Indira in very complicated situation now. - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

64

Views

6.3k

Users

18

Likes

108

Frequent Posters

designersaini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21
if we go wid d legal issues den i dont think husna is married to kabir coz he is still married to noor who is alive 9t seperated frm him n also kabir hasnot divorced her.i dont 9 about pak laws but in hindus bigamy is 9t allowed.so dat means husna n kabir were having extramartial affair.
Indira is also 9t d legal wife f rishi due to dat 7 years gap.so husna/indira at present situation is neither d legal wife f kabir nor f rishi.
But as all d legal issues n logic never had n will never hav any relation wid HD so cant say anything.everything will only gt cleared when indira will gain her full memory.
Edited by designersaini - 12 years ago
Badala thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Walden

@bold: I'm trying to keep my sarcasm in check 😊. Yes I believe that one can love two people at the same time- in the sense that you fell in love with these poeple at different times...didn't fall out of love with the first one but they were taken away from you (thru death or memory loss)...but due to various circumstances (death of first spouse or memory loss- doesen't matter) decided to move on with someone else...and now are confronted with having both those people in your lives. But some believe that this cannot happen. You can only love one at any particular time. So if I follow this logic, it will be easy for Indira to choose...she'll just choose the one and only one she loves currently forgetting anything and eveything that happened with the other one.
@bold 2: Yeah, I completely agree (unless Rishi also develops some kind of a mental illness all of a sudden or if Kabir turns negative all of a sudden- never underestimate the writers of this show)

@blue: 😆 I just could not catch your sarcasm. You have been so forthright about all your comments that it just didn't strike me. 😆

@pink: I so don't want that🤢 I am not a big Sumit fan, I don't want to see him portraying variety of roles. I just like Rishi and want a smooth life for him. But that's not gonna happen , I think
kiran_rati thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
i really dont think that baby is indiras
and saheb is indira's husband
i believe in inshi
i believe more rati di than CV
samrudhi.r thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: designersaini

if we go wid d legal issues den i dont think husna is married to kabir coz he is still married to noor who is alive 9t seperated frm him n also kabir hasnot divorced her.i dont 9 about pak laws but in hindus bigamy is 9t allowed.so dat means husna n kabir were having extramartial affair.
Indira is also 9t d legal wife f rishi due to dat 7 years gap.so husna/indira at present situation is neither d legal wife f kabir nor f rishi.
But as all d legal issues n logic never had n will never hav any relation wid HD so cant say anything.everything will only gt cleared when indira will gain her full memory.


Hindu law doesnt allow bigamy in India, but muslim law in India allows that. Not just in India, every where muslims are allowed that i guess.

But since Indira is an Indian Hindu, and if she had married Saheb even if it is 4-5 yrs ago (Babli is definitely older than that), according to our law she is wife to Rishi at that time. So if u take in legal POV, Indira's marriage to Saheb would not be valid acc to Indian law.

PS: I have no degree in LLB.😃
nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Walden

Ashish, regarding choosing between Rishi and Kabir, you are assuming that she loves both!!! One from her distant past and one from her present/remote past- I thought it was not possible to love two people at the same time Anyway, I think the choice is pretty clear...she has to chose Kabir. It will be a difficult decision. I supported Rishi when he chose Zara (his present), so I'll do the same here. It will be easier for Indira though because once she chooses, she can clearly move on..as opposed to Rishi who had to continue caring for his past and carry both the present and the past simultaneously.

Regarding the kiddos, I hope they both get what they want. It may not be perfect, but sometimes its just enough to know that there is a mother figure out there who loves you.

Brutus you too!!!
why you want indira to stay in pakistan? will she get the same freedom which she use to get in India . will she have easy going there in presence of Noor?
let her be here in cc with rishi.
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: nutan7

Brutus you too!!!
why you want indira to stay in pakistan? will she get the same freedom which she use to get in India . will she have easy going there in presence of Noor?
let her be here in cc with rishi.

@bold 🤣
Let me clarify my position...If Indira/Husna decided to have a relationship with Kabir (even after knowing that he was married to Noor), then she should follow-thru with that emotion and decision even after her memory comes back. Her memory, or lack thereof, does not and should not diminish the feelings she had for Kabir. Just because she had no memory of Rishi at that point does not, in my books, nullify the emotions she felt for Kabir. Don't know if that makes any sense!
About living in Pakistan or India...I would argue that Indira had little freedom (or didn't allow herself the freedom at times) to live her life even when she lived in CC all those years. Kinda ironic right!
Ranjinikishan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
so dia wants indira to go to pak & live with saheb happily everafter & rishi in delhi alone crying & crying..such a stone hearted u people are😒
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Ranjinikishan

so dia wants indira to go to pak & live with saheb happily everafter & rishi in delhi alone crying & crying..such a stone hearted u people are😒

Oh Rajini, you misunderstand me. Ok let's pretend that while Indira was dead, Rishi had fallen in love with someone else (not a Indira lookalike like Zara, just someone else- lets call her Sahiba😆). And then Indira comes back into his life. Well, if it was me, I would want Rishi to continue his relationship with Sahiba. So if I flip the characters and their positions, I would say the same for Indira.
And this is my major major problem with this show. It assumes that if people don't get something they want in life or if life doesen't turn out exactly like they wanted, their only option is to get sad and dukhi. Why should Rishi be sad? Okay he may be sad for a little bit, but this is why I loved his character to start out with...he always had the ability to bounce back! And I hate the writers for taking this away from his character 😡
Ranjinikishan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
akele mein kya bounce back😡..not liking your opinion..i dont want rishi to be alone all his life..kuch toh positive hona chahiye yaar..
ashish.sachi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Ranjinikishan

akele mein kya bounce back😡..not liking your opinion..i dont want rishi to be alone all his life..kuch toh positive hona chahiye yaar..


Nahin milegi Rishi ko Indira kabhi bhi ( well at least HD ke last Episode tak😆😆😆)

Rishi ki Ma Simi ne curse kiya tha usey ," jis ladki ke liye tu apni Ma ko chhod raha hai , wo tujhe kabhi nahin milegi" , aur Ma ka curse toh definitely lagta hai.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".