)I wanna know ur thots on this and grasp why you think so. Let's ve an adult discourse. MSK is Geet ki Maan. There is no doubt about it. But, he has a past just like Geet. Sameera, who per him and Daadi betrayed him. So, could he also be a "bin bhihaye papa"
(an unmarried dad!). I am not saying that he's a cad. But, he does appear to have some moves. He must ve learnt them somewhere😉😆 Maybe from Sammy Aunty?
Now before u beat me up for defiling Dusht Dhanav's character - I don't think whether he is or not "innocent" in anyway undermines the anjaani ehsaas he feels to the depths of his soul for Geet, who is his destiny.
Edit:
After reading the comments so far - here is the Case for Innocent v. Experienced.
Now lemme understand the case for Innocent:
1. Uncle Google
2. Anjaani ehsaas he's only experienced with Geet
3. He's never bought a girl flowers (Sin's counter to this is golddiggers prefer jewelry!)
4. Aunty National Geographic
5. Naturally Gifted
6. Innately respectful of women
Counter-Case:
1. He knows his moves
2. He knows what reactions to look out for in response to his moves
3. He is so "despo" becoz he's done it b4🤣🤣
4. The eyes scream "experience"
5. Vintage (age - unlikely he's untouched at this age)
6. Sameera could hv bumped him b4 she dumped him
7. He's tooo confindent in his moves
8. He knows too much about removing women's jewelry & dressage
If u r not offended then "hit" lyk and join the discussion. Don't let the bakers and zoology talk deter u
Edit Further:
Best Answer so far about Sammy ka Possible Impact:
Is by An12345689 on p 27:
"Mother abandoned him and his father after shedding tons of glycerin. Dadi Ma selects a girl for Mann and that girl makes him feel important by doing things for him (sending flowers and etc.) tells to trust again ... but she has another plan and when he starts dreaming about a future with her (mind you not love but going with the flow of things) ... the smart lady ditches him and vanishes with a considerable amount. He is devastated and shuts the door completely. He hates playfulness as well as tears of women."
EDIT - Updated Again from p. 108!:
@All - holly crap! U all still yapping about Maan's manily quotient🤣 with 75% convinced he's Xperienced n 25% screaming innocent😆😆I am particularly amazed at the Forum Voter turnout! Nearly 70-80% of the forum has voted😃 (Over 240 pple😲)
Well u will be happy to know I made CVs aware of this little debate u all ve been having😉 Afta reading it they may juss go "Sam WHO?!"🤣
**********
My Opinion:
I voted Not Innocent, but for the most part did not participate in the debate as i did not want to influence the discourse. I will now briefly state my opinion here:
Geet is like mirror. MSK is a complex jigsaw puzzle. They r both principled people but, flawed not perfect. Maan has not forgotten Sameera nor the lessons she taught him. She most likely deepened his childhood scars. There is a reason for his distrust of women, which was there even in HP! Daadi taught him to respect women and he does, but his level of disdain for them was aparrent to all including Geet from day 1. That much angst only comes from serious multiple mental fracture. Not an invention of Vincent's but, something pre-existent!
The Geet Team just keep delaying her entry, but she has been thought about. 74% of IF janta think he's experienced - more if we include the maybe crowd...there perception is not entirely baseless given MSK's confident debonair air! He does not hesistate wit Geet...and he knows his own potency. Even worries he maybe losing =)) wen Geet tell's him his impacts gone!
Now de real issue is Vishwaas n Bharosa, na?! Y has he not told Geet the truth about Sameera? Conversely, has he hidden it? To my mind? No! He feels that Geet is solely his! And he has wholly given himself to Geet on a spirtual & emotional love level. During the pyaar ka ghar sequence he admitted he did not know wat "love" was and only Geet cud teach him. He her willing student. But, that does not make his past inexistent! She empowers him to move beyond the past and that is xactly wat he told Dev on sagaai night. Geet's past to him does not matter neither from his perspective does his own! They per him had both moved beyond their pasts n were engaged in present n future. Once he realized Geet was wholly his, her past became irrelevant except 4 de fact that someone hurt her n she deserves justice. Likewise sameera is irrelevant to their relationship. There is no "truth" that needs telling here. Geet felt she had a truth to tell! Y? Becoz her past impacts the future in de form of baby! Msk's samaan is in the attic vis a vis Geet is carrying hers. Geet's 2nd truth also needed telling becoz it effects the present... She wants justice in the present and wud ve had to share a house wit that creepo Dev otherwise.
The day Sameera moves outta of the attic into the present... If that day MSK hides the truth from Geet then to my mind they will destroy his character! Till then she is irrelevant! He's not hung up unlike most mcp's on geet's physical experience so, we shud not penalize him 4 his Xperience!
This is my opinion. You are all welcome to disagree.
Edited by AnjanaToronto - 15 years ago
27