I do not understand the point of the serial! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

59

Views

5.1k

Users

18

Likes

134

Frequent Posters

FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: _innocent_

sorry for such a late reply:)... my point is.. if a woman who was pregnant was subjected to so many physical assaults her baby would not survive! and thats is the reality of the situation:)



its ok..
thats true.. i have a feeling he will kill his own child.. i am scared with the promo when he wants a boy.. what if baby is a girl...
OMG... i can vagely predict whats gn happen..
bitting my nails
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Nkapoor2

Again relax! I just don't understand why people are making avatars of a couple in which a woman is battered!



i think both of you should relax...
its a drama.. enjoy it.. :D😃
672058 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: FIRESafiReFIRE



i think both of you should relax...
its a drama.. enjoy it.. :D😃

lol yeh I know, I get it, I was not trying to insult the show, just started watching it, and do not totally understand the point it is trying to make, but I have seemed to upset some hardcore fans! I just find it a lil unrealistic how the guy is escaping from all of the stuff he is doing..I dunno how to explain it...sometimes his change of behaviour...his humor, his wit, his cleverness leads me to believe how he could even be sick at all! and some weird instructions like you should only watch animal shows, what?? that is not typically realistic! at times it seems more like an horror show, that, where the assasin is very clever, that is why it does not look realistic at times! and the girl Jhanvi has no backbone, and I am also confused as to whether she still loves Viraaj or not, it is just weird! and the fact that he is like the 'hero' of the show makes it even more confusing! anyway I am a KarnVir fan and I am watching it, and am enjoying his acting! I am just saying that the show could have been more realistic in its portrayel!
Edited by Nkapoor2 - 13 years ago
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

i think both of you should relax...
its a drama.. enjoy it.. :D😃
lol yeh I know, I get it, I was not trying to insult the show, just started watching it, and do not totally understand the point it is trying to make, but I have seemed to upset some hardcore fans! I just find it a lil unrealistic how the guy is escaping from all of the stuff he is doing..I dunno how to explain it...sometimes his change of behaviour...his humor, his wit, his cleverness leads me to believe how he could even be sick at all! and the girl Jhanvi has no backbone, and I am also confused as to whether she still loves Viraaj or not, it is just weird! and the fact that he is like the 'hero' of the show makes it even more confusing! anyway I am a KarnVir fan and I am watching it, and am enjoying his acting!


lol... you sound so confusing to me... hehe😆
well ... far as i know.. its a dark story.. anti hero type wala.. have you ever read Shakespeare?.. he wrote some of superb one.. its amazing...

in this viraj is anti hero..
and its realstic.. i have done many case study.. and you will be surprised there are so many guys like him out there.. and annoying thing is.. there are people like janvi who does nothing at all.. hopes after hopes..

so it is realstic.. but the dark truth.. hope it answers...

and chile both you and rimimaan..
person like him will have everything... they know perfectly well how to camaflauge them :)
672058 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
^^yeh but some weird instructions like you should only watch animal shows, what?? that is not typically realistic! at times it seems more like an horror show, that, where the assasin is very clever, that is why it does not look realistic at times! I am just saying that the show could have been more realistic in its portrayel! and that is what I am saying I would see Sanjay's role in Khalnayak as an anti-hero, however a person who beats and rapes his wife so violently cannot be termed as an 'ant-hero' therefore do not understand the point of the show!
Edited by Nkapoor2 - 13 years ago
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Nkapoor2

^^yeh but some weird instructions like you should only watch animal shows, what?? that is not typically realistic! at times it seems more like an horror show, that, where the assasin is very clever, that is why it does not look realistic at times! I am just saying that the show could have been more realistic in its portrayel!



this is a hint how his mind, brain.. normal psycological thought is limited..
he have been in isolation so much... that this is normal to him whereas to us.. ITS weird..
this also gives us hint about his childhood.. in this case.. maybe when he was young someone told him to watch this type of stuff to get strong and that have been locked safely..

the whole point of this part was to show.. what a crazy and weird man he is
crazygod thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Nkapoor2

lol yeh I know, I get it, I was not trying to insult the show, just started watching it, and do not totally understand the point it is trying to make, but I have seemed to upset some hardcore fans! I just find it a lil unrealistic how the guy is escaping from all of the stuff he is doing..I dunno how to explain it...sometimes his change of behaviour...his humor, his wit, his cleverness leads me to believe how he could even be sick at all! and some weird instructions like you should only watch animal shows, what?? that is not typically realistic! at times it seems more like an horror show, that, where the assasin is very clever, that is why it does not look realistic at times! and the girl Jhanvi has no backbone, and I am also confused as to whether she still loves Viraaj or not, it is just weird! and the fact that he is like the 'hero' of the show makes it even more confusing! anyway I am a KarnVir fan and I am watching it, and am enjoying his acting! I am just saying that the show could have been more realistic in its portrayel!



