Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.3k

Users

14

Likes

127

Frequent Posters

bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
agree with u fully
i have left seeing the show
punnubaby thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: imli123

There is a limit to everything. I was not going to write anything, but now I just have to. I
need to vent out my frustration on this terrible track. Yes terrible,
disgusting track that completely defamed the characters. And this is coming
from someone that defended the Antara-Satya marriage in the beginning. I
supported the writers and their vision but I just can't anymore because of what
that they delivered. I know some people are saying that what occurred between
Antara and Satya is not marriage, but yes it is. I'm Muslim but I still know
that saath peeres do have a lot of importance in Hindu culture. What they did
is just make a mockery out of it. If Antara is publicly announcing that Satya
is my husband, then why on Earth is there even a debate. I cannot justify her
actions at all. She claimed that she was "ajj ki zamane ki majboor larki" who
can take care of herself and her family, but her actions speak different. She proved
to be another rash, stupid heroine. What angers me the most is that by marrying
that psycho she not only disrespected her love, but more importantly
disrespected herself. She knows that Satya is not worthy of her or anyone else
yet she still let all of this transpire. She didn't even take a day to think
things through and plan out her next move, which people in real life do. And
Raghu--I can't justify him either. He was molded as a very strong character
initially, but has gradually become so weak. Telling her the truth before the
wedding would have been more true to his character. He should have followed his
heart and instincts. He should have had more faith in their love. I was
surprised that he became Devdas so quickly and didn't even go and look for her.
Antara and Raghu are both equally at fault. And Satya"well what can I say about
him. Quite impressed actually, he did get what he wanted. I don't see his fault
here...he didn't win, Rantara's love failed.


I don't mean to hurt anyone's sentiments, but this is just my take on this track. Sorry in advance if anyone doesn't like what I said.




Bang on!! Satya din win,Rantara love failed,u actualy nailed it at this!!

N yes they hv made a mockery of weddin!! N this ws least expected frm Antara!!


Dreamygal301 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#13
Hi Imli,😊

Yes Rantara love failed. They failed to trust each other, stand by each other and broken all promises made.

But now the real love story will start and it will be rock solid.

Antara needed to go through this. Have you forgotten she found out Raghu 'killed' her father? are you saying even after learning a fact like that you would go running to your lover and want to be with him for all life? No, she behaved as any child would do, one who loved their parent anyway.

Their love wasn't strong to withstand this storm. They both got weak and sidetracked. But the writing has been in the wall that it would be like this. They fell in love too fast, were insecure quite a lot and rash behaviour as always been part of their core, often led by their temper and emotions.

Consider this track a cooling off period on both side. Slowly, like layers of onion, they will start seeing through the smoke and lies. Both will repent, cry and have boatload of regret. Then they will fall back in love and be so strong that nothing can break it.

Coming to Satya, he has been clever. Antu had never ever seen his bad side at all. Yep not even the cliff side, because he declared his feelings and whatever that followed could be considered the angry words of a rejected suitor.

Now she will truly see the dark side of Satya. Then she will realise that in loving Raghu she had been RIGHT not WRONG (as she is feeling now because she feels she had betrayed her father).

It is a crappy track, one fond of by indian writers because of the so called trend. If you want to blame anyone, blame the viewers who's demand produced these tracks over and over again. I personally would have ensured both Raghu and Antu were locked up in a room and had a long, long argument, shouting match, screaming and then outpouring of grief.

In fact this is the scenario I thought it would go through, after she finds out during the wedding. I thought either Raghu or Antu would drag the other way and hast it out. I thought perhaps the scene would last for a week, at the end she would say 'I can't be with my father's kliller' (don't forget she loved her father so has to say something like this) and then goes with Raghu running after her. Really it would make sense for him to try to win her again while finding out the truth and Satya off course trying to add more petrol to the flame between them. I did get upset when this track was confirmed but now have decided that no matter what Rantara love will prevail - you just need to see it in a different way now.

