5th Round - Judges vs Judges - Page 3

Originally posted by: kothra

Goooo shahrukh fan
Make Alisha win this time😃

am trying lets see what happens😛

Originally posted by: srk_lover

goooo alishaa!! 👏 👏 👏

asma dont worry....ill be cheering every team periodically 😉

thank you megs😃

Originally posted by: the_charm

the performances are not poor at all.......im not saying they r perfect but they r not at a poor scale too....they are at a competing level... but thats not he point.......i but being harsh wont let them do great......yes they need to know their mistakes but they should not be taunted.

criticizing by sweet talking doesnt help all the time. there are certain contestants who are below average and they are building castles high in the air about being indian idol. having dreams is not bad but what is bad is when it really gets into their heads and they are not even trying to listen to us, then this is where they need a reality check. you have seen one of the contestants, that pseudo superman himesh guy who came for auditions, we are trying to tell him you are not good, but woh chala hi jaa raha hai, and its because of criticizing by sweet talking, ke aap sub ko topi pehna gaya aur hum log ke saamne se woh ticket lekar chala gaya. uski baat chodo, there is this guy who claimed that he had worked with me and he didnt even look appropriate for indian idol, his tune was not in sync, humarey lakh mana karne ke bewajood bhi woh gaye jaaraha hai gaye jaaraha hai, aisey logo ko inki asliyat dikhani chahiye, and that truck guy, mein maanta houn ke woh humble person tha, but he was not good for singing, all i did was tell him what his singing was good for, he can sing while driving truck but cannot sing for indian idol. this is a cut throat competition and we need to be real with them. if i dont criticize them then half of the contestants who had come for auditions would have never even left the venue and would be harping on giving them one chance again and again. if you tell these contestants their mistakes, they would not put as much effort that they would have otherwise put if they were criticized harshly. again i will say this is a professional platform, you should be ready to take every thing that includes good or bad that comes your way

Originally posted by: shahrukh fan

am answering the point that's highlighted in blue....... if you do sumthing for the first time and somebodybe it your parents,teacher or friendscritisize it by saying it's crap etc etc it's awful and it hurts i agree.......

i'll give you another egwhen i strated cooking for the first time my mum used tell me of nicelyabout where i went wrong but when i was still making the same mistake i used to get a right telling off by her and she used to say stuff like "look at girls in your age they know how to make this and they do it without there mothers help"etc etc....and trust me them comments really hepled me, know whenever i cook i give my 110%.....so basically how long can you say to some one nicely that you need improving.....even my driving instructor used to shout at me to get best out of me😛

hope it all makes sense😳

so you see the point alisha ji, with the taunts you got you are a good cook now 😳

Originally posted by: raunaq

so you see the point alisha ji, with the taunts you got you are a good cook now 😳

exactley....if we the judges are not gona be firm with them how will they improve then....anuji please mujey ek aur chance du na apni kissi film main gaaney ka😳😆

😕 😕 😕 where is everyone 😕 😕 😕

Originally posted by: shahrukh fan

i dont know who tauntd who....i don't remeber seeing any thing like that 😕.......Seriously some contestant need critizim......do you guys remeber rahul Vaidya (sorry dont know how to spell his surname) in II1 he was such a good singer but his attitude was awful and when sonu and rest of the judges told him about his attitude he was one of the 3rd finalists....so judges beig harsh does help the contestants big time😃

The judges used to taunt a lot during the audition round......even to some exceptional contestants......but anyways we are not discussing whether judges did criticize or not..........we are talking about whether criticism is good or bad..... im not uptodate with II1.........but i from what u wrote, i wanna say just check my first post im not saying they should not be told.........i am saying they should be told but not CRITICIZED.

Originally posted by: raunaq

javed saab mein bilkul aap ke is baat se bilkul sehmat nahi houn, hum idhar maata pita nahi banne aayein hain, we are the judges here, who have seen the real world, har maa baap apne bacche ki drawing zaroor pasand karega aur galatiya bhi bade pyar se nikalega ke kaafi waqt lag jayega woh galtiya sudharne mein, but this is a dog eat dog world, in the real market no one will tell these contestants ke beta apney is sur pe dhayan do, apne is galati pe dhayan ya apna yeh theek karo aur phir kal aana, it doesnt happen like that in the real world. maa baap, guru ka kaam hai train karna, the job of the contestant is to make himself/herself ready to face the struggles. this is a one time opportunity game and if the contestants dont know how to sell themselves with their talents then too bad for them. this is a professional platform where they should be mentally prepared to face criticism because they also have to present themselves professionally. when a movie is made, the director either receives a good comment or harsh/bad comments, he never receives comments like director saab try to make a good movie and then come back. when a certain product comes out in the market, they either receive bad comments which also includes taunts from customers or good comments, there is no excuse that this product should be made this way and then bring it back again and we will assay it again. its either yes or no. these contestants are like ready made products, our job is to pick holes in them and tell them whats their flaws. if that contestants has the spunk to stand upto what i said and has the wits to reverse criticism, then he is the winner

im not saying we are parents😆........you mean if you point out the mistakes sweetly it would take long time to correct it............and if you say it harshly they would correct it quickly......but theres no point......suppose one II contestant is told tht he is gud but this n this needs to be improved so tht he can do his best......wont he work on his flaws?......but if he is told he was rubbish he had no sur nothing thn he wud spend most of his time being depressed......and thts the fact which we have already witnessed in II many times...........and yes you are right...........thts the world today people wither say good or bad.......they never say to improve..........and for tht they may loose someone or something tht has the poteintiality to improve.

great topic 😛

I think it is very important for the judges to criticize the contestants so only then they would be able to find out what is it that they need to work on! Also, most of the time critisizing makes contestants want to work harder to impress the judges and the audience in the future! It is the critisizing that helps the contestants in figuring what is their performance lacking.