out.

btw what is g club?

Sree mera toh tujhe pata hai! I never blame ASR or Shyam for Khushi's problem! Because she got herself into this mess by giving Shyam another chance when the pregnancy issue came in. Yes Arnav did mess her life up - no denying that - but her lack of realizing what the real world is even after coming face to face with Shyam's real character - and then not confiding in anyone is totally her fault. Its always easier to blame the guy - but the girl who takes it all - is equally responsible.
As a girl she should have the courage to fight out with Arnav and Shyam in a way that should have left them astounded. That would have been character growth.
Edited by --Anna-- - 13 years ago
--Anna-- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
Chalo now is chutti at work! Me going home! Hopes alive for a good episode and breaking down of Khushi! C ya all tomorrow or maybe not (I have to go shopping for my Goa trip )
Ruby , Teju, Sree, ranju, Riti - loved discussing with you guys today!
Love all
Anna
..mrinalini.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
I for one was totally pissed off seeing Sanaya's reaction in the blood scene.Or was it CVs' fault!!I don't know..But even I felt bad watching our dear old Arnie boy's blood on that creepwa's shoe..And Khushi!!Oh dear!!What if her husband is killed!!THAT'S BLOOD FOR GOD'S SAKE!!Her husband is probably physically tortured..Doesn't that bother her??Well,it bothers me🤣
sree07 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Sree mera toh tujhe pata hai! I never blame ASR or Shyam for Khushi's problem! Because she got herself into this mess by giving Shyam another chance when the pregnancy issue came in. Yes Arnav did mess her life up - no denying that - but her lack of realizing what the real world is even after coming face to face with Shyam's real character - and then not confiding in anyone is totally her fault. Its always easier to blame the guy - but the girl who takes it all - is equally responsible.
As a girl she should have the courage to fight out with Arnav and Shyam in a way that should have left them astounded. That would have been character growth.


@anna .. I agree khush has gone astray during kidnapping track.
But before that i do maintain my stand that she was a victim and I would never blame the victim, no matter what, be it any crime.
Here in kidnapping track, khushi is not the victim... ASR is the victim.
Edited by sree07 - 13 years ago
sree07 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sampin

I for one was totally pissed off seeing Sanaya's reaction in the blood scene.Or was it CVs' fault!!I don't know..But even I felt bad watching our dear old Arnie boy's blood on that creepwa's shoe..And Khushi!!Oh dear!!What if her husband is killed!!THAT'S BLOOD FOR GOD'S SAKE!!Her husband is probably physically tortured..Doesn't that bother her??Well,it bothers me🤣


I think we should step back and see the real picture.
Sanaya emotes whatever the director asks her to do.
And if her reaction was not satisfactory to him then he would have gone for retake. So here in this context, seems like director got what he wanted and he definitely did not want any extreme reaction from khushi - the character(we saw that)

I think it may be unfair to compare the lack of character's emotions with an actors abilities.
..mrinalini.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: sree07


I think we should step back and see the real picture.
Sanaya emotes whatever the director asks her to do.
And if her reaction was not satisfactory to him then he would have gone for retake. So here in this context, seems like director got what he wanted and he definitely did not want any extreme reaction from khushi - the character(we saw that)

I think it may be unfair to compare the lack of character's emotions with an actors abilities.


YES,I agree!!Probably the director was satisfied!!But how could he be??Because as much as I understand acting..that wasn't upto the mark!!Specially when a young wife sees her missing husband's blood and is aware of the fact that he is kidnapped,how could she be like that??Sorry,but I couldn't buy the reaction!!Maybe our Khan Sahab could!!

Or it might also be that they want to portrait Khushi as a strong girl who's on a mission..But still seeing your husband's blood..How could she be so unfazed!!

tintin70 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Sree mera toh tujhe pata hai! I never blame ASR or Shyam for Khushi's problem! Because she got herself into this mess by giving Shyam another chance when the pregnancy issue came in. Yes Arnav did mess her life up - no denying that - but her lack of realizing what the real world is even after coming face to face with Shyam's real character - and then not confiding in anyone is totally her fault. Its always easier to blame the guy - but the girl who takes it all - is equally responsible.
As a girl she should have the courage to fight out with Arnav and Shyam in a way that should have left them astounded. That would have been character growth.




Just imagine, someone close to you has been kidnapped and you have seen him being carried blindfolded in front of you.

Now will you go on your day to day work as usual? Like come back home, eat,sleep, take bath , get dressed and attend pujas ???? My God, I will not even go home till I do something... Even if I don't want to tell to other members of family, I will take help from someone and do something... One life is at stake. The goons can wipe away the life anytime...
I guess, this is what the fiction is all about...


riyya6 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
the whole problem is kidnapping track dragged beyond limit... now thats the drawback... i do agree they should show khushi 's emotion here but of course they cannot show her worry only for one day n forgets... but at least they need to show... i really dun understand Cv, Barun is not around,... Sanaya is given full take, this girl need a break too... They can show shyam-anjali, akash-payal... these character are there n they are connected with Arhi... at least the distribution is there n scenes can be worked out accordingly...
Leave anjali shes pregnant... but wwhat happen to Khushi-payal r/ship... they hardly shared anything between them after the marriage... how could it be possible... the bonding must be there..
u see payal, GH members knows abt shyam. khushi should share her problem with them... imagine the bonding of family to help her... yes KKG does not want anyone to get worried but involvement of family member must be there unless u have an evil family 😆 viewers like this kind of bonding with drama... look at the top shows its not only love element but big dramas... of course we dun want saas bahu drama but theres lots more to show... think out of the box
Edited by riyya6 - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".