Are these the same writers? Same creatives? - Page 5

Originally posted by: surithy

Today instead of her walking before him if she walked along with him the total episode would have made a huge difference. It would have signified her wanting to spend time whatever she could. Even the expressions of Gulaal didn't connect today. I would say ESPECIALLY Gulaal's expressions didn't connect...and her being the central character, not some sidey like PB...the expressions being disconnected jars more.

I don't think Kesar leaving or asking the shoe ceremony for Raman is out of character. He was never connected to his family, he was away and no one in that family ever tried to neither connect nor understand him even after his return. He was never interested in the village people or the position of Sarpanch. He was always treated as the youngest and he accepted it with grace that is why he mentioned Raman. I didn't feel that he thought about leaving beforehand but that was spontaneous maybe when he feared that his family might pressure Gulaal for his sake. He was on his way somewhere when MB stopped him to talk about their desire. Like Jezz said bravo to him for not being the charity case. Yes, it does almost feel as if Kesar's decision to leave was taken on the spot when he saw how desperate the family was to bring Gulaal back through any means even if they had to resort to emotional blackmail...they hit a new low today...Kesar was the only one talking sense there..

MB-wanting to beg Gulaal???????????? Yeah that was seriously W*F-ish😕😕

Originally posted by: nneeiill

Now that i watched the epi again
it dint felt that bad..
but i feel real bad for CV's

KG love story was the main plot and they dint get proper time to showcase it...

SP screwed it up like totally...

Originally posted by: nureat01

Nitya, you watched the epi twice?? I toh can't bring myself to...and kahaan there was a time when I was watching each epi almost 3 times a day while taking caps and stuff too *sigh* Guess those days are long gone now.

Originally posted by: nneeiill

Actually I could not watch kesar n MB scene..and the last part..
Morning i just watched till Talli scene

Originally posted by: JZephyr

Nur - you just HAVE to see that MB looking over at Kesar with his tuntuna moment - its brief and quick - but both actors at their best... it was THE touching moment of the day, for me!

And yeh - Kesar's been hubby to her forever... but what I meant was in a time period where Gulaal was sort of opening up to his being in that place... Undeniably gives a miss to some brilliant old scenes for a FB... I mean remember that confrontation when Kesar told her she will stifling the woman inside... or perhaps that scene where Kesar tells her she would have to love him back to stay in the house forever... or even the time Gulaal is trying to protest with Kesar and say she should move away from him so she doesn't harm him and he says every happiness in his life is because of her... or most importantly perhaps - she could have FBs from when Kesar breaks the wedding with Talli... those were some incredible 'husband in realization' dialogs from Kesar, and his consequent confession in the rain ofc... phew - yes, there is LOTS to show in FBs... but I think they're limiting it to the time Gulaal finally, with whatever resignation, sort of let Kesar step into her inner most circle, and the life they spent as a 'couple' (minus paap and chiii lol) then... because that is the phase recalling which Gulaal's realization should touch its peak, of how easy it really was letting him in, once she let go of her resistance, and how right it had seemed, despite whatever notions she had previously held... and how for that brief phase - even without her 'reciprocating love' in a sense, and at her darkest phase in general, she had managed to feel so light hearted, and found semblance of deep peace!

Arshi said somewhere - and I agree a 100% with her, that it would really really help if we saw things through Gulaal now for a while, and not look at Gulaal and/or Kesar through others... like when she comes back to the haveli - we see Gulaal through the family - if only we'd seen the house, celebration, family, AND kesar through Gulaal, it would have made one hell of a difference to the same damn scenes! It would help connect those FBs she was having, with her running state of mind... much much better...