Even today, while getting married her heart and mind was with Raghu. And this is the way it will be. I guess what we need to take from this is if CVs can play with marriage then so should we. We should disregard what it means and just concentrate on Rantara,
Edited by Dreamygal301 - 11 years ago
Lovenarbhi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
kya kare yaar, ye log ek lovely story and a lovely couple ko satyanash karne mai thuli hue hai, gosh how i wish they would brought in some other twisttt
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Dreamygal301

Hi Imli,😊


Yes Rantara love failed. They failed to trust each other, stand by each other and broken all promises made.

But now the real love story will start and it will be rock solid. And I have waited for this love story to start. The conflict in this saga is just so unbelievable how do you love a man who was involved in the death of your father?

Antara needed to go through this. Have you forgotten she found out Raghu 'killed' her father? are you saying even after learning a fact like that you would go running to your lover and want to be with him for all life? No, she behaved as any child would do, one who loved their parent anyway.
We are all well aware of her relationship with her father , he was her God and her whole like is based on his ideals so how can she not be angry at a man who killed all that. The daughter , like it should be is roaring for justice.

Their love wasn't strong to withstand this storm. They both got weak and sidetracked. But the writing has been in the wall that it would be like this. They fell in love too fast, were insecure quite a lot and rash behaviour as always been part of their core, often led by their temper and emotions.
There relationship till now has lacked depth, you had the typical love-hate relationship and somewhere they did found each other , kindred souls with common loss. The fact that Antara was fatherless, drew initial reactions in Raghu. But they never could confine in each other freely, he never clearly opened up about Satya or even family dynamics. You saw them too eager for their new found happiness.

Consider this track a cooling off period on both side. Slowly, like layers of onion, they will start seeing through the smoke and lies. Both will repent, cry and have boatload of regret. Then they will fall back in love and be so strong that nothing can break it.
Exactly right now if you notice her hate and his tears all are for each other. This is the biggest conflict in their life and whatever love story that will be born out of this is going to be epic. There will be a fresh start to their love.

Coming to Satya, he has been clever. Antu had never ever seen his bad side at all. Yep not even the cliff side, because he declared his feelings and whatever that followed could be considered the angry words of a rejected suitor.

Now she will truly see the dark side of Satya. Then she will realise that in loving Raghu she had been RIGHT not WRONG (as she is feeling now because she feels she had betrayed her father).

Till this point she is blindly walking on the path of revenge using Satya , what she is unaware of is how he will turn against her. I suspect he might emotionally abuse her to a point which will make her realize the true magnitude of her step. She will cry and that is important for Raghu to react. Because else he is going to remain distant as he will be under immense guilt.

It is a crappy track, one fond of by indian writers because of the so called trend. If you want to blame anyone, blame the viewers who's demand produced these tracks over and over again. I personally would have ensured both Raghu and Antu were locked up in a room and had a long, long argument, shouting match, screaming and then outpouring of grief.
Practically the situation needed a wise elder, unfortunately these two have been forced to be the leaders so they resort to settle the things in the most childish manner. Whatever might be the situation I doubt and can say Antara would have walked off Raghu . Marriage and revenge could have been avoided but guess they need to give an epic send-off , otherwise his character would be a liability.

In fact this is the scenario I thought it would go through, after she finds out during the wedding. I thought either Raghu or Antu would drag the other way and hast it out. I thought perhaps the scene would last for a week, at the end she would say 'I can't be with my father's kliller' (don't forget she loved her father so has to say something like this) and then goes with Raghu running after her. Really it would make sense for him to try to win her again while finding out the truth and Satya off course trying to add more petrol to the flame between them. I did get upset when this track was confirmed but now have decided that no matter what Rantara love will prevail - you just need to see it in a different way now.
I too hoped for it but then I thought , what can Raghu do to win her love? His action needs to be of a larger-than-life proportion to compensate for her loss and pain. It would have been totally out of character for Antara to not be impulsive. I would have happily taken a revenge track void of marriage but well they have to round DM in this tale somehow.

Even today, while getting married her heart and mind was with Raghu. And this is the way it will be. I guess what we need to take from this is if CVs can play with marriage then so should we. We should disregard what it means and just concentrate on Rantara,
I think we should be excited to see a mature take on their love story for a while and enjoy the evolution of the real RaghuNath Naik., the one uninfluenced by DM and protective of Antara.


