5th Round - Judges vs Judges - Page 5

Originally posted by: shahrukh fan

well like i said earlier NO PAIN NO GAIN!!!!!!!

criticism is part of the game honey.....no fame comes without criticism........life does not give chances again and again.....all am trying to say is if you love to hear praises you have to have courage to hear the criticim aswell..... 😳😃 all these big stars hate getting criticized but they only give there BEST when they actually do get criticized.....so criticism does help as i said before 😳😉

ooohooo !!! At last I finished reading all the pages .....sorry raunaqwa , I couldn't come to cheer u ...

Lekin 😉I had faith in u ki u won't need cheer leader and I was right !!! kya jabardast jawab de rahi ho !!!! In a true Anu Fashion 😉...

U rock !!!!!! mindblowing ..awesome ..mazaa aagaya ... 😛

keep it up circuitwa !!!!!!!! 👏..

Originally posted by: Chief Saab

great topic 😛

I think it is very important for the judges to criticize the contestants so only then they would be able to find out what is it that they need to work on! Also, most of the time critisizing makes contestants want to work harder to impress the judges and the audience in the future! It is the critisizing that helps the contestants in figuring what is their performance lacking.

P.S: We think we are supposed to debate and three of u agree on each and every point.....so its more like 2 team, one with three members and other with 1 member😕

sorry the charm but am sorry i really do belive critisam helps big time... i know it seems unfair that you feel like that but am really sorry.......its funny that am in Alisha's team and you in Javed's team because in reality Javed criticizes more than Alisha😆

Originally posted by: the_charm

I agree criticism is a part of the game but as long as it can be taken......and not more than that......and thts what am saying.....criticism can help the contestants only if its within the limit and it wont help them if its too much rather it would discourage them. So criticism is good upto a level.

Originally posted by: the_charm

my mother always does that to me.......but it never works.....i say her i wont do any work until you stop telling this n that.

Originally posted by: raunaq

since you gave the examples of parents, therefore i also tried to contradict your opinion using the example you gave to make you understand clearly. however, a good guru will always be harsh to his contestants because he wants the contestants to emerge as flawless. i hope you get the point. the debate is about being critical or encouraging and since you agree on being critical then i think the question of being harsh or not shouldnt come in between. however if you insist that harsh criticism can depress the contestants, then they should go back home and cry behind the curtains, this platform is not for them. a harsh critique knows when and what flaws should be pointed out. harsh tone is just a reminder for them that they have to do better efficiently. aap ko kya lagta hai mujhe yeh sub karte huey acha lagta hai, ya is sey mujhe shaanti milti hai? nahi, i would like them to see how the professional world is at a young age, yeh jo dukhi aur roney ke jo excuses hain woh yehan nahi chalega, they need to learn how to tackle ups and downs which also includes harsh criticisms

Originally posted by: raunaq

aap dono meri baat se sehmat hain. yeh to khushi ki baat hai, javed saab aap ne to aaj khud hi keh diya ke criticism ko challenge ki tarah lena chahiye aur dikha dena chahiye logo ko, ab criticism harsh ho ya na ho, baat to ek hi hai na, agar in contestants me dum hai aur taakat hai challenge lene ki to criticism kaisa bhi ho, woh unko apni spirit mein lenge aur ainda improve karne ki koshish karenge

Raunaqwa, Kahan tak pahuncha? Ee lo ham aayi gava hain chai lekar aapke liye.