Deepali didnt now where she made mistake? - Page 4

Originally posted by: coolsonu

well, then Joshiji....as majority of us including deepali herself didnt understand wat was wrong in her performance according to Anu Malik , so I think SONY should hire you to do the job of explaining his comments...It will b very good for all of us and the contestants too!!

sonuji, i wouldnt mind that at all as i have gud knowledge of music..

music is not easy.. its a very very complicated field.

tpam. i am not demeaning deepali as overall she's quite an okay singer. but she needs to become humble and learn more.

Originally posted by: tpam

haila jenny tu mujhe kab se tpam kehne lagi?😕😆😆

aww...amu di....popularity mein kami ho rahi hai??!!😆

Originally posted by: joshi23

This is a first sensible post seem to be coming from a deepali fan. I like your #2 point that deepali might have lost her focus in the mukhra because she was walking in stairs from a dimly light place into the manj.

BUT,, then you look at Abhishek. Abhishek basically did the same thing with his song singing the mukhra 'dunia me, logo ne dil apne phir thaame.. aye hoon leker mein phir kitne hangame' at a dim lit stairs..

But Abhishek was flawless. This is mark of a brilliant singer.

soo....u hav compared Deepali to Puja and now Abhishek......compare her to other 9 contestants as well.....shayad tab aapko lagay Deepali is not the worst!

Originally posted by: joshi23

This is a first sensible post seem to be coming from a deepali fan. I like your #2 point that deepali might have lost her focus in the mukhra because she was walking in stairs from a dimly light place into the manj.

BUT,, then you look at Abhishek. Abhishek basically did the same thing with his song singing the mukhra 'dunia me, logo ne dil apne phir thaame.. aye hoon leker mein phir kitne hangame' at a dim lit stairs..

But Abhishek was flawless. This is mark of a brilliant singer.

I am her pankha - there is no question about it. I think she is the best !!

I am just trying to make it conducive for her to do her job. I am not sure but I do not think Abhi walked downstairs - I think he was on flat territory to start with . Regardless, we are focussing on Deepali so bringing Abhi into this is bit out of the discussion.

PS: Danka for admitting to the sensible post - I have to be fair ......

Originally posted by: joshi23

sonuji, i wouldnt mind that at all as i have gud knowledge of music..

music is not easy.. its a very very complicated field.

tpam. i am not demeaning deepali as overall she's quite an okay singer. but she needs to become humble and learn more.

firstly..I am not Sonu Niigam😆I mean my name is not Sonu....its nimra😃well, if u r ready, mein sifarish karwaoon??😆yes, u r right....music is very complicated and it involves loadza confusions too...right?

kia sab waqaee bhag gaye? 😕 😆 dekha...amu di main ne kaha tha na!!!!😆

Deepali was wrong - Puja was right
Deepali was arrogant - abhishek is better
Deepali was rude - Smita was humble
.
.
.
I read all posts n replies but the common thing I found was that^^...

may be many ppl are in hope that Deepali makes ONE mistake and they start picking on her but see when they got it also its not worth arguing... its too small to be ignored

tpam, I dont intend to hurt deepali fans. But I want to tell them that they should realize that its better for their #1 contender i.e. Deepali to remain humble. It was not in the good taste with Sony playing her skit of her telling Puja that 'hum itni effort karte he par anu malik ji ne humein dead singing bol diya'.. Its makes her sound like she didnt like judges comments..

coolsonu.. yes music is very complicated

sarah.. thats not the case. i am a humble guy

Originally posted by: joshi23

sarah.. thats not the case. i am a humble guy

yes buddy... thats fine you are pointing out something we never did but the approach is somewhat not tht easy that we accept it... it was better if you shudnt have included other contestants' names here... one thing we all need to agree that Deepali is the best singer out there now... and if we try hard also we dont actually find anything wrong in her whereas others make mistakes every now & then so talking about her very very small mistake is nothing compared to what others do :)

Originally posted by: joshi23

I disagree with your notion because its quite simplistic. Puja is just one example but others that come to my mind are Smitha, Amit, Prashant and Charu as well. When Smitha and Amit were criticized by Udit, Prashant and Charu by Javed, all of them remained either quiet or nodded to accept their mistake and didnt say anything 'against' the judges.

Deepali is taking things a bit too easy. She thins that she is the cutest of all females and the best singer as well so she 'cannot be criticized'. That she is above them all.

If a senior judge and a big music director like Anu thinks her singing/performance was overall not upto II standards, she she listen quietly and try to improve. Not indulge in one-on-one discussion with the judges.

i dont think she said anything against the judges...she said she didn't know where she made a mistake so she was being honest ...she didn't say it in an ARROGANT way ...if she had said something like "Oh sir i dont know where you thought i made a mistake" or i dunoo anything of tht sort, i would agree with you but the gurl just said SHE DIDN'T KNOW where had the mistake been commited...so from my point of view the discussion is sorta baseless!~