Judges .....Dont blame the audience - Page 4

Originally posted by: Khushi11

Ok Remo looks cute to sum people thats y they vote for him but why Kuldeep? I dont think he is that good of a singer, nor is he handsome, or doesnt even have the x factor.. so sad stories or anything like that... then why is janta voting for him?

Who says junta voting for him..In most of these shows, only people from their region vote maximum. Rest all people vote but very few in number

Thank to everyone for your replies....whether you agreed with me or not.

Show is not about choosing the best singer..its about making more and more money which is not possible if public voting is discouraged

YEP, producers dont care who wins, as long as they make money. so forget about allowing judges to choose bottom 4 and then allow public to save 3 of them. its all about business and sucessful business means maximum profit, i-e maximum votes 😃

Originally posted by: zunairryk

YEP, producers dont care who wins, as long as they make money. so forget about allowing judges to choose bottom 4 and then allow public to save 3 of them. its all about business and sucessful business means maximum profit, i-e maximum votes 😃

Well, I personally think that what's wrong is wrong, whether its the judges who are at fault, or the audience. That doesn't change anything.
If Mohit is constantly being given votes --- the judges are at fault for promoting him. Why is the public listening to the judges?
When Remu is given horrendous comments --- the judges are right. But why isn't the audience listening to the judges then?

The bottom line is that voting is done purely on a regional basis. And that is wrong. Also, female contestants are given less votes ... that's also wrong. The format of the show cannot be changed. But the judges should be more convincing and lead the votes in the right path. Both parties are at fault here, the only problem is that there is no solution to fix these issues.

I guess that's what happens when you force a foreign format on the Indian audience and Indian judges. India had been used to the traditional format where judges chose the winner and we had winners like Shreya Ghoshal. Then all of the sudden II started this trend of public voting and now we have winners like Sandeep Acharya and Prashant Tamang.

Originally posted by: shehzaadi91

I guess that's what happens when you force a foreign format on the Indian audience and Indian judges. India had been used to the traditional format where judges chose the winner and we had winners like Shreya Ghoshal. Then all of the sudden II started this trend of public voting and now we have winners like Sandeep Acharya and Prashant Tamang.

Originally posted by: sumanforums

Thank to everyone for your replies....whether you agreed with me or not.

Also i think the more the judges scream foul the more the audience will be determined to vote for their favourites. And 1 more point that is Sonali said the audience always like "becahre se log". In her frustration she did not realise (or did she) that she was directly insulting kapil, kuldeep, remo for being the "bechare se log".

Did she bring them in just to insult them this way. If she had liked their singing enough to get them in, why doesnt she respect the judges' choice.

Originally posted by: mintyblue

SHE IS RIGHT. THEY ARE CRAP SINGERS😆

in fact the boys are all crap insgers- except rajdeep/prosenjit. But its these 2 who land up in danger zone- what shame. and befoe you say vote etc. I did- i vote for all 4 prasenjit,bhavya,torsha,rajdeep eevry week- they are the best😃