Sorry to comment and add a post to this thread... Why you don't find it realistic ? a man locking his wife and daughters for 15 years in a house, not letting them interact with outer world? is that realistic? a man for sake of success in business sleeping with his daughter ? is that realistic ? is human body parts being mixed in hotel food as nothing is more addictive: is that realistic? parents killing their 14 year old daughter and servant in cold blood? is that realistic? a man at NOIDA feasting on human meat? is that realistic?

there are many such news which doesn't sound realistic to us, unless it comes one day in news; and we say shocking... But they are realities that are happening around us... I don't know how many marital abused women you know, and have studied what all kind of mental, physical, sexual abuse they have faced... So maybe it all might sound unrealistic to you... Women in domestic abuse live their whole life, with such abusers for various reasons... they look for hope, or are tied down by some compulsion... That is what this show in its first phase seems to be portraying, covering every aspect... and that every ray of hope that Jhanvi finds, meets with a failure...

So far as I understood, this show is not about reality, but a shocking reality. So at times we all may find it a bit unreal... As whenever a reality is fictionalized and packaged to deliver entertainment (entertainment doesn't mean just smiles and happiness, but anything that binds us to our sofa sets and watch it); it is bound to get overboard at times... This show is really packaged well... Had it been an ugly looking person, shot more grouchily, been more painful, how many of us would have been watching it... they made the narrative thriller to hook us... Such a dark content, and still the makers make us come back 7 days a week, and watch it, is indeed commendable... Its a very smartly packaged show...
Edited by crazygod - 13 years ago
-LOVE-Arshi- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 3 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Nkapoor2

^^yeh but some weird instructions like you should only watch animal shows,what?? that is not typically realistic! at timesit seems more like an horror show, that, where the assasin is very clever, that is why it does not look realistic at times!I am just saying that the show could have been more realistic in its portrayel! and that is what I am saying I would see Sanjay's role in Khalnayak as an anti-hero, however a person who beats and rapes his wife so violently cannot be termed as an 'ant-hero' therefore do not understand the point of the show!




I reply don't know how you don't find this show realistic!
Have you ever done normal basic psychology of human,
Or maybe try to understand a person?

I am not trying to be rude, but it seems like you have not walked out of your fairyland yet.
I know it's hard for you to understand maybe because of that, but I think you had enough explanation from various member!

If you don't like the show don't watch it.

I find your point unbelievable like you really not thinking or you don't want to think.
To me your point is unrealistic, even after all this explanation.
doyelpakhi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
@NKapoor2

Viraj is an anti-hero because he can do anything for Jahnvi - he can take her life if she defies him and at the same time he can give his own life for sake of Jahnvi.

If he would have only shown the first trait, he would have been only a villain, but his I-can-give-my-life attitude makes him the anti-hero.

The tortures shown in this serial is very much real - in fact there are hundreds of women who face such tortures - not only by the husbands but by the in-laws too. Most importantly, in those cases, husbands are not so mad about their wife ala Viraj that they can give their life for the wife's sake.

As far as rape scene is concerned - it looked horrifying to us more because of the fact that he has done it to punish Jahnvi - but marital rape is quiet common - may be all men don't rape their wives to punish but there are men who ignore whether the wife is ready to have physical intimacy or not - they just take it for granted that they have a right over their wives' body.


I am not biased against any gender but the truth is the characteristics of Viraj is present in many men - may be mild or subtle manner.

Men, due to the social conditioning, genetic factor etc. like to have control over a woman especially - when it's wife and daughter. Don't you see that even now men often make the major decisions of a household and it's women who make sacrifices like leaving a career, etc. etc.
ChurailMukhi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#30

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".