DG- You worded it all so beautifully!
Aisha15 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
Hey Dreamygal 😊
I would never expect Antara to run back to Raghu after finding out that he is responsible for her father's death. I too am a daddy's girl, and trust me that is far from something I would do. But what about Satya pushing her mother? I know it's not as big of a crime, but I wouldn't marry someone that disrespects my mom like that either. Furthermore, she knows this guy is legit crazy but she still compromised with him. So I don't agree with her decision AT ALL.

And you are right...these tracks occur because viewers allow them to by watching it. The Indian audience needs to become more mature in that sense. I for one won't be watching it though (doesn't matter because it won't affect TRPs).

charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: imli123

Hey Dreamygal 😊

I would never expect Antara to run back to Raghu after finding out that he is responsible for her father's death. I too am a daddy's girl, and trust me that is far from something I would do. But what about Satya pushing her mother? I know it's not as big of a crime, but I wouldn't marry someone that disrespects my mom like that either. Furthermore, she knows this guy is legit crazy but she still compromised with him. So I don't agree with her decision AT ALL.

imli , I think DG also not endorses her action. What we are saying is that she is right now too blinded by her grief and loss that nothing is making sense to her. There is no anchor in her life, after her father. And Raghu who guided her for some time, is the culprit here. She is alone , angry and hurt beyond we can ever imagine. She has taken a very impulsive and rash decision. With time when she will see the true impact of her action and Satya's tortures start troubling her , then she will slowly regret it . But I am damn sure , she will continue to let the blame be on Raghu. Thats her coping mechanism , lets hope someone helps her before she suffer more.

And you are right...these tracks occur because viewers allow them to by watching it. The Indian audience needs to become more mature in that sense. I for one won't be watching it though (doesn't matter because it won't affect TRPs).

Edited by charminggenie - 11 years ago
Dreamygal301 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: imli123

Hey Dreamygal 😊

I would never expect Antara to run back to Raghu after finding out that he is responsible for her father's death. I too am a daddy's girl, and trust me that is far from something I would do. But what about Satya pushing her mother? I know it's not as big of a crime, but I wouldn't marry someone that disrespects my mom like that either. Furthermore, she knows this guy is legit crazy but she still compromised with him. So I don't agree with her decision AT ALL.

And you are right...these tracks occur because viewers allow them to by watching it. The Indian audience needs to become more mature in that sense. I for one won't be watching it though (doesn't matter because it won't affect TRPs).


Hi Imli,😊

Charming G said what I would have said.😊 Definitely do not endorse Satya's behaviour. I don't hate him because I never put that kind of emotion in anything make believe. But I do hope some of her goodness rubs off in him. It is interesting that both Rukku and Satya love another who is already committed elsewhere but they both behave very differently in how they cope with it. I think this is intentional on the CVs part to show people's nature dictates their behaviour.

Antu just isn't in her right mind at the moment. As girls we should understand, our very own genes work against us because we are hormone riddled beings!😉

She is too blinded to even think of anything beyond her own hurt and anger let alone think of Satya's every action. You may not like me saying this but I guarantee that at that moment when he appeared in front of her, Satya was looking like her only friend, someone who 'understands's her. So wait for the track where cool logic starts resurfacing again.
Edited by Dreamygal301 - 11 years ago
kaurhs thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19
Great points everyone. Just my assumption that so many changes in the track, in fact even picturization of the scenes have gone blah...all this could mean that ph/cvs might be shutting it down. Feeding crap to the audience so viewers eventually stop watching the show and they know by ruining Rantara's characters audience are definitely going to be mad and trp will suck, thus giving them reasons to shut down the serial. They all know audience can digest a lot of stupidity but if the characters of leads are BUTCHERED then audience will eventually let go and stop watching the show. And people have left and quit. Maybe that is what they want to pull the plug on ddej. Just my opinion.
nnks thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20
superb post yaar ..agree with ur each n every word...thanks for making this post